3 ms·
How much responsibility does Tesla have in attempting to encourage willfully irresponsible and negligent humans to be less so? Or are we all beholden to the low
by toomuchtodo 3y ago
How much responsibility does Tesla have in attempting to encourage willfully irresponsible and negligent humans to be less so? Or are we all beholden to the lowest common denominator.
The warnings are clear when enabling the driver assistance system. You are responsible. Pay attention. If you don’t, you’re liable. Any Tesla drivers who say otherwise are a combination of ignorant and liars.
- silverquiet 3y agoMaybe they should call it something like "driver assistance system" rather than "full self driving"? I've never driven a Tesla, so I'm not aware of what warnings are in place, but doesn't it seem reasonable to think that a full self driving system could fully self drive the car? Perhaps it is Tesla who is lying if the car is not capable of driving itself fully?
- qsdf38100 3y agoThis "Full Self Driving" thing is absurd. It should already be illegal to sell "Self Driving" cars that are 0% responsible for any crash. But Elon thought it wasn’t enough and decided to go Full Hypocrisy and called it "Full Self Driving". What a joke.
- sorokod 3y agoI guess that the outcomes of these lawsuits will tell. I'd phrase your question differently though: how much responsibility does Tesla have in selling a mass consumer product that allows consumers to be irresponsible and negligent in a friction-less manner.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoConsumers are already irresponsible (DUIs, road rage, inattentive driving), how is Tesla making it worse with a system that aggressively determines attention via camera and wheel torque? Should they not sell to irresponsible drivers based on their driving record and insurance scoring? I’d tolerate that if it meant responsible drivers don’t get dragged down by the low to median quality driver.
- sorokod 3y agoI am not obliged to contribute to Tesla's business plan and strategy, the question is about a legal obligation, not profit maximization.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAgreed; hopefully the law rules for the responsible, not the irresponsible. But this is America, so could go either way unfortunately.
- FireBeyond 3y agoHow do you define "responsible" in this context to represent Tesla? Tesla has had to be dragged kicking and screaming into compliance for safety issue after safety issue: Early AP/FSD required a hand on the steering wheel only once every FIFTEEN MINUTES. Tesla was the cause of the requirement to consider an incident "within 5 seconds" of an AP/FSD disengagement to be considered for those factors. Tesla was the last manufacturer to implement cabin monitoring. (I despise them too, for the record) Musk has said that he'd have Tesla pay a fine for every vehicle shipped just to avoid having the airbag warning on sunvisors. Many other tales abound, from component firmware developers being aghast that when shipping new firmware to Tesla that had a 36 hour test suite and cycle, that they'd get emails 3-4 hours later that said "looks great, thanks" and would explain that they "just flashed it onto a car they had and took it for a drive".
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThese actions have not incurred a material number of deaths. Zero deaths is unattainable, a handful are tolerable. https://www.tesladeaths.com/ https://www.tesladeaths.com/
- FireBeyond 3y agoPretty bold of you to decide people who were killed (particularly non-Tesla owners) because of issues with drivers using Tesla's barely competent (at BEST) software are "tolerable".
- Veserv 3y agoThe standard is not prominently advertising the opposite of what the manual and fine-print say. People regularly do not read the manual. People regularly do not read warning messages. Everybody knows that. Claiming that you have cleared up confusion because you wrote a warning message that says the opposite of the advertising you created is deliberate and calculated deception. NOBODY in that room made an honest mistake: "Oh my goodness, I thought people read and carefully consider warning messages." BULLSHIT. Everybody knows this is pure legal head-up-ass-covering. Twisting ethics into a pretzel to come up with implausible excuses for such blatant deception is just plain absurd.