5 ms·
I think what bugs me about comments like yours is the mentality that the labels must fail. Why? If you want to support local indie bands, go see local indie sho
by tedunangst 15y ago
I think what bugs me about comments like yours is the mentality that the labels must fail. Why? If you want to support local indie bands, go see local indie shows. Do we really think its not enough for me to win, my enemies must lose?
I apologize if I'm projecting an attitude into your comments that's not there, I may be reacting to a general trend and not your comment specifically.
- tikhonj 14y agoThe argument isn't that the labels "must fail", it's that they must give up trying to create artificial scarcity. The problem isn't the labels, it's their behavior. People implicitly (or explicitly) believe that changing this behavior will cause them to fail, but the main point isn't about their failing. In fact, the best outcome would be the label's succeeding despite giving up on the current business model.
- res0nat0r 14y ago> they must give up trying to create artificial scarcity. How are they trying to create this artificial scarcity? Many if not all the major labels have a lot of their artists music available via digital formats like iTunes and Amazon, etc. They just have the crazy idea that if you want to listen to their artists music whether it be via a CD, 12" or MP3 that you should pay them for it.
- tikhonj 14y agoWell, first there is no question that they're trying to create scarcity: you can create nearly infinite copies of information for basically 0 cost, and they want that to become difficult. Secondly, it's artificial because they're leveraging the government to enforce it. If they took no action, there would be no scarcity. Therefore it is artificial. Contrast this with, say, physical goods: even if the manufacturer does nothing about limiting the distribution of whatever you purchased, it would still be scarce because making copies requires significant resources. Fundamentally, economics is about managing scarcity. The main reason you pay for some resource is because it is scarce. So their "crazy idea" is exactly that: creating scarcity.
- res0nat0r 14y agoI still don't see how they are trying to do this when about all of the major labels let you buy their music via iTunes, Amazon, Rhapsody, Spotify, etc...
- tikhonj 14y agoScarcity is a limit in resources. The music labels are using the government to limit their songs by stopping you from creating copies. Without these restrictions you would be able to make an effective unbounded number of copies because each copy has a resource cost of basically zero--there would be no scarcity. With these restrictions, you can only make as many copies as the labels allow you to, which means the number of copies is bounded. I should note that this is orthogonal to whether you think they are justified in seeking to be paid for their songs: in either case, they ensure being paid by making the songs more scarce using copyright.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoOne of the most important concepts in economics is scarcity[1]. It is what drives the whole supply/demand cycle. When somebody says the labels are trying to create artificial scarcity, the logic is this: A. High demand, low supply raises prices. If I reduce the supply, I can increase the price (up to a certain limit). B. Music has high demand. Music labels have controlled supply for years, giving us the "normal" pricing for CDs. C. With the Internet, the incremental supply costs go to zero. Supply is also infinite (anybody can create a copy), so the price drops to zero. D. The only way to keep the price above zero is to create a scarcity that doesn't actually exist. The labels have done this by fighting putting anything online, suing people who copy files, getting the government to criminally try a class of people who copy and using DRM to prevent copying. The whole goal of all of this is to introduce a scarcity into the product so people will pay. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarcity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarcity
- res0nat0r 14y agoI don't think I'd define the labels requiring you to pay them for their artists creative output as enforcing scarcity...