3 ms·
"new concepts (for example functional programming)" New? Functional programming has been around since the 1960s. ML was first available in 1973. Haskell was fi
by dalke 14y ago
"new concepts (for example functional programming)"
New? Functional programming has been around since the 1960s. ML was first available in 1973. Haskell was first released in 1990. Even Python, a decidedly non-functional language, included the "map", "apply", and "reduce" builtins in its 1.0 release in 1991.
The author of the essay says that 45 is often considered "old fart" age.
Let's say someone was 25 when Backus presented "Can Programming Be Liberated From the von Neumann Style? A Functional Style and its Algebra of Programs" in 1977. That's 35 years ago, making them 60. Or perhaps the reference date should be when "Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs" came out in 1985? Making them 52 now.
(I picked age 25 since at age 20 they would be "out of nowhere, 22-year-old kids" you were talking about.)
By neither criteria is functional programming new enough that a 45 year should consider it a "new concept."
- adrianN 14y agoIf you take the existence of papers as a measure about what is relevant for an industry programmer, then I hope you are familiar with things like writing formal proofs using Coq and Isabelle (Coq started in the eighties), or generating programs directly from a specification.
- dalke 14y agoI don't. That's why I included SICP in 1985 as another reference point. Quoting from Wikipedia on "Functional Programming": Also in the 1970s, the development of Scheme (a partly functional dialect of Lisp), as described in the influential Lambda Papers and the 1985 textbook Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs, brought awareness of the power of functional programming to the wider programming-languages community. Even then, my own knowledge of functional programming started in the mid-1990s, as a physics grad student. It wasn't good knowledge, most assuredly, but enough that I am confident that a hot-shot young developer of 1990 would know the basics about as well as a hot-shot young developer now. Oh, and I even remember my advisor coming in one day exclaiming that we should all learn Dylan; that it was the new, elegant language of the future. ("About as well" because there 1) there's more documented experience with functional programming, and 2) there are many more developers now, so statistical distributions say that there are going to be a few more people now who know it better than they did then.)