3 ms·
> I think the issue is that it's relatively easy to make infinite copies of ebooks. That's the case regardless of any DRM or even what the source material is.
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> I think the issue is that it's relatively easy to make infinite copies of ebooks.
That's the case regardless of any DRM or even what the source material is. You can OCR a physical book or type the contents into your computer once from any source you can read with your eyes and then make infinite copies thereafter.
The thing that prevents this is that making unlimited permanent copies is copyright infringement, the same as it ever was. Making the unlimited copies is now cheaper than it was a century ago, but that has nothing to do with where or how the infringer gets the first copy.
Never mind breaking DRM, there are services that will OCR a book for around $15. For most books it would cost less to OCR than to buy a single physical copy, from which an infringer could make an unlimited number. Putting this out as some kind of significant distinction between physical and digital copies is just looking for an excuse for a money grab against the new technology.
- tombert 3y agoWait, no, you do not just get to claim OCR is as easy as "right click copy, right click paste". Even if OCR weren't kind of crappy, which is absolutely is, you still have to physically take a scan or photo of every page, potentially assemble them, load it into the OCR software, then distribute it. Yes, there are services that will OCR a book for some amount of money, but that's still more work than just copying a digital file. I would still need to package and ship the book, get out my credit card to pay, unpackage the book when it's shipped back. It's categorically more effort, pretending otherwise is just outright dishonest.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoNone of that matters when the number of copies you can subsequently make is unlimited. The amortized cost of the one-time scan is entirely negligible. This is the same reason DRM doesn't prevent everything from being on The Pirate Bay. It's not that breaking it is always trivial, it's that you only need one person to do it once. It doesn't matter if it costs one cent or a thousand dollars because neither of those is enough to be a deterrent.