4 ms·

Yea, thank you for your feedback!

reaperman 2y ago
> “…which has the potential to do as much harm as good.” I find this is one of the more difficult things for people to learn to fully integrate into their psyche. Many people never learn to truly care about this and everything it means. They go on forever primarily caring about what’s good for them personally.
- paulcole 2y ago
  Strong disagree. Put yourself first nearly 100% of the time. Nobody cares about you so don’t think others are doing anything but prioritizing themselves. I mean look at the world. Essentially everybody puts themselves first and it’s clear as day. Don’t trick yourself into being the sap doing things for the greater good. And who cares if there’s equal potential for harm and good? The harm might be less than we imagine and the good might be better than we think it could be. “This might be bad” is a terrible reason to not do something. Nearly everything might be bad! People are pretty resilient. They can generally deal with you being selfish.
  - spencerflem 2y ago
    That's grim. Don't light yourself on fire to keep others warm or nothing, but in my experience most people are hoping to make the world better where they can. This sort of hustle culture belief is definitely present in the world, especially among finance and us techie types, but there's tons of examples of people Not acting like this. Teachers don't do it for the pay, etc. There's a reason meaningful jobs tend to pay less, and its because so many people want to do useful helpful things that badly. Anyways point is, that I want to explicitly condemn this type of thinking. Yeah don't let fear of doing the wrong thing paralyze you but also think through the consequences
    - paulcole 2y ago
      > most people are hoping to make the world better where they can. Are they actually making the world better or just hoping they can? Everybody in the developed world, if they wanted to make the world better, would live drastically differently because of their impact on the environment/climate change. But it’s more fun to just say that we’re hoping to make the world better so we don’t have to acknowledge how selfish we actually are. I’m not talking about hustle culture here. I’m talking about the selfishness we all partake in and do our best to ignore.
      - bruce511 2y ago
        I agree that most (privileged) people behave selfishly. You don't have to look far to see that. That doesn't make it good. Which is why advice to be explicitly selfish is jarring. We don't need advice yo do that, we excel at it naturally. There are however great rewards to be had from being unselfish. We can see that around us too. Being at least aware of our proclivities is the first step in discovering the benefits of countering them.
        paulcole 2y ago
        If people are naturally selfish and they’re giving you advice to not be selfish, why aren’t they taking their own advice? And why should you take theirs? It’s like a burglar telling you it’s a good idea to leave your doors unlocked.
        bruce511 2y ago
        Lots of people act, at least partially, in unselfish ways. Selfishness is not a binary characteristic. There are degrees of selfishness - and spheres of selfishness. Just because something is in our nature, it does not mean we have to behave that way all the time. Most people are neither purely selfish, nor purely unselfish. To answer your question though, since selfishness exists on a scale, your assumption that people offering advice are not also practicing it is, at best, a conclusion without data.
  - zero-sharp 2y ago
    This is one of the worst things I've read on here. I hope it's a parody and that I'm just too stupid to understand it.
  - teapot7 2y ago
    That's awful.
echelon 2y ago
You're 16. This is awesome, and you're doing great. This is such strong signal for an amazing career and impact. Keep going!
- helloduck1234 2y ago
  Thank you!
bruce511 2y ago
I'll add, that although this is a good project, it really doesn't matter if it works or not. I don't mean the fact checking part - thats legitimately a good thing to pursue. What I mean is that the value of this (to you and your co-creators) has enormous value to you way beyond the social good it might provide. For example at some point you're going to have to deal with nuance. Things are rarely purely right or wrong. (The earth is not round, but its a good first approximation for geological beginners.) So, I'd encourage you not to measure success here with "does it work", or how many users, or if LLMs are a suitable approach, or any metrics like that. The goal here shouldn't be popularity or "correctness". The most value you will get is the experience of building something, ideally in team. Of facing road-blocks and challenges and overcoming them. Or, to put it another way, have fun. And things that are easy are not fun... Congrats on the project. May it lead you forward to discovering more about how to code, more about the world, more about yourself. Don't shy away from the hard questions. But above all keep it fun.
nzealand 2y ago
Your response to critical feedback is excellent btw. Nice job all around!

> “…which has the potential to do as much harm as good.” I find this is one of the more difficult things for people to learn to fully integrate into their psyche. Many people never learn to truly care about this and everything it means. They go on forever primarily caring about what’s good for them personally.

paulcole 2y ago
Strong disagree. Put yourself first nearly 100% of the time. Nobody cares about you so don’t think others are doing anything but prioritizing themselves. I mean look at the world. Essentially everybody puts themselves first and it’s clear as day. Don’t trick yourself into being the sap doing things for the greater good. And who cares if there’s equal potential for harm and good? The harm might be less than we imagine and the good might be better than we think it could be. “This might be bad” is a terrible reason to not do something. Nearly everything might be bad! People are pretty resilient. They can generally deal with you being selfish.
- spencerflem 2y ago
  That's grim. Don't light yourself on fire to keep others warm or nothing, but in my experience most people are hoping to make the world better where they can. This sort of hustle culture belief is definitely present in the world, especially among finance and us techie types, but there's tons of examples of people Not acting like this. Teachers don't do it for the pay, etc. There's a reason meaningful jobs tend to pay less, and its because so many people want to do useful helpful things that badly. Anyways point is, that I want to explicitly condemn this type of thinking. Yeah don't let fear of doing the wrong thing paralyze you but also think through the consequences
  - paulcole 2y ago
    > most people are hoping to make the world better where they can. Are they actually making the world better or just hoping they can? Everybody in the developed world, if they wanted to make the world better, would live drastically differently because of their impact on the environment/climate change. But it’s more fun to just say that we’re hoping to make the world better so we don’t have to acknowledge how selfish we actually are. I’m not talking about hustle culture here. I’m talking about the selfishness we all partake in and do our best to ignore.
    - bruce511 2y ago
      I agree that most (privileged) people behave selfishly. You don't have to look far to see that. That doesn't make it good. Which is why advice to be explicitly selfish is jarring. We don't need advice yo do that, we excel at it naturally. There are however great rewards to be had from being unselfish. We can see that around us too. Being at least aware of our proclivities is the first step in discovering the benefits of countering them.
      - paulcole 2y ago
        If people are naturally selfish and they’re giving you advice to not be selfish, why aren’t they taking their own advice? And why should you take theirs? It’s like a burglar telling you it’s a good idea to leave your doors unlocked.
        bruce511 2y ago
        Lots of people act, at least partially, in unselfish ways. Selfishness is not a binary characteristic. There are degrees of selfishness - and spheres of selfishness. Just because something is in our nature, it does not mean we have to behave that way all the time. Most people are neither purely selfish, nor purely unselfish. To answer your question though, since selfishness exists on a scale, your assumption that people offering advice are not also practicing it is, at best, a conclusion without data.
- zero-sharp 2y ago
  This is one of the worst things I've read on here. I hope it's a parody and that I'm just too stupid to understand it.
- teapot7 2y ago
  That's awful.

echelon 2y ago

You're 16. This is awesome, and you're doing great. This is such strong signal for an amazing career and impact. Keep going!

helloduck1234 2y ago
Thank you!

bruce511 2y ago

I'll add, that although this is a good project, it really doesn't matter if it works or not. I don't mean the fact checking part - thats legitimately a good thing to pursue. What I mean is that the value of this (to you and your co-creators) has enormous value to you way beyond the social good it might provide. For example at some point you're going to have to deal with nuance. Things are rarely purely right or wrong. (The earth is not round, but its a good first approximation for geological beginners.) So, I'd encourage you not to measure success here with "does it work", or how many users, or if LLMs are a suitable approach, or any metrics like that. The goal here shouldn't be popularity or "correctness". The most value you will get is the experience of building something, ideally in team. Of facing road-blocks and challenges and overcoming them. Or, to put it another way, have fun. And things that are easy are not fun... Congrats on the project. May it lead you forward to discovering more about how to code, more about the world, more about yourself. Don't shy away from the hard questions. But above all keep it fun.

nzealand 2y ago

Your response to critical feedback is excellent btw. Nice job all around!