7 ms·
NASA lays out how SpaceX will refuel Starships in low-Earth orbit
- avmich 3y agoDo they describe somewhere how they achieved the apparently successful propellant transfer in microgravity in flight 3? Having pressure difference might not be enough if the fuel is a mix of liquid and gaseous phases. Edit: aha, found - "Then, SpaceX will fine-tune tank pressures and fire propellant settling thrusters." And they are using free flow. Wonder how long the transfer will take and how much of a propellant settling acceleration is needed?.. Also :) the relative positions of ships become important if no pumps are used...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the relative positions of ships become important if no pumps are used It shouldn’t if they’re using pressure to feed propellant. Do you mean relative to the Sun in respect of boil off?
- avmich 3y agoNo, I'm confused between "free flow", "no pumps" and "pressure difference", which to me a sort of a pump - in some sense, active forces applied to propellants. So I was thinking about flowing from a point of higher potential energy to point of lower one, on Earth you put the empty glass below the full when you need to pour water from the full to the empty. If Starships actually use pressure difference, then it's not quite free flow, and geometrical positions aren't that important.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> If Starships actually use pressure difference, then it's not quite free flow, and geometrical positions aren't that important That's how I'm reading it, analogous to a pressure-fed engine [1]. A separate, expendable gas supply pressurises the donor tank to force the propellant out and over. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressure-fed_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressure-fed_engine
- avmich 3y agoNot sure if it's too similar to pressure-fed engine, that one works with a clear acceleration direction, which really helps to keep fuel at the local bottom. > A separate, expendable gas supply pressurises the donor tank to force the propellant out and over. But what if the fuel is a mix of liquid bubbles and the gas freely floating in the tank? (BTW, on the different point, some pumps applicable here could be really simple, like analogous to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_ejector#Water_aspirator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_ejector#Water_aspirator)
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> that one works with a clear acceleration direction, which really helps to keep fuel at the local bottom I believe the plan is to impart a gentle spin. > some pumps applicable here could be really simple The Venturi effect reduces pressure. It's definitely worth exploring. But you'd need to test it to explore where it causes volumetric effects, e.g. by exacerbating boil off.
- avmich 3y ago> I believe the plan is to impart a gentle spin. That would be something new. And for a partially refueled stage, that's a lot of mass to spin. How fast? the speed of spinning could be important too.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> that's a lot of mass to spin. How fast? No clue! But I think they were targeting mili-g acceleration--could probably be achieved by the boil off alone.
- rbanffy 3y agoHeating the donor by exposing it to sunlight while shading the receiver should provide some pressure differential for no added power. Gentle rotation would start with the center of gravity wihin the donor, but as the transfer goes on, it'd move to the middle of the two rockets and stop the transfer at that point.
- jdewerd 3y agoOhhhh, is that why it was spinning going into the reentry attempt?
- me_me_me 3y agodeepcut :D
- jdewerd 3y agoIt wasn't intended as a jab, spinning it up to settle the propellant for transfer sounds like a good idea to me. Of course, failing to exit the spin is still mission-ending but they'll figure it out. Now we just need the Attenborough voiceover about the mating habits of starships as they spin through space.
- me_me_me 3y agoyou would but you need to stop the spin and then dock the two together. That would send fluids to the back of the tanks. At this stage it might be easier to build fueling station in the orbit with actual transfer pumps.
- avmich 3y agoI'd definitely prefer to decouple the carrying fuel to the orbital depot and the refueling at the said depot, when it already does have the fuel amount needed. As for spinning two Starships of significantly different mass... that should be interesting to see. Doable, yes :) but interesting nevertheless.
- jdewerd 3y agoSpin after docking, of course. Pushing the liquids is not the hard part. Settling the liquids in 0g is the hard part.
- aejm 3y agoI understand their desires to eliminate parts and reduce weight in the second stage (Starship), but I foresee them eventually adding in pumps to aide in transfer of propellants. Maybe not in all variants, but definitely in the crew version, as having the ability to transfer propellant even if the pressure differences and settling cannot be achieved seems worth the lost performance.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> having the ability to transfer propellant even if the pressure differences and settling cannot be achieved seems worth the lost performance Pumps are way more complicated than pressure feeding.
- brunoqc 3y agoI wonder if it answers some of SmarterEveryDay's criticism[1]. Like the crazy number of launch required for this. [1] Talking about the Artemis program to the American Astronautical Society https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoJsPvmFixU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoJsPvmFixU
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoI’m a fan of that channel. But he seemed to miss the point of Artemis. The criticisms were valid. But his KISS call on the framework seemed to ignore that the point isn’t getting to the Moon, it isn’t even getting to the Moon repeatedly; it’s developing a system for repeatedly getting to Mars.
- moffkalast 3y agoAnd keeping it simple will inevitably drive costs up due to the additional brute force required, making it all uneconomical in the first place. Apollo was simple. It also cost 25% of the US's yearly GDP in total.
- avmich 3y ago> It also cost 25% of the US's yearly GDP in total. Well, peak ~4% of US budget, not GDP, in 1966. A lot, but not that much.
- vundercind 3y ago25% of GDP is closer to what World War II cost in its peak year. Perhaps 30%. But it’s kinda hard to define, since it also grew GDP tremendously (in the US). It may have been a much higher percentage with 1945 costs measured against 1939 GDP, if that makes sense, but I’m not sure it’s appropriate to make that comparison.
- moffkalast 3y ago> in total I think the average figure is 2.5% yearly for 10 years, so that would be as if it were 25% in one year for the entire programme.
- youngtaff 3y ago> In the long run, SpaceX wants to ramp up the Starship launch cadence to many daily flights from multiple launch sites. And how much is that going to pollute our atmosphere?
- avmich 3y agoLess than aviation?
- rbanffy 3y agoCertainly more than aviation per passenger * mile (assuming altitude being the traveled distance)
- avmich 3y ago> Certainly more than aviation per passenger * mile (assuming altitude being the traveled distance) But then it's much less of passenger * mile with the given definition.
- rbanffy 3y agoI don't think many people would find it appealing to no longer flying in order for billionaires to fly on rockets.
- CaptArmchair 3y agoPotentially more then one might assume. This is an area that needs more research, but initial estimates seem to indicate that an increase in launched very much warrants concern. CBC made this nice interactive graph highlighting the issue. https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/features/2023/rocket-pollution/ https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/features/2023/rocket-polluti... I'm a huge proponent of space flight, but my main concern is how the drive towards commoditization, again, seems to gloss over potential hidden costs with a complex, global impact.
- 3y ago
- nerdjon 3y agoSo the idea of refueling in space is interesting, but I am a bit confused by the practicality. if we could refuel from the Moon, yeah I 100% see the value of it due to less wasted fuel getting off the moon. But unless I am mistaken, the biggest problem with fuel is that it obviously costs fuel to get fuel up. It has a weight so its not like you can just say, I want 100 lbs of extra fuel, you need that amount of fuel plus the amount of fuel to carry that amount (and then the amount to carry that amount, and so on and so forth). So in reality what is the difference between say, 100lbs of fuel across 10 Starships vs 100 lbs of fuel on a single ship? Yeah you would need a bigger ship to handle all of the fuel necessary, but something about this being necessary for the moon seems off? Mars I can understand more. I just feel like I am missing something here, until reading this I did not realize that refuel in space was necessary for the Moon. Also to be clear I am not discounting the work on doing this, but I was just always under the impression that this was a thing that was necessary for Mars where now it seems like we are talking 11 launches to get too the moon?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> what is the difference between say, 100lbs of fuel across 10 Starships vs 100 lbs of fuel on a single ship? Exponential. > something about this being necessary for the moon seems off? Mars I can understand more It's not necessary for the Moon. The reason we're doing it is so once Artemis is done on the Moon, we have a system ready to send astronauts to Mars. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation#Experiment_of_the_Boat_by_Tsiolkovsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation#Ex...
- nerdjon 3y agoMaybe there is a typo in the article then that is why this seemed weird? The first paragraph: > ambitious refueling demonstration, a technical feat that will put the Moon within reach. Again here: > By the time NASA and SpaceX are ready for a lunar landing, multiple Starship tankers will take off from at least two launch pads to aggregate propellants at a depot to supply the Moon-bound Starship. Then again here: > On future Starship missions targeting destinations in deep space, like the Moon, this docking maneuver and refueling process will be repeated multiple times to give the vehicle enough gas to boost itself out of Earth orbit. Another one: > The results of this refueling demonstration will allow SpaceX and NASA engineers to calculate how many refueling tankers they will need to fill up a Starship heading for the Moon. All of this makes it seem like this is necessary just to get to the moon with Starship which really makes me wonder about the practicality of this when later it mentions the possibility of 10 refueling missions. Or am I misreading what this is saying?