3 ms·

there may be an important divergence implied by this essay .. people here ask about using an LLM.. but the essay refers to "different photographs of the same sc

there may be an important divergence implied by this essay .. people here ask about using an LLM.. but the essay refers to "different photographs of the same scene from different photographers" or other personal collection items that are related but subjective or not-authoritative There is a rush in public to condense and summarize many authoritative publications to find patterns, or to replace a human expert with automated results.. yet that is fundamentally different than taking multiple incomplete perspectives to add to a human library-owners knowledge and investigations. It is subtle to speak it but not subtle in its implications.. taking "data as facts" and condensing them or reordering them or rewriting an output based on them, using automation, is different than a human mind taking in many inputs for human mind knowledge and enabling new outputs from a human author.

_bramses 3y ago
> There is a rush in public to condense and summarize many authoritative publications to find patterns, or to replace a human expert with automated results.. yet that is fundamentally different than taking multiple incomplete perspectives to add to a human library-owners knowledge and investigations. It is subtle to speak it but not subtle in its implications.. taking "data as facts" and condensing them or reordering them or rewriting an output based on them, using automation, is different than a human mind taking in many inputs for human mind knowledge and enabling new outputs from a human author. You nailed it! Thanks for noticing the divergence!
- walterbell 3y ago
  There's lots of interesting work that came out of BCL in 1960s, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_Computer_Laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_Computer_Laboratory > The focus of research at BCL was systems theory and specifically the area of self-organizing systems, bionics, and bio-inspired computing; that is, analyzing, formalizing, and implementing biological processes using computers. BCL was inspired by the ideas of Warren McCulloch and the Macy Conferences, as well as many other thinkers in the field of cybernetics. On cybernetics, https://www.pangaro.com/definition-cybernetics.html https://www.pangaro.com/definition-cybernetics.html > Artificial Intelligence (AI) grew from a desire to make computers smart, whether smart like humans or just smart in some other way. Cybernetics grew from a desire to understand and build systems that can achieve goals.. it connects control (actions taken in hope of achieving goals) with communication (connection and information flow between the actor and the environment).. Later, Gordon Pask offered conversation as the core interaction of systems that have goals.

_bramses 3y ago

> There is a rush in public to condense and summarize many authoritative publications to find patterns, or to replace a human expert with automated results.. yet that is fundamentally different than taking multiple incomplete perspectives to add to a human library-owners knowledge and investigations. It is subtle to speak it but not subtle in its implications.. taking "data as facts" and condensing them or reordering them or rewriting an output based on them, using automation, is different than a human mind taking in many inputs for human mind knowledge and enabling new outputs from a human author. You nailed it! Thanks for noticing the divergence!

walterbell 3y ago
There's lots of interesting work that came out of BCL in 1960s, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_Computer_Laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_Computer_Laboratory > The focus of research at BCL was systems theory and specifically the area of self-organizing systems, bionics, and bio-inspired computing; that is, analyzing, formalizing, and implementing biological processes using computers. BCL was inspired by the ideas of Warren McCulloch and the Macy Conferences, as well as many other thinkers in the field of cybernetics. On cybernetics, https://www.pangaro.com/definition-cybernetics.html https://www.pangaro.com/definition-cybernetics.html > Artificial Intelligence (AI) grew from a desire to make computers smart, whether smart like humans or just smart in some other way. Cybernetics grew from a desire to understand and build systems that can achieve goals.. it connects control (actions taken in hope of achieving goals) with communication (connection and information flow between the actor and the environment).. Later, Gordon Pask offered conversation as the core interaction of systems that have goals.