2 ms·
> We as a society make a significant distinction between declining to provide something in the first place, and choosing choosing to take back something someone
by toast0 3y ago
> We as a society make a significant distinction between declining to provide something in the first place, and choosing choosing to take back something someone already possesses. To wit:
>> At what point do we fault someone for not putting in work to delay someone else's death?
> That isn't what is happening. I'm faulting someone for putting in work, to expedite someone else's death.
My understanding is someone on ECMO needs continuous monitoring and infusions of things. You could put in work to proactively remove them from ECMO, hastening their death. Or you could stop putting in the work to continue the treatment and let what happens happens. Are those equivalent?
Maybe the machine needs maitenance to continue functioning and you don't do it.
Maybe you designed the machine so that it must be disconnected every 30 days, so that the default is death after a month and the doctors have to actively choose to replace the machine every 30 days if death is to be avoided.