4 ms·
Thanks for the link elsewhere. While I agree with your assessment about what probably happened, I still say there aren't many facts. It would be helpful to know
by toast0 3y ago
Thanks for the link elsewhere. While I agree with your assessment about what probably happened, I still say there aren't many facts. It would be helpful to know how far in advance the observer changed lanes.
> Even if they slammed on the brakes and managed to cut half their speed they're still slamming into a stationary, heavy object at 40ish mph.
A 40 mph collision is often survivable these days (that's the speed used for crash tests!). The accident vehicle driver survived regardless; the driver of the stopped car didn't though.
Driver assistance is really unhelpful in these situations. Most likely the lead car slowed down, at least a bit while changing lanes, so an active driver would also be slowing and may be quicker to slow more when an unexpected car is there, but driver assistance is going to see the lead car left the lane and there's no other cars (because stationary objects are ignored) so go ahead and speed up. Tesla's are known to have a very high rate of acceleration in this case, not sure about the acceleration for the MachE.
Adding more speculation: as an untrained armchair internet crash investigator, my guess is the collison happened at over 40 mph. The IIHS crash test [1] seems to show less damage than the accident vehicle, and the stopped vehicle was overturned in addition to significant damage.
[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Po_QfX5U8lI&pp=ygUXbWFjaCBlIGNyYXNoIHRlc3QgZnJvbnQ%3D https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Po_QfX5U8lI&pp=ygUXbWFjaCBlIGN...
- vel0city 3y agoI do agree there's a certain level of variability in the possibilities of what actually happened with the facts given so far. I'd really like to see a video recording of what happened so we can actually judge the possible reaction time for the Ford driver. I totally acknowledge its possible there was many seconds between the observer car leaving the lane and the Ford colliding; it is a pretty straight stretch of road so the observer could have seen the car for a bit. Within the unknowns of this incident, it is possible a human without ADAS systems in use here could have responded better. But to me, with what I'm reading about it and my past experiences of watching drivers on Texas highways hitting stopped cars in broad daylight, I imagine a lot of humans would have hit the car in a lot of the possible scenarios.