3 ms·
Ha! That's actually... not a terrible idea. It's not really clear that it serves any societal purpose to have trading all day long. It's just a lot of traders
by crazygringo 3y ago
Ha! That's actually... not a terrible idea.
It's not really clear that it serves any societal purpose to have trading all day long. It's just a lot of traders super glued to the news and trying to react instantly. And trades take a couple of days to settle anyways.
I'm really curious if anyone can point to important economic efficiences that would be lost if trading was restricted to two 15-minute windows per day.
- lucianbr 3y agoWouldn't it be more relevant to reduce the time it takes to settle trades? That seems anachronistic, like sending checks by snailmail. We have so many computers in the 21st century, and most money is digital already. Does settling/clearing on a delay actually serve a purpose, or just enables someone to collect rent?
- collinmcnulty 3y agoIt serves the purpose of bringing all the market participants together to have the deepest market at the time of trading. This prevents pricing swings based on who happens to want to trade right this minute. Trading more frequently actually allows brokers to collect rents in the form of a spread for the “service” of buying from you now and selling to me later. If we had a daily auction, we could avoid the need for such a broker spread.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSupporting citation: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-04-29/stocks-trade-for-390-minutes-a-day-increasingly-only-10-matter https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-04-29/stocks-tr... | https://archive.today/C5LVD https://archive.today/C5LVD ("Bloomberg: Stocks Trade for 390 Minutes a Day. Increasingly, Only 10 Matter")
- tonfa 3y ago> Does settling/clearing on a delay actually serve a purpose, or just enables someone to collect rent? It removes friction from the market since it gives time to line things up between market participants. For example if some assets are on loan, it gives time to the people who were borrowing it to find some other market participant to borrow it from. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-02-28/trading-stock-takes-time https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-02-28/tradin... was a good explainer
- lucianbr 3y agoIt's funny that the article explaining why it is good and necessary to have T+2 settlement also mentions that markets are moving to T+1 settlement. To me that seems like a contradiction. Must be my cluelessness talking.
- tonfa 3y agoIt's going to be a tradeoff in any case (T+2 requires more collateral but gives more times to line things up for settlement)
- xhkkffbf 3y agoWhile I also agree that there are downsides to keeping the exchange constantly churning, I worry that it's hard to align the open moments with the times when market-shifting news arrives. We can't expect the Bhopal plant to explode just in the 15 minutes when Dow Chemical is active. Still, I agree that we need to think again about the focus on hyper liquidity. When I see high speed trading, I feel like it's just an endless competition to steal the bid-ask spread from the suckers who are actually trading.
- pavlov 3y ago> “I worry that it's hard to align the open moments with the times when market-shifting news arrives. We can't expect the Bhopal plant to explode just in the 15 minutes when Dow Chemical is active.” With the current system there’s only a 27% chance that global news arrives when the world’s most important market is open. It’s practically a completely arbitrary number. So it might be more fair to everyone to either reduce the number to a minimum, or expand it to as close to 100% as possible.
- crazygringo 3y agoBut that's the whole point -- that most news doesn't happen during trading. That you have ample time to digest the news from overnight to trade in the morning, and ample time to digest the news from the day to trade at the end of the day. There's definitely importance for prices to change daily in response to news. I'm questioning any economic or societal need for prices to change by the second/minute, or even hour, in response to news. All it does is funnel some extra profits to professional traders who watch the markets and are subscribed to every news alert, and disadvantage everyone else who just stays on top of industry/market news like a normal person.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoIt would be annoying from a user perspective because i would have to be at a computer for only those fifteen minutes when i wanted to rebalance my portfolio or risk automated buys and sells working properly. it would probably change the value/ reaction to information assymetry which might be good or bad. It would probably decrease opportunity for me to buy stocks i like at a lower price by sitting on bids and waiting for the random walk to push the price down to my bid just due to noise.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLimit orders. Can always modify your order for the next trade window if something unexpected occurs wrt price action, preventing order fulfillment.