2 ms·
It’s a fair point. Most of what the IA does is probably technically copyright violation but I’d argue there’s a qualitative difference between making copies of
by ghaff 3y ago
It’s a fair point. Most of what the IA does is probably technically copyright violation but I’d argue there’s a qualitative difference between making copies of public websites, software that publishers have abandoned, and other things in that vein—especially given they historically bent over backwards to stop sharing copyrighted material if someone got upset— and sharing digitized copyrighted books Willy-nilly given there was already precedent that you just can’t do that.
- jfengel 3y agoAs I understand it, they're pretty good about taking your site out if you ask them to. That's not quite the letter of the law on copyright, and potentially leaves them open to lawsuits, but few web site publishers are really going to pursue them once they've taken the material down. If they'd applied that same level to the books, they might have avoided this mess.