5 ms·
Most clean power purchasing strategies do little to cut emissions
- integral_1699 3y agoI had a similar realization a few weeks back while trying to purchase a new electricity contract. In the EU, this is made even worse by the definition of green electricity which includes biomass but excludes nuclear energy. For those curious, I wrote up what I found here: https://integralreview.com/green-electricity/ https://integralreview.com/green-electricity/
- surfingdino 3y agoWhat you get when you add politics to science.
- blueflow 3y agoBiomass gets its carbon from the atmosphere. Fossil carbon is the problem.
- pyrale 3y ago> Fossil carbon is the problem. Greenhouse gases are merely one of the significant changes we cause to our environment. The issue with biomass is the huge land surface it requires to produce the necessary fuel.
- blueflow 3y agoYou are not disputing that biomass is carbon neutral?
- ljf 3y agoThe fuel you burn is neutral in that it pulled as much carbon from the air while growing, as is released by burning it. But the carbon cost to manage, process and transport that fuel is not neutral.
- blueflow 3y ago> But the carbon cost to manage, process and transport that fuel is not neutral. Because gasoline for the trucks and coal for the electricity is fossil carbon. Which is not biomass. My point.
- pyrale 3y agoWell, my point was that carbon neutrality is only one variable of the equation. But if you want to focus specifically on biomass, I would say: "it depends". You can't answer that question easily. For instance, would you say a biomass plant producing electricity from wood pellets imported from Brazil is carbon-neutral? I think it isn't. When you're looking at biomass, you can't just look at the plant, you need to focus on how its fuel is sourced, what impacts this sourcing activity has, etc.
- blueflow 3y agoBecause the fuel for the wood freighter is fossil carbon! This is an argument against fossil carbon, not against biomass.
- pyrale 3y ago> Because the fuel for the wood freighter is fossil carbon! No; the reason is that this wood is a byproduct of land use change, which is a source of increased carbon emissions [1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_use,_land-use_change,_and_forestry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_use,_land-use_change,_and...
- wiredfool 3y agoIn some countries, peat is considered biomass. It’s probably worse than coal in terms of per unit damage, but generally it’s burned in far lower quantities.
- stefan_ 3y agoYes, it’s releasing carbon now, to be recovered a hundred years down the road. That doesn’t really work with the timelines we are looking at.
- blueflow 3y agoThat's not how it works with plants. If you or a cow can eat them, that means that they are already done capturing the carbon because that's what they are made out of.
- stefan_ 3y agoThey are done and we still got too much atmospheric CO2, now you burn them. Feel free to insist they captured it in the past hundred years but it’s really a distinction without a difference in this situation. You don’t get a free pass on the CO2 you are releasing now.
- blueflow 3y agoIf you do not burn them, the plants will die and get composted into soil. Soil itself will decompose and release that carbon back into the atmosphere. In temperate climate, this happens in a decade or less. The cycle keeps running with or without humans doing the emissions part. So lets focus on the extra carbon that we dug out and inserted into the cycle.
- sp332 3y agoDrax is cutting down old-growth forests in Canada and shipping them to the UK to be burned for fuel. https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-farce-of-burning-wood-pellets/ https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-farce-of-burning-woo... This is compressing the release of hundreds of years of captured carbon into a lot less time, increasing atmospheric CO2 levels.
- blueflow 3y agoThis "compression" also applies to fossil carbon, even if on a larger scale. So fossil carbon is still worse than biomass.
- flakeoil 3y agoIf it takes 50-100 years to grow back, then the CO2 is still in the air during this time plus you reduce a lot of habitat and create deserts. If all the energy we consume today for heating, cars, electricity etc would come from biomass/trees then a huge part of our forests would have to be cut down in just a few years time, before they have a chance to grow back.
- blueflow 3y ago50-100 is a pretty short time-frame compared to coal and oil formation.
- vladvasiliu 3y ago> In the EU, this is made even worse by the definition of green electricity which [...] excludes nuclear energy Are you sure about this? I've done a quick search for what is specifically included, but came out empty-handed. I was under the impression that France managed to get nuclear to be included. --- Edit: found something that seems to say it's included in the "list of technologies" aimed to achieving "net zero" emissions. Although it's not "green", it's "strategic". https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/nuclear-power-officially-labelled-as-strategic-for-eus-decarbonisation/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/nuc... > After much back and forth, nuclear power was finally included in the single list of 17 technologies proposed in November by the text’s rapporteur, German MEP Christian Ehler (European People’s Party – EPP). In addition, all nuclear technologies were covered: existing and future ones, fission, fusion as well as the fuel cycle.
- integral_1699 3y agoWhen I searched, none of the electricity providers included nuclear energy in their list. I tried doing some research and found this definition for the European Environment Agency: "Electricity produced from resources such as solar, wind, geothermal, biomass, and low-impact hydro facilities is often referred to as 'green electricity'." It's good to see as you point out that the situation is evolving. Strategic is better than nothing!
- willis936 3y agoThis is about companies buying from grid suppliers. Obviously if companies have on-prem energy generation that is used this analysis does not apply. No company is going off grid though, so for evaluating "carbon free" goals it's relevant.
- Aachen 3y ago...anymore* These headlines misinform people who e.g. generally mean well but are also doubtful that corporations aren't pulling their leg with things like green energy contracts. However, the article says it did make sense back when it funded build-out: > While a win for the status of renewable energy technologies, a side effect of cheap renewables means that new corporate or institutional agreements to purchase power from solar and wind projects have an increasingly limited impact in driving long-term, system-wide emissions reductions. "increasingly limited impact" has quite a different vibe than the headline's "they do little" as a general statement
- Trias11 3y ago[flagged]
- throwenv 3y agoThe best thing to cut emissions is minimalism. The planet has limits
- leereeves 3y agoYeah, if climate change is as big a threat to civilization as covid was, why don't we have permanent WFH so people don't have to commute?
- melling 3y agoWhat does this mean in real terms? There are 8 billion people. Many people still live in poverty.
- ArnoVW 3y agoIn real terms this means that we change some of the habits that bring us marginal happiness and comfort, to allow others to rise out of poverty, and leave our children a world to live in. Lower your thermostat (hint : put on a sweater), isolate your house, eat less meat, reduce air travel, take care of your stuff so it lasts (and buy less gimmicks). All of this will likely sound like ridiculous to an American (or even to large swaths of Europe). But I assure you it really is both impactful, necessary and not very difficult. And it’s either that, or figure out how to explain to your children and their children, why you absolutely needed all those things. Because they will want to know why their standard of living and security has degraded wrt to ours, and “we didn’t know” wont work for anything you did since 2010 (and in reality the 1990’s)
- melling 3y agoI assure you that won’t solve the problem. I’m not sure it will buy us any extra time. I can’t believe it’s 2024 and we’re still having this conversation. You have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about!!!
- ArnoVW 3y agoThe question was “what does cutting emissions mean in real terms”. I answered that question. I never said that it was the one and only thing to do, nor did I say that it would solve everything. There is not “one” thing that will solve this. But we can, as you say, buy time, whilst we try to invent technology to find other solutions. Mind you, the Jevons Paradox will just mean that we consume away whatever improvements we create. Hence the importance of being able to restrain ourselves. We have a pretty good picture of what activities emit CO2, and for whom. An average American emits every year twice as much as an average Dutchman, and thrice the amount of an average Frenchman. Again, for a marginal improvement of standard of living. All of this is well documented and saying it isn’t is not going to make the problem go away. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_... https://www.myclimate.org/ https://www.myclimate.org/
- Ekaros 3y agoIt always felt wrong to me that you could buy some type of electricity when none was produced. It is not fungible like that. Only correct way is to cut off the loads when your wind-powered or solar-powered contract do not have matching production.
- siddboots 3y agoIt's just a contract - if both parties are happy to deal with the energy in bulk, then there's no problem. However, if either the buyer or seller thinks there is a risk some of the generation won't be produced, there's still lots of ways to manage that risk in a relatively simple way. Probably the simplest is a variation on "take-or-pay" where the buyer holds some of the risk when the generator is curtailed, i.e., not dispatched by the system controller. Essentially that means that the buyer is committing to have load available to generate against. I've also seen renewable PPAs with time of use specified either in volume for purchase, or in the price structure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kkfx 3y agoIt's years I cry that the sole reasonable usage of p.v. is self consumption and so the sole reasonable dimension for a plant is "how much can I self-consume myself?". The sad state of things is that we have little designed for that at home. Personally I have a Victron EVC 300400300 one of the very few car charger claim to be integrated with p.v. production and yes, it is. Bugged and limited as hell: - many times does not start charging when p.v. power is available, no "force start" button or "try start" configuration option available - it stop charging only after around 30' without enough p.v. power HARDCODED - poor integration with it's own Victron GX server, not taking into account total home consumption in a hybrid system but only the one protected by the local battery if any, of course with a smart-meter system And it's one of the best available. Thermodynamic (heat pump) water heaters? Well one of the most reputed brands here in EU, Daikin, offer just two dry contacts to pilot the appliance, designed to follow grid tariffs, not p.v. All the rest essentially do not take p.v. into account at all. This combined to the absurd prices p.v. installer companies ask their customers (and in some state self-made is illegal) put a strong brake in p.v. economics.