27 ms·
Is 53% turnout a lot or a little in Israel? It's a lot in the US, obviously. What does it matter that the number includes Druze and Bedouin? Other than that bot
by tptacek 3y ago
Is 53% turnout a lot or a little in Israel? It's a lot in the US, obviously. What does it matter that the number includes Druze and Bedouin? Other than that both communities are harshly discriminated against in the surrounding countries without reaction or even notice from the commentariat?
I understand arguments about colonization vis a vis Gaza and (especially) the West Bank, whose occupations represent the threat of an in-progress appropriation and "colonization", if we're going to use that word. I don't understand what discussion about the "colonization" of Jaffa gets you. Jaffa is to Tel Aviv what Saint Paul is Minneapolis. It's not going anywhere. What's to advocate for? You would literally be on firmer footing advocating for the return of San Antonio to Mexico.
- runarberg 3y agoThe report linked by my parent talks about 53% being a great turnout for Arab voters, as it was up from only 44.6% a year earlier. However this number has been going down all this century. If compared to Israel as a whole, it is very worrying to a point where I would call it a democratic flaw, as the general population has election participation around 70%. Talking about the colonization of Jaffa was in response to the peace deal, where DiogenesKynikos said: > This is a massive concession, because the Palestinians have given up their claim to places like Haifa and Jaffa, which used to be almost 100% Palestinian cities, and which they were unjustly driven out of. So far, no Israeli government has reciprocated and acknowledged a Palestinian "right to exist." Jaffa was colonized in 1948 by displacing almost all of their residents, most are still to this day refugees in Gaza or Lebanon, two-three generations later. Jaffa still exists as a placename, but the city does not, it has been completely annexed into Tel Aviv, which used to be a suburb of Jewish settlers (according to the Wikipedia article I just read). I don’t see a comparison with Saint Paul (which is still an independent city) or San Antonio. The concession of relinquishing claims to Jaffa is nothing short of the concessions which the Irish nationalists did when they relinquished claims to Belfast. In return Ireland actually got statehood and eventual independence. Years later Catholics living in Belfast got equal rights, political representation and a political avenue for decolonization. If the British would have behaved like Israel, they would have driven almost every Catholic out of what would become Northern Ireland before 1921 (they had already renamed all their placenames centuries prior) made sure those that remained had no affiliations with Catholics in the Free state, denied them the right to return, moved British Protestants into the vacant areas (they had also done that centuries prior), and never actually given the Irish free state political recognition. Even after the nationalists gave up any claims to Belfast.
- tptacek 3y agoJaffa isn't Belfast. Its history is nothing like that of Belfast's. It's status is closer to that of San Antonio (except with the complexity of the exchange of displaced populations). I still don't understand what the point of trying to call out its "colonial" status is. It's not going anywhere.
- runarberg 3y agoEvery case is unique, and yes Jaffa is nothing like Belfast. I simply brought it up because Belfast was also a settler colonial city claimed by the colonized peoples before the colonized relinquished their claim of it in a deal. However unlike Jaffa, when the nationalists relinquished their claim of the city, the colonizers reciprocated and gave them recognition of their state in return.
- tptacek 3y agoSo, if I understand the argument, it's that calling out the "colonization" of places like Jaffa is moral leverage in an argument for recognizing Palestinian statehood in Gaza and the West Bank? (I don't think you need more leverage for that argument; I think it's self-evident. But ok!)
- edanm 3y agoJust to add a note here - historically, Palestinian citizens of Israel (commonly referred to as Israeli-Arabs) have had complicated feelings about taking part in Israeli elections. I don't think I can speak properly on this topic as I'm not a Palestinian myself, but if you're interested it's worth trying to look into this. Despite making up 20% of the Israeli population, 2021 was the first time an independent Arab party was part of an Israeli government. This was a huge deal at the time and the "Israeli Arab" vote was very actively pursued (and the Israeli right wing used all sorts of horrible tactics to try to suppress it).
- runarberg 3y agoI did find this quote interesting from the IDI poll[1] > Asked by the IDI which issue should be at “the heart of the election campaign,” 54% said violence in Arab society, 16% said housing, 11% said the status of the Al-Aqsa Mosque in the Old City of Jerusalem, and only 5% said the Palestinian issue. What I take from this is that Israeli-Arabs care a lot more about their own community as Israeli-Arabs than the prospects of their neighbors in Palestine having a free Palestinian state. 1: https://www.timesofisrael.com/surveys-predict-bump-in-arab-voter-turnout-ahead-of-november-1-elections/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/surveys-predict-bump-in-arab-v...
- edanm 3y agoInteresting. Though this is from two years ago, I imagine it would seem different today. In some sense the fact that so many don't vote is a kind of solidarity with other Palestinians, though I think a misguided one.
- racional 3y ago[flagged]
- racional 3y agoJaffa is to Tel Aviv what Saint Paul is Minneapolis. A deeply broken analogy. Jaffa, unlike Tel Aviv, was 70 percent Arab in 1945 and was considered the cultural and economic capital of Palestine. It was attacked in a major offensive by the Irgun in April, and later by the Haganah in May of 1948 (before the Declaration of Independence and the "defensive war" that followed it). I'm sure you know all about the Irgun; here's a description of their tactics from an Israeli historian: In one attack, on 13 December, a barrel packed with explosives was dropped from a vehicle next to the entrance to the Alhambra (al-Hamra) Cinema, adjacent to the Jaffa City Hall on King George Boulevard. The barrel rolled down the street and came to a stop outside Cafe´ Venezia. Some of the clients noticed it and rushed to take shelter in the kitchen or fled out the back door. The ensuing explosion killed six clients and passersby, among them a ten-year-old boy, the others aged 16 –24. The building and the nearby cinema were badly damaged. On the same day, the IZL blew up houses in the villages of Yahudiyya-‘Abbasiyya and Yazur, killing seven Arabs. On 30 December, the IZL launched another attack on Jaffa’s rear. This time the squads landed from the sea and tried to attack Arab cafe´s in the port area, but local fighters stationed nearby drove them off, apparently without losses on the Arab side. The next day, IZL men, dressed as Arabs, again entered Jaffa and threw a bomb into an Arab cafe´. Around 100,000 people were forced to flee (from the city proper and surrounding towns) - some 10-20k of which were literally pushed into the sea. Of course, very few were allowed to return. 90 percent of the smaller towns were completely depopulated. The 4000 Arab residents who remained were forced to live in a small corner of the city in dilapidated housing, and under martial law. From a recent New Yorker piece: “Ajami is about to be closed off with a barbed-wire fence that will rigorously separate the Arab neighborhood and the Jewish section,” an Israeli official wrote in 1949. “That arrangement will immediately render Ajami a sealed-off ghetto. It is hard to accept this idea, which stirs in us associations of excessive horror.” After the "defensive war" Arab houses were looted and given to migrants from Europe. Streets and public places were renamed. Arab Jaffa was effectively wiped off the map. What's to advocate for? A reasonable understanding (and non-erasure of) extremely basic and uncontested regional history.
- racional 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago