6 ms·
All this technology has the effect of pushing up the cost of vehicles, often for questionable minor safety improvements. Is there a good analysis of why the roa
by pjc50 3y ago
All this technology has the effect of pushing up the cost of vehicles, often for questionable minor safety improvements. Is there a good analysis of why the road safety trend has gone the wrong way in the US lately?
- willcipriano 3y agoThis is protectionism for the voting block in Detroit. You'll see this sort of thing every 4 years. I'm guessing patents and the like have already decided who the winner of this rule is and it probably isn't automobile buyers in the US.
- acdha 3y agoIt’s matching European standards after years of American roads becoming deadlier while the rest of the world is getting safer. I wouldn’t read anything more into it than “we’d like fewer dead people on our roads”.
- drawkward 3y agoEven if true, who cares, if it means fewer preventable fatalities?
- willcipriano 3y ago"If we can save one life, it's worth it" is part of the reason everything is so expensive in the US. People forget that poverty is also deadly and don't factor that into the calculation.
- drawkward 3y agoI'd argue that profit margins are more to blame here.
- willcipriano 3y agoThen you'd be against giving gifts to Detroit to keep those high.
- Veserv 3y agoThe article says it will save a estimated 362 lives per year at a cost of 82$ per car or 354 M$/yr. The actuarial value of a human life is usually around 5 M$, so that is a societal ROI of 5 if we only count fatalitys.
- willcipriano 3y agoYour model assumes a even distribution of funds across society.
- drawkward 3y agoyou don't have a better assumption.
- lm28469 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/27/upshot/road-deaths-pedestrians-cyclists.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/27/upshot/road-deaths-pedest... I can't link the graph directly because it doesn't display the text, ctrl-f "Change in U.S. road deaths since 1994" to see it
- acdha 3y agoI’d also add https://www.ghsa.org/resources/news-releases/pedestrians-preliminary24 https://www.ghsa.org/resources/news-releases/pedestrians-pre... > A combination of factors creates this deadly situation for people walking on U.S. roadways. A steep drop in traffic enforcement across the country since 2020 has enabled dangerous driving behaviors – including speeding and driving impaired – to flourish. At the same time, roads are largely designed to prioritize fast-moving vehicle traffic instead of slower speeds that are safer for people walking. Many parts of the country lack infrastructure – such as sidewalks, crosswalks and lighting – that help protect people on foot. The U.S. vehicle fleet is increasingly dominated by larger, heavier vehicles that are more likely to injure or kill people walking. I think the pause on enforcement a lot of police departments did after the George Floyd protests is a contributing factor to that first point: it’s not just that the worst drivers realized that they could do whatever they want after buying some fake plates on Facebook[1] but that other drivers start feeling like suckers for still following the rules. I wouldn’t say the drivers here were ever great but they used to at least stop for the red light in front of the neighborhood elementary school. 1. This was incredibly blatant - clearly neither Facebook nor police were interested in doing anything about it. A local cyclist spent a few minutes looking and found tons of sellers: https://tomlee.wtf/2023/02/03/fake-tags-are-a-real-problem/ https://tomlee.wtf/2023/02/03/fake-tags-are-a-real-problem/
- lesuorac 3y ago> I think the pause on enforcement a lot of police departments did after the George Floyd protests is a contributing factor to that first point Which is always a silly thing to read. George Floyd wasn't arrested because he flying 60 mph through red lights. It was over an alleged crime with maximum damages of $20; it's not even comparable to the violations being let slide.
- gumby 3y ago> All this technology has the effect of pushing up the cost of vehicles, often for questionable minor safety improvements. DoT (and other departments) are required to take the cost of rules into account when writing them. So for example if the cost of putting in a safety rail on a curve exceeds the cost of the lives estimated to be saved at that curve over the lifetime of the rail, it won't be installed. Different departments used to, and AFAIK still do (though I don't track this), value the price of a life differently. And it's not just the cost of the life; it's the cost of the cars damaged in a rear-end collision.
- Amezarak 3y agoCell phones. I look around me and at least half of the drivers I see are texting/scrolling, watching videos, or posting Snapchat stories.
- acdha 3y agoThis is true but it can’t be more than part of the explanation: pretty much everywhere else has phones but has seen declining fatality rates.
- BadHumans 3y agoThe US has heavier cars to skirt around regulations and no public transit infrastructure.
- acdha 3y agoYes, and worse pedestrian infrastructure, very limited law enforcement, and lax driver licensing. There isn’t a single fix which is going to make our roads as safe as, say, Germany but progress in any area will help.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoThe cost here is pretty trivial from my understanding. It’s essentially just a vision system that can send a brake command. Aka a camera behind the mirror and a microprocessor. Much of the other components are already present on modern vehicles.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> The cost here is pretty trivial from my understanding. The cost to implement it or the cost to make it utterly bulletproof?
- Germanion 3y agoThis requires a automotive grade camera with connection to the can Bus. This might not be expensive per se but is still a few hundred bucks. For a small car this can easily be a few percent extra.
- Spartan-S63 3y agoI think there's one of two ways to make roadways safer: 1. Add these safety feature mandates that increase the price of vehicles 2. Move towards banning larger and larger vehicles and create limits on height and clearance for non-commercial vehicles. The latter doesn't seem politically popular, so the former is the only choice.
- marssaxman 3y agoThere's another way, which is far more cost-effective and particularly well suited to government action: build more public transportation.
- spankalee 3y agoPushing up the cost of cars is good. They're damaging to the environment, people, and our infrastructure. The minimum we can be doing right now is to lower the safety risk and emissions of them.
- grobbyy 3y agoNo. It's not. Pushing down car ownership might be good, but not based on wealth. Priority should go to elderly, people with disabilities, people with kids, etc. Even so, the goal shouldn't be fewer cars but less miles driven. The kind of antagonistic approach you prescribe rarely leads to good policy.
- spankalee 3y agoCars are massively subsidized, and requiring that they be safer reduces some of their externalities a bit, raising their cost and lowering that subsidy. That's a good thing.
- nomel 3y agoWhere I am, my car commute is 30 minutes. If I moved closer, shaving it to 10 minutes, my housing costs double. If I get down to 5, housing costs are about 4x. If I use public transport now, the travel time is 2 hours. To keep my public transport to 30 minutes, I have to ~2x my housing costs. I think, realistically, people will just end up commuting further, to offset the cost, since that is the best financial, and time, choice.
- spankalee 3y agoWe should also build more housing!
- nomel 3y agoThat's another significant problem. Any dense housing built near the city is, necessarily, corporate built, due to initial costs. The ability to own these units is disappearing [1], with much more profit being found by renting. This means that moving near a city is, almost always, a 100% loss, where you burn your housing cost every month, rather than building equity with something you can own some commute away. This adds significantly more cost to the short commute, if you plan on living in the same place for a while. [1] https://www.ppic.org/blog/multi-unit-housing-is-becoming-more-common-but-has-low-homeownership-rates/ https://www.ppic.org/blog/multi-unit-housing-is-becoming-mor...