8 ms·
Xbox 360 Should Be Banned from U.S. for Violating Patents, Judge Says
- georgemcbay 14y agoI used to naively hope that situations like this would force the government to sit up and take notice at how badly the patent system is broken and how it hurts most industries more than it helps them, especially hurting the "little guys" (who are often invoked in defense of the system) disproportionately since the system is set up to cost so much to "play the game". But now I know that in the end each will pay the other their necessary "protection money", the lawyers will skim a huge amount off the top and big corporate business will go on as usual.
- dclowd9901 14y agoIn a system written by lawyers, whom else would you expect to emerge the winners?
- dromidas 14y agoI like how one of his justifications is that upholding copyrights is more in public interest than our entertainment.
- crash013 14y agoIt is
- npc 14y agoNo it's not. (See what I did there? I responded to an unsupported statement of fact with another unsupported statement of fact. Both our arguments are equally valid, i.e. not at all. Perhaps next time you post on HN you could add some arguments to support your position, if only out of courtesy to those of us who cannot read your mind to see the no doubt infallible logic behind your opinion.)
- wcarss 14y agoI voted in favour of your response, because the sort of snark that you presented resonates with me, however, two things: 1. This kind of response (along with the kind that I am giving now) is often just as much a problem as the initial non-useful post in terms of "useless thread clutter". Things could go either way on whether it's really useful to point out the situation to a user "for their benefit" -- the voting system exists partly to let us wash unproductive responses out of sight. 2. You particularly noted "next time you post on HN", and that made me feel a bit sick. There's little more elitist than saying to a newbie that they need to change their behaviour "around here", or "to hang out with us". It shows a greater concern for our little clique than for the ideal of argumentation, or for the dissemination of knowledge to people who could use it. All that said, I'm clearly not following my own advice here -- in my defense, I'm making the bet based on your post that you're someone willing to consider your actions and either respectfully disagree or change, but I could be wrong. My response likely ought to be voted down as further useless junk.
- rhino42 14y agoThat being said, there is value to posts like the above. If we want to avoid becoming Reddit, we must self moderate and make an effort to stabilize our culture.
- chc 14y agoI don't see where copyright law comes into this.
- dromidas 14y agoI probably should have said 'IP rights' but you know what I mean. Referring to his quote, "a strong public interest in enforcing intellectual property rights; not enforcing those rights in light of a potential economic impact occurs only in exceptional circumstances"
- nwmcsween 14y agoThis is one of the reasons I sometimes commit code under a pseudonym rather than my own name, go ahead and litigate an imaginary person, I honestly could care less who holds what patents on my code - if it works I'm using it.
- ajross 14y agoThis won't help anyone. You don't litigate against software authors. Patent suits are filed (or threatened) against the people who are selling/offering or otherwise making profits from a plausibly infringing device; because that's where the money is. I think maybe you're confusing patent law (which is a civil thing about damages) and copyright law (which sometimes has criminal penalties). It's not illegal to write and publish source code implementing patented algorithms. In fact: the patent itself is in fact supposed to be an officially published version maintained by the government. At best, anonymous contributions might insulate you from being subpoenaed because they can't find you.
- nwmcsween 14y agoMy goal is to insulate myself from the stupidity that is software patents, I generally come up with the ideas myself while working but then search for prior implementations to see it has been patented (some of which should never have been given a patent).
- RollAHardSix 14y agoI've actually had a similar experience with this. I was working on our company website and came up with something remarkably similar to Amazon's One-Click Ordering System. Having ordered a max of 3 things off Amazon in the past 10 years; I had absolutely no idea they had any such feature. Continuing my work lead out to the architecture and rough code-outline of this (I was unusually excited so I did a bit of pre-coding). Then deciding to 'do my homework' I went off to find prior implementations; low and behold I came across Amazon's One-Click Ordering Process. (And also the information covering the two-click ordering process lawsuit that still went in Amazon's favor). So my question is if I had implemented such a system would I have been liable? The sad thing is, looking at the way the patent system is now, I WANT to say yes. Even with it being my own code just the process being patented would have prevented me from using it; despite the fact that I came up with a similar process completely on my own. It just seems to me that in a way the patent system stifles...innovation. I am now very concerned about putting my efforts towards something without checking for a patent first. I'd like to see someone with more experience and legal knowledge could expand on Patents and Patent Law in general.
- jasonkolb 14y ago"The Xbox 360 violates four Motorola patents, according to ITC Administrative Law Judge David Shaw, Wired reports. Shaw made his initial ruling against Microsoft in April, and now recommends a ban on sales and import of the game console." Didn't Google just buy Motorola? This could get interesting.
- ajross 14y agoI'm not sure that I see it that way. If anything I'd think Google would find it in its (and, frankly, our) best interests to let the patent war escalate further. The more of a mess it is, the more likely someone in government will step in to intervene. At this point it's becoming routine for every successful consumer electronics device to see a patent ban somewhere. That's not sustainable. I hope.
- jasonkolb 14y agoI hope too.
- taligent 14y agoThe government will step in alright and investigate Google/Motorola for anti-trust violation. Just like what is happening in the EU. And I expect them to be severely punished. The fact is that Google/Motorola behaviour in abusing the principles of FRAND is arguably some of the worst seen in the history of the industry. Almost every single consumer electronic product would have either (a) not existed or (b) be significantly more expensive without the fair licensing of patent pools.
- felipeko 14y agoPatents/FRAND pools are just a way for big old companies tax the little guys, not for inovations, but by making an standard encumbered with patents. Completely the the opposite of what patents where supposed to do. So, in a way, FRAND is actually a abuse of the patent system in more ways than not. Because of FRAND you already have products that do not exist and products that become significantly more expensive.
- simba-hiiipower 14y ago"The ideal outcome for consumers would be a broad cross-licensing agreement that would allow the Xbox 360 and Motorola phones to co-exist. But Microsoft is already getting hefty patent ransoms from other Android phone makers, and likely doesn’t want to let Motorola off the hook too easily, especially now that it’s owned by Google." Ok, not directly related to the bulk of the article, but that point up above got me thinking.. Couldn't it end up benefiting MSFT if Motorola (now GOOG controlled) doesn’t pay-up under its Android licensing program? If essentially all other non-google-owned OEMs are paying a licensing fee and essentially GOOG itself manages to dodge it, it could further drive a wedge between them (Samsung, HTC, et all v. Google/Motorola).. leading to those OEMs (who currently dominate the market) shifting focus to Windows Phone, and thus benefiting MSFT in the end..? Just a thought; thought I’d share..
- cooldeal 14y agoMeanwhile, MS won another round in Germany against Motorola. http://www.engadget.com/2012/05/24/microsoft-motorola-sms-patent-germany/ http://www.engadget.com/2012/05/24/microsoft-motorola-sms-pa...
- csallen 14y agoThe patent system as it exists today is a far cry from what the founders had in mind when, in the Constitution, they granted Congress the power to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." Nowadays people think of patents as a way of protecting the "property" of inventors, and so patents are granted and enforced according to that principle, regardless of whether they promote or hinder progress. The usage of the words "theft" and "piracy" to refer to patent and copyright infringement is a symptom of this state of mind. Thomas Jefferson et al would have called this nonsense. By its very nature, an idea -- once divulged -- cannot be someone's property, and it should not be treated as such. To prevent the free flow of ideas through a populace is, in many cases, harmful. (Imagine a group of hunter gatherers in which one family has patented the idea of farming.) At most, limited monopolies should be granted to prevent situations in which nobody is incentivized to create due to rampant copying. But we still have to be judicious in granting these monopolies: "...it may be observed that the nations which refuse monopolies of invention are as fruitful as England in new and useful devices." -- Thomas Jefferson "But grants of this sort can be justified in very peculiar cases only, if at all; the danger being very great that the good resulting from the operation of the monopoly, will be overbalanced by the evil effect of the precedent; and it being not impossible that the monopoly itself, in its original operation, may produce more evil than good." -- James Madison It's painful to see copyrights and patents today accomplishing the polar opposite of what they were intended to. But we've been gradually heading in this direction for the last 200 years. In my opinion it's a combination of (a) allowing businesses to have too much say in law-making, (b) Congress + the populace not being sufficiently educated about the implications of copyrights and patents, thus giving more power to the natural tendency to think of ideas as property, and (c) the Supreme Court following overly non-interventionist policies and allowing Congress to make unconstitutional decisions.
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoI find this constitutional fundamentalist attitude to be just as wrong. The founders had no idea how the future would turn out. Lets just face facts: the idea of owning knowledge can never work out fairly thus patents in themselves are unethical and unfeasible. The system should just be retired. The founders were wrong about this the same way they were wrong about slavery and other 18th century issues. They are forever limited by their 18th century outlook. There is no way you can have a "fair" patent system. Its like having "fair" slavery. Just let it go.
- joelhaus 14y agoDid anyone else notice that FOSS Patents gets a citation in this article? The author, Jared Newman[1], needs someone to point out to him that he is citing an article written by someone with a major conflict of interest, the paid Microsoft shill, Florian Mueller[2]. If we ever hope to have public opinion shift on the patent issue, this type of journalism will only prolong the struggle. [1] https://twitter.com/#!/OneJaredNewman https://twitter.com/#!/OneJaredNewman [2] http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120419070127103 http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120419070127103
- Natsu 14y agoWhy would he tout what is clearly bad news for Microsoft? Personally, I'm sick of all this injunction nonsense, but they need some way to fight back against Microsoft's patent aggression.
- rbanffy 14y agoWell... This is getting very entertaining. Normally, I'd condemn Motorola's attitude, but Microsoft has been patent-extorting every Android manufacturer they can intimidate. I really hope Motorola can beat some sense into Microsoft.
- Lendal 14y agoMaybe they should be banned. Only something of this magnitude would draw the necessary level of interest from apathetic voters to make this a campaign issue, thus positive change might result. If a couple of years without Xbox's is the price for patent reform, I would gladly pay it.
- intended 14y agoIn this case though it wouldn't work out that way because the topic is pretty arcane. Unless the issue can be reduced to a catch phrase that actually encapsulates the idea, or people see some obviously valuable thing which is clearly being taken away from them; then its very hard to sell this.
- bbrtyth 14y agoThat would teach Microsoft a valuable lesson about harassing Android over ridiculous software patents.
- tsotha 14y agoBut the valuable lesson they would draw from it all is "we need to patent every thought a Microsoft employee has", which is probably not the lesson you're imagining.
- gouranga 14y agoThe patent system is like watching a scene from Alien vs Predator... "Whoever wins, we all lose" is surprisingly apt as well.
- rsanchez1 14y agoMaybe if the 360 is banned, people will finally wake up to how absurd the patent system is and demand reform.