5 ms·
Nix: The Breaking Point
- rijoja 3y agoWas this about some PC nonsense? This post doesn't really point to any concrete problems, but seem to be about someone trying to gain control over the project?
- bananapub 3y agoit is mostly used on personal-computers yes, but that's not really the crux of the issue.
- rijoja 3y agoThe acronym I was referring to was Political Correctness...
- Kiro 3y agoThey are well aware. What's more interesting is that you responded so seriously to an obvious joke.
- rijoja 3y agoYeah no I thought of that, and consider saying something funny back, but then I remembered what HN's policy was on the subject, and thought that in the case someone fails to see the sarcasm, they'll not be confused.
- saagarjha 3y agoHacker News has no official policy on being funny. It just penalizes you if you’re bad at it
- constantcrying 3y agoApparently it is about Nix, for the first time, seeing real world usage by a serious corporation, but that usage turning out to be autonomous drones aiding the US in killing random civilians on the other side of the world.
- rijoja 3y agoRight, that explains it. The post is really lacking when it comes to concrete examples of what is going on. "The ad-hoc structure of maintainers here better represent the goals of Nix users and their methods of success. Yet, these contributors are beginning to flee." It also makes the claim above, is there any truth to that? Is there evidence of contributors fleeing, and if so where? What is stopping them from forking the project?
- Cacti 3y agoAnduril specializes in counter-drone warfare and collaborative intelligence. They are not bombing civilians on the other side of the world.
- mtndew4brkfst 3y agoIt's relatively easy to find articles from the horse's mouth about this. If you read through the euphemisms you can see that besides drone/counter-drone stuff, they also participate in building and deploying tech that are not purely "defensive", not focused solely on drones, but capable of and built for violence against people, infrastructure and other (manned) vehicles too. Suggest clicking through since the URLs are not nearly as clear as the content: https://www.anduril.com/article/altius-700m-live-fire-test/ https://www.anduril.com/article/altius-700m-live-fire-test/ ALTIUS-700M brings unmatched payload capacity to the loitering munitions market, combining multi-domain launch, proven collaborative autonomy, and category-leading range with a larger, penetrating warhead to kill or disable armored targets and infrastructure. https://www.anduril.com/article/anduril-s-lattice-a-trusted-dual-use-commercial-and-military-platform-for-public-safety-security/ https://www.anduril.com/article/anduril-s-lattice-a-trusted-... U.S. Customs and Border Patrol, for example, uses Lattice for land and maritime border security to autonomously identify, track, and detect people https://www.anduril.com/article/army-selects-anduril-and-palantir-to-deliver-titan/ https://www.anduril.com/article/army-selects-anduril-and-pal... TITAN is a vehicle-mounted expeditionary ground station that will accelerate and simplify the Army’s ability to access and process massive volumes of Space, High Altitude, Aerial, and Terrestrial sensors to provide actionable targeting information for enhanced mission command and long range precision fires. TITAN will reduce sensor-to-shooter timelines by enhancing the automation of target recognition and geolocation from multiple sensors [...] "and long range precision fires"
- mid-kid 3y agoI've seen a lot of articles about the Nix community lately and every single one is as vague as the next. Can someone summarize, to someone who hasn't partaken in any official Nix channels, what the catalyst of this was, if any? Or at least what sorts of actions/events have caused this discontent?
- chpatrick 3y agoAnduril is a big user of Nix and wanted to sponsor a conference, which upset some people because they're a part of the military industrial complex.
- rijoja 3y ago> "Much of the frustration has risen from inaction by authoritative figures. Whether inconsiderate sponsorship, conflicts of interest, harmful conduct, or a refusal to collaborate, these actions have repeatedly affirmed such positions of authority as the effective owners of Nix with no consequence." Right so the author of the post in question, is in favour of Nix taking sponsorship from Andruil, or against it?
- chpatrick 3y agoIt sounds like the author is annoyed that Anduril didn't get sent away (immediately) yes. As far as I know that was actually up to the conference organisers though, not the Nix project.
- rijoja 3y agoRight thanks for clearing that out!
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThe author of the post is saying that the problem is the sponsorship not considering the community. Their own opinion doesn't necessarily matter if they don't choose to be writing an opinion piece. They are partially writing an opinion piece, but not about their opinion about working with the military. They are writing about Nix leadership vs Nix community.
- infinisil 3y agoThis is a great post, very well said! Over the weekend I’ve been working with NixOS foundation members and other community members to address what you’re describing, and I’m happy to say that the foundation is very willing to delegate governance to the community! This kind of thing takes time to erect, but I’m doing my best to push this swiftly while trying to limit burnout. Stay tuned for a statement from the NixOS foundation this week!
- rijoja 3y agoMaybe if you're up to speed with the internal politics of the nix project. If you're not it reads like a lot of grandstanding, and asking people to resign, without giving concrete examples of what has gone wrong.
- Hugsun 3y agoI didn't know about these problems until now and this article didn't tell me anything besides that there are issues in the nix community. It's a bit like long form subtweeting.
- brabel 3y agoThis seems to be the new way people have decided to discuss polemic topics about their projects: avoid all mention of specific disagreements or god forbid people, and be as vague as possible about everything. Remember the Rust polemic where the entire Rust moderation team resigned? I was following the debate at the time and could barely understand what the actual problem was... only after reading A LOT of arguments in multiple websites I was able to kind of understand what was going on (here I am being vague myself, ha! If you know what that was all about, please comment, I don't feel like I can do it properly). What is this all about? Is it a particular person, or organization, being a troublemaker?? Is it one event? Many? Do you think your project's internal politics are some kind of "state secret" or what?? And by the way, why do Governments have so many secrets anyway!?!?! You've got to be up to no good to want to keep everything bloody hidden! For goodness' sake, just spit it out!! We can handle the truth.
- nebulous1 3y agoAs far as I can tell the core issue is that one of the larger corporate users of Nix is a US defence contractor called Anduril. Anduril were one of the sponsors of the 2024 NA NixCon, which is a official conference run by the NixOS foundation. The acceptance of this sponsorship has caused some conflict.
- taosx 3y agoNOT WORTH THE READ. All the posts that appeared recently on Nix have the same vague, over-politicized language where they are complaining that the person with most potential as a dictator is not one and they want more power to make decision in behalf of nixos. I feel for Dolstra, pain in the ....
- kreetx 3y agoAs a user of nix I most certainly will continue to use it, there isn't really any need to know about the community issues at all. I also don't think there is any reason to "fork it" either, just go to a forum or chat room where you can keep things technical and plow forward.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kkfx 3y agoNixOS generic user here: allow me to be a bit rude, NOT to light fire but to extinguish them: - apparently the current rupture came from a company sponsorship to a Nix Foundation conference, due to the fact this company (Anduril, a heavy NixOS user and contributor) is a mil-tech one, well... I doubt that's the reason. I know many with strong opinion to a point of leaving if some of their principle is touched or even discussed, but that's can't be a community-wide cause, nixpkgs is one of the largest package system of the world, hard to believe that it's community polarize around such event; - IMVHO the very issue is that Nix{,OS,pkgs} is a FLOSS project but itself it does not reflect a FLOSS one, having some "central" elements (the cache, github infra etc) that are more a commercial structure than a community owned one, and there is a big dispersion in current development: NixOps seems to be abandoned, Disnix is not a complete replacement, Flakes seems to be the future, but they are still experimental end not much documented, home-manager is still a separated things and so on, the hard-to-digest nix language does not help. Long story short it's not a matter of mil-tech, lack or abuse of authority but the fact that: - a commercial project have targets, a vision, all party involved do what they can to implement/reach the defined goals - a community project have a multitude of visions and targets, it change a bit a time, sometimes fast, sometimes slow, with many branches, sometimes competing sometimes cooperating, Unfortunately, to go the commercial project route we need a hierarchy, contracts and so on, to go the community project root we need a community-matching structure, central points, with people owning them do not works well. Now, having no official repo, build system etc is hard, some have proposed some tools, but they do not develop much and they do not perform much. I think the point is looking at a more classic FLOSS approach, an entity do the commercial aspects with an official release, while the larger slice of the community create independent hubs, there is not need to be all in the same place as long as the codebase start openly and openly evolve.
- rijoja 3y agoSo why not fork the project?
- kkfx 3y agoBecause there are some central points, for witch you need or a decentralized system (absent, so far) or big money to build another... That's the "hybrid model issue" I'm talking about. Shared binaries from /nix/store in a torrent-style setup might be feasible, but so far there is none. Similarly distributed build for large projects (LibreOffice, Firefox etc) might be possible, but so fare there is none. There are servers dedicated to that, paid for that. Not-so-small companies could pay. Public universities as well, but in the present world public uni do not even mirror anymore FLOSS projects, so... We need a distributed architecture to keep up FLOSS.
- weinzierl 3y agoThe NixOS foundation is a non-profit organization registered in the Netherlands. Since non-profit can mean a variety of things, maybe someone with more insight can explain a little bit. It would be especially interesting to know which of the various US 501 variants is closest to what the NixOS foundation is.
- barfbagginus 3y agoI've been reviewing some of the nix packages for apps I care about, including python and zotero. It's a little bit difficult to argue that these packages are much cleaner than the zotero or python packages you'd see in Debian, Arch, or Alpine. They're big balls of mud, exacerbated somewhat by nix's tendency to encourage inline expressions and shell scripts. This reintroduces a need to mentally interpret intermediate values, conflicting with easy audits - a big reason for declarative packaging in the first place. I've avoided adopting nix given that I didn't see a clear path towards cleaning up these kinds of packages. I wonder if this community shakeup could be an opportunity for a more literate and prosaic format for nix. If we're booting some of the long time chooms on account of them being socially regressive, what would you bet that they're also the reason for nix's seemingly "non-negotiable" technical debts? I guess we'll see! Here's hoping the fork will be a nicer place with cleaner codes.