3 ms·
Did you miss the fish?[0] You should see the error in first viewing What about the woman with glasses? Her face literally "jumps"[1] Same with this guy's hands
by godelski 3y ago
Did you miss the fish?[0] You should see the error in first viewing
What about the woman with glasses? Her face literally "jumps"[1] Same with this guy's hands[2]
Interesting, we notice that [1] has "sora" in the name though I think it is a reference to the main image on sora[3]
Not sure if the gallery is weird to anyone else, but it doesn't exactly show new images and the position indicator is wonky.
The thing that makes me most suspicious is seeing the numbers on these demos. 1, 2, 4 (terrifying to me), 5, 65, 66, 68, 72, 73, 83, 85, 86 (is this Simone Giertz? Vic Michaelis?). The part that is tough about evaluating generative models is the cherry picking for demonstrations. You have to do it or people tear your work apart but also in doing so you give a false impression of what your work can actually do.
IMO it has gotten out of hand and is not benefiting anyone. It makes these papers more akin to advertising than communication of research. We talk about integrity of the research community and why we argue over borderline works but come on, if you can get a better review by more samples, you can get better reviews by paying more, not by doing better work. A pay to play system is far worse for the integrity of ML (or any science) than arguing over borderline works.
Edit: I think it is also a bit problematic that this is posted BEFORE the arxiv link or GitHub goes live. I'd appeal to the HN community to not upvote these kinds of works until at least the paper is live.
[0] https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/demo_0065.mp4 https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/...
[1] https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/demo_0027sora.mp4 https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/...
[2] https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/demo_0068.mp4 https://storydiffusion.github.io/MagicStory_files/longvideo/...
[3] https://openai.com/sora https://openai.com/sora