12 ms·
The Ivy League and other elite private colleges are losing esteem
- bugglebeetle 3y agoOne of the worst, most embarrassing mistakes one can make as they age is to believe themselves so wise as to offer up unsolicited advice to the young.
- makeitshine 3y agoThe only advice you can give the young is unsolicited. They'll never ask for it because they already believe they know everything. I'm fully aware my reply is ridiculous, much like what I was responding to.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoThat wasn’t my experience at all. Most people who gave me advice unsolicited gave me bad advice, while those I sought out were hesitant to steer me, but what they did provide, was quite valuable.
- makeitshine 3y agoYou likely get a lot of unsolicited advice you don't recognize as such. Be kind to people, look both ways before crossing the street, be honest, eat healthier, workout more, etc...
- bugglebeetle 3y agoThat’s mixing together a broad set of things I wouldn’t consider aa advice, so much as basic socialization. Potty training toddlers is not giving them advice.
- parpfish 3y agoonce I hit 40, I noticed that I became far more receptive to giving and receiving advice. I used to think old people gave advice because they were know-it-alls, but now I think it’s just because it can take a while to really understand that experience is valuable
- hehdhdjehehegwv 3y agoI don’t think you should even be allowed to vote past 40.
- jp_sc 3y agoFunny, I was thinking the same for the people under 30
- bruceb 3y agoWhen the richest and most powerful start sending their kids to public school then I might believe this. Until then the title makes for good clickbait but nothing believable. This tweet I read earlier today lays out the case: "The best reason to go to a top 10 American university: In a random class you'll have a governor's daughter, the son of a billionaire and two guys with 170+ IQ. It's a hell of a group of people to mingle with to succeed in life. I'm super anti-university but I'll admit that this alone probably makes those schools worth it.." https://twitter.com/orrdavid/status/1784703997808455849 https://twitter.com/orrdavid/status/1784703997808455849
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThe richest can pay 20x more for something only slightly better and genuinely think it's a great deal. You can't.
- DrFalkyn 3y agoBut if you make friends with those rich kids may open opportunities you would not otherwise have.
- nytesky 3y agoBut is it easy for a lower economic state kid to befriend rich kids? They do come from different worlds, and even the activities (skiing for a weekend, taking taxis to concerts, etc) can divide you. This was partly my experience, though it never entered my mind to try and befriend “rich kids” but I think my choice of activities (think LAN parties vs poker games with real money), my time spent in a campus job, not knowing how to ski or have money for a trip, definitely narrowed my friendship opportunities.
- rblatz 3y agoIt’s always been the network, and it always will be. I went to a public university, all my friends and roommates are doing well, but none of them have started a company worth more than a million or so. Some are director level at big tech companies, but none are exec level.
- Imnimo 3y agoI don't buy a lot of this analysis. >This week, for instance, Google — despite probably being the most progressive or Silicon Valley company, nevertheless fired dozens of employees involved in pro-Palestine/anti-Israel protests that resemble those on university campuses. I find it extremely hard to believe that Google is going to start not wanting to hire MIT grads because MIT has a protest encampment. This sort of thing might make sense to someone with a political axe to grind, but it strikes me as completely out of touch with reality. I interview a lot of candidates for highly technical positions. I cannot imagine a frame of mind where I would worry that someone with a Harvard degree is "More likely to hold strong political opinions that will distract from their work". Even if you believe this is somehow unique to graduates of private universities, Google fired 28 people over protests. Out of nearly 200k. There's just no possibility that worrying about this is justified.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> hard to believe that Google is going to start not wanting to hire MIT grads because MIT has a protest encampment There was a time when Google wouldn't consider a candidate if they weren't from MIT. The loss of that monopoly is the point. You aren't disadvantaged going to MIT today relative to a few decades ago. You're just not as relatively advantaged as you once were.
- Imnimo 3y agoI'm extremely skeptical that this shift has anything to do with protest encampments and coddling concerns.
- wredue 3y agoIt has everything to do with explosive growth in IT jobs, definitely nowhere near enough MIT grads to fill probably just googles growth, plus other things, none of which has anything to do with alt-right conspiracy theorist Nate silver claims.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> skeptical that this shift has anything to do with protest encampments and coddling concerns I am as well. I'm less sceptical of (a) the partisan shift in the value of elite education and (b) the effect per se.
- DrFalkyn 3y agoI'd say its the exception that you should not go Ivy/elite if you get in. Ivy Leagues have experiences/opportunities that simply are not replicated at state schools. Yes for determined/driven individuals, it may not matter all that much. And if you are not going to take advantage of what those elites have to offer, maybe you should reconsider if the financial burden is too high.
- hehdhdjehehegwv 3y agoAnd the resumé boost is for life.
- jacobn 3y agoUnless of course: “Public perceptions of higher education have declined rapidly, and I expect the problems to get worse.” turns out to be the case (Which it probably won’t)
- wredue 3y agoIt absolutely is the case for Nate, who has a vested interest in attacking education.
- titanomachy 3y agoWhat vested interest is that?
- wredue 3y agoHe gets paid to be an alt-right mouth piece.
- onion2k 3y agoI don't think that's really true, and if it is I don't think it's an advantage you'd actually want to use later in life. Based of my experience of hiring over the past 25 years (as someone hiring people, not as a candidate), my belief now is that your university degree is important for about a decade, has diminishing returns over the next few years, and then it's basically irrelevant. If you've got 15 years of relevant experience what degree you have and where it's from makes no difference to a good company. The exception is somewhat antagonistic too - if you still believe it's important (e.g you come to an interview and talk about how great Cambridge is) that's a signal you're not going to be a good hire. Obviously there are many caveats to this - I don't have an elite university degree, I'm not in the US, I've only ever hired developers, I've never worked in a business that needed people with elite university degrees, the number of people I've hired is a tiny sample of the industry, etc. I suspect people who think elite degrees are important are mostly other people who have an elite degree, and often those people are the ones who make it into hiring manager positions or higher. In that case it kind of does matter, but only if you want to work in a company where an elite university degree counts for more than experience, and I'm pretty sure you don't.
- afavour 3y agoI think I agree with Nate’s advice (skip the Ivies, go to a good state school) but I don’t agree with the reasons why. I don’t think elite private colleges are losing esteem at all (the recent noise about pro-Palestinian protests will be forgotten five minutes after they stop, just like all the other campus protest movements in decades past, this isn’t new!), I just think the economic argument is getting harder and harder to make.
- anothernewdude 3y agoI think they are losing esteem, but some silly protests aren't why. The selection process itself is deeply, deeply flawed and interacts poorly with incentives for education. Feedback on performance is muddled up with the effects of networking with monied up people. Not much of this is positive. Their ability to hire and the amount of money they have still is, I suppose. Assuming those are focused on teaching, though, which I doubt.
- afavour 3y agoNetworking with monied people is still a perk for sure. But I wonder (jokingly but not completely jokingly) if you’d be better off spending 1/10 of the cost going to Burning Man every year with index cards of rich inheritees to hunt down.
- bsder 3y agoMaybe not Burning Man, but probably Coachella and SXSW.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoThe selection process at most highly competitive schools is flawed, but the Ivy League universities still get the best students, in general.
- anothernewdude 3y agoAnd if you get the best students, then do you need to bother to provide the best education? If your students are going to achieve good results anyway? Might the quality of that education become suspect, if it lacks incentives to improve, since the branding largely carries everything?
- hilux 3y agoThat is such a confused spaghetti of arguments, I don't even know where to start. One thing is clear (to me, if not to Nate): people don't base their decision to attend Harvard, Stanford, Columbia, or UChicago based on popularity polls of the unwashed masses. And the same goes for the recruiting teams at Google, Goldman, etc.
- wakawaka28 3y agoOne thing is clear to me (if not to you): These schools live on their reputations, and if you have to rely on biases of alumni of similar gilded brainwashing centers to make it worthwhile, it truly is not worth the money. Also, people who call everyone who didn't go to get annointed at such a money pit "unwashed" are so far up their own asses that they cannot possibly grasp what a waste of money it was to go there in the first place.
- hilux 3y ago(1) You don't understand sarcasm. (2) For those of us who work for a living, brand matters. That's not my choice, it's the real world. (3) It's not a "waste of money" if it costs much less than going to a state school, which it does for most poor and middle-class people.
- wakawaka28 3y ago(1) If you think what you wrote sounds sarcastic, you don't understand sarcasm either. (2) Agreed. Which is exactly why these various Ivy League brands need to be concerned about their appearance. Maybe if they didn't cost $100k per year and up, they would not be under such scrutiny. (3) I reckon if you can qualify for any significant discounted admission at an Ivy League school, you can get a full scholarship and/or awesome financial aid at a number of excellent state schools. So the value isn't in it for poor kids. As for rich kids, well, just because they have the money doesn't mean they want to waste it on a school that is just not worth it. I'm sure these schools' reputations aren't quite bad enough to discourage the rich from going, but let's see how bad they let it get.
- jnwatson 3y agoHarvey Mudd will cost $93K this upcoming year. Virginia Tech will cost $41K (in state). It is tough to justify a 2.3x difference in price.
- echelon 3y ago> Virginia Tech will cost $41K (in state). It's hard to justify that sticker price too.
- Aunche 3y agoI see 37k, which includes room, board, and some modest personal spending. https://www.vt.edu/admissions/undergraduate/cost.html https://www.vt.edu/admissions/undergraduate/cost.html
- echelon 3y agoHoly shit, that's for one year. You're paying the sticker price of a brand new car every single year. This is bonkers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 3y agoYeah but after considering tons of financial aid , scholarships, discounts, forbearance plans, and other aid, it's not as bad as the 93k sticker price suggests. No one is writing a check for 93k. In return you get a degree with considerable earning power that pays off from higher wages that increase with inflation, whereas student loan payments are fixed and amortized over a decade.
- threeseed 3y agoMore nonsense from Nate Silver. As he himself points out the decline in esteem is being driven by a general distrust of all institutions amongst certain elements on the right. But what he fails to mention is that most of these people aren't in positions of power e.g. hiring and thus their opinions aren't all that relevant. If you go to an Ivy League school you statistically will get a higher paying job, have a better chance of getting into YC and other such programs and generally lead a better life. And for most that is what is important - not the education. And he has provided no data to show it is changing.
- yieldcrv 3y agoall exclusive things are getting panned right now amusingly, people still want access and it conveys social benefits and they still are nice clubs
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoHaven't read the article yet, but: if I know anything about human nature is a lot of people always want to improve, do better, etc and they will just throw money at anyone who promises them that. This aspect will not change.
- nostromo 3y agoIt's kinda crazy just how untouchable Israel is in the US politically. TikTok can spread all sorts of craziness amongst America's youth for years -- but the second politicians find out it's being used to oppose Israel's actions in Gaza, it's banned by congress and the president (which is of course still pending). Ivy Leagues can spend years promoting very radical ideas and kicking out people left and right for wrongthink -- but the moment they stand up for very permissive free speech (finally) it happens to be on the wrong issue and boom, they're fired. Student protests for good and bad reasons have been going on forever. But suddenly the media is very concerned with student protests being ill thought out in a way they haven't been before. If you asked me if Israel still had this much pull in America, I'd have said not they don't. But obviously I was very wrong.
- threeseed 3y agoTikTok isn't banned. They are just being forced to operate it as a US company. And given we have whistleblowers who say they were providing information to the Chinese government and odd data like below it doesn't seem particularly unreasonable. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GMAVQ5VXsAE1weD?format=jpg&name=medium https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GMAVQ5VXsAE1weD?format=jpg&name=...
- mistermann 3y ago> They are just being forced to operate it as a US company. Can you explain the role the word "just" is playing in your statement, and how you determined it to be true?
- nostromo 3y agoNone of that is new. What changed is that politicians didn't like the messages being sent on TikTok. And, yes, the act calls for it to be banned unless it's divested. That's still a ban.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> They are just being forced to operate it as a US company They are being strongly encouraged / coerced to operate as a non-Chinese controlled company. If they were controlled by a company in France, India or Brazil, that would be fine. Failing that, TikTok would be removed from app stores (and U.S. hosting). They are still free to do business in America. And TikTok.com will cleanly resolve. (Unlike e.g. Facebook in China.)
- pietz 3y agoExcuse my ignorance but was it ever about the higher level of quality in education with the schools? I honestly thought the "getting in" aspect was the most important one.
- paulpauper 3y agothis is true. hard to fail but way very hard to get into Harvard.
- WCSTombs 3y agoWhat you get out depends on what you put in. Yes, you can skate through some of the top schools, but if on the other hand you want a top-tier education, you will definitely get it there.
- ryandrake 3y agoYou know what they call someone who graduates with a D average from Harvard? "A Harvard Graduate." The name brand itself opens the doors, I don't think too many care whether or not you skated through.
- WCSTombs 3y agoI can only give you one data point, but I went to one of these "elite" universities (many years ago), and the quality of education I found there was really incredible. I honestly would not trade that for anything.
- sandspar 3y agoI'm reading the comments here and it's remarkable how few people seem to have felt the vibe shift. The vibe began shifting like a year and a half ago and it's getting more widespread by the day. Zoomer males, future leaders, are thinking very different thoughts from the rest of society.
- TeaBrain 3y agoThe vibe shift from whom? The ivy league acceptance rates have continued to trend downward over the last decade because more gen z are applying every year.
- edanm 3y agoI mean, the vibe might be shifting. But if you're thinking it began to shift only a year and a half ago, I think that's why you might feel you're out of whack with other people here. The case against universities, against higher education, against ivy leagues etc, has been a topic of conversation for years. Most of my life I think. I don't know how many pieces I've read about why higher education is now going to become less relevant.
- sandspar 3y agoMany parts of the underground started going to the overground about that time. The stuff that only weirdos talked about eight years ago is becoming common parlance.
- ken47 3y agoIf they're losing esteem, it's because of the purity of education is fading. First, tuitions are becoming outrageous. The mixture of profit motive and higher education has an unpleasant odor. Then, there are the numerous academic integrity scandals among now-infamous scholars at Ivies or similar, such as Marc Tessier-Lavigne, Dan Ariely, etc., and a general feeling that the overwhelming pressure for novel discoveries / getting published in a big journal is undermining scientific progress. Also, there is a perception that students are increasingly selected for reasons other than academic merit, e.g. family name / an ancestor who was an alumnus, big donations, athletic vs. scholarly ability, and so on. Rich parents buying their kids' admissions through sports "recruitment" was particularly egregious. Asian students with perfect SAT's and AP/IB-loaded 4.0+ GPA's being rejected for "non-racist" "reasons," as revealed by "Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard" and other top-tier American universities was a cherry on top.
- paulpauper 3y agoWhy something could happen is not the same as it happening. There are a lot of reasons for elite schools to lose prestige, but it's not happening or no evidence. Lesser-ranked schools also have those problems, so elite schools still stand out.
- ken47 3y agoIf you're going to compare them to lesser ranked schools, sure. But the feeling is that, if a rising tide lifts all boat, the tide has been falling in this case, and top-ranked schools have a lot more to lose.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI think that Silver’s view of state schools is a bit rosy due to growing up as a child of a Big Ten university professor. The Big Ten schools and the UC system stand apart from all other state schools when it comes to research dollars spent. They give up nothing to the Ivies in terms of opportunity on campus. After graduating, though? It’s less clear to me.
- chmod600 3y agoHow are these kinds of self-reinforcing systems usually brought down? I doubt some shifts in the opinions of normal people are going to stop the elite flywheel -- there's just not enough connection between a machinist in Ohio or a nurse in Phoenix and the elite for their opinions to matter. The Ivy League can fall apart one of two ways: 1. The levers of power move around to new groups of people radically enough that the jobs that were once elite are now irrelevant and forgotten, like a guild for some forgotten craft. AI is obviously one way this might happen, where many elite professions might just collapse. 2. Internal bickering over identity that just makes it impossible for normal people to attend. Think crazy stuff like requiring graduates to share their income for life with other graduates, or requiring some weird kind of binding pledge about who you can work for. Colleges already have a weird possessiveness over their graduates, this just takes that to the logical next level.
- relaxing 3y ago> Think crazy stuff like Who is doing this?
- alexitorg 3y agoThe key point in the article is that the polling shows that respect for universities has fallen, and fallen quickly since 2016. It obviously isn't just about Israel, as it happened well before 2023. I put it down to a number of factors: -The replication crisis -Divergence of "Social Justice Leftism" (for want of better words) over main stream liberal and conservative ideals at universities. -over production of degree holders, creating a shortage of trades people and graduates who can't get jobs. You have many graduates who prefer to work in unskilled jobs rather than retraining into trades. -Increased expense of university. On average most attending university are better off. But there are a lot of people worse off. -Disappointing returns on research at universities. Commercial and Industry specific labs have a much greater return on investment, but the narrative has been about needing to invest in universities. I'd like to see less places funded at universities. Less research funded at universities. More funding for research elsewhere. Pre registration of studies become the norm or mandatory (i.e. say before you do the work what you are looking to test in the data you collect). More prestige and funding for trade schools.