5 ms·
Why Germany ditched nuclear before coal–and why it won't go back
- dsq 3y agoGermany, unlike France, the UK or the US, has no nuclear wrapons program. Therefore there is no dual use incentive to keep the civilian program running. Japan, it is true, also has no (active) weapons program, but has kept its civilian program going so far.
- ein0p 3y agoJapan has the capability to spin up such a program within months, and ability to further enrich uranium. And because it has this ability, with tensions in Southeast Asia rising, I think it’ll use it in the coming decade. You don’t maintain your own ultra expensive space industry for any other reason.
- Voultapher 3y ago> You don’t maintain your own ultra expensive space industry for any other reason. Except the kind of rockets they've been designing would make for terrible ICBMs. Take for example the recent H3 a hydrogen powered booster. For weapons you want solid or maybe hypergolic propellants that can be stored and ready to fire for long time periods. Liquid hydrogen would be an awful choice for that.
- ein0p 3y agoYes, but the gap between that and ICBMs is much narrower than between no rockets at all and ICBMs. Japan can’t have ICBMs at all, their armed forces are entirely defense oriented by treaty. So they build what they can, because no treaty lasts forever.
- Grimeton 3y agoThe whole article is ideological tainted and tries to make the move away from nuclear look good. That's all there is to it, especially in the light of the recently made public documents that show that the decision was taken by an ideologically blinded minister for economic affairs against the better judgment and suggestions by the experts. The damage to Germany's economy is already visible and will become worse as this goes on while the minister for economic affairs stated in a speech that this was anticipated and is part of the plan. Whatever that plan is.
- davidhbolton 3y agoNo mention of the fraud involved in pushing Germany to phase out Nuclear? https://dailysceptic.org/2024/04/27/new-document-release-reveals-greens-engaging-in-fraud-to-deceive-ministers-and-push-german-nuclear-phase-out/ https://dailysceptic.org/2024/04/27/new-document-release-rev...
- Arnt 3y agoAmazing what people will write. The minster asked the nuclear operators whether they could operate the plants longer, and the operators said (paraphrasing) "we'd need more fuel, and even if we were to order fuel today it wouldn't be delivered in time" and that was the end of the story. Two years later, "fraud!" Amazing.
- Grimeton 3y agoThey actually wrote and I'm paraphrasing as well:"It's not a problem and it would also lower the overall power prices as the cheaper nuclear power would push the gas plants out of the merit order system." But this was never communicated to Habeck (Minister for economic affairs) [1] And in the department of the environment a report was completely altered from "can run for years" to "is impossible to use them at all" by a single person that shares the ideology... [2][3] Interesting how official documents that have been made available clearly show how experts have been ignored and their reports have been altered to fit a political and ideological scheme. [1] - https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-03_BMWKFachreferat.pdf https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-03_BMWKFachreferat.... [2] - https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-01_Atomaufsicht_Version1.pdf https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-01_Atomaufsicht_Ver... [3] - https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-03_Atomaufsicht_Version2.pdf https://assets.cicero.de/2024-04/2022-03-03_Atomaufsicht_Ver...
- Arnt 3y agoI think this article looks for sense and a plan where there is none. I think it's simpler: Fukushima changed the political landscape so that there no longer was a majority in favour, and the use-by dates on the existing power plants expired. Coal also hasn't a majority in favour, but the use-by dates are different, so it's fading out of use in a different manner, rather slowly.
- V__ 3y agoThis is the correct answer. There were upcoming elections, and the acting government was afraid of loosing votes to the Greens due to the shift in public opinion. The decision was made, nobody wanted to reverse it. Additionally, it turned out, that the extension was unnecessary while costing millions. The fact is, that nuclear in its current form has no future. It's too expensive, takes too long to build, and it's unpopular. Maybe SMRs or other new forms will change that in the near future.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- wkat4242 3y agoAnd it's hugely expensive decommissioning isn't even factored into the business model (because then it would be even less viable), the state is left cleaning up the mess.
- epups 3y agoThe article makes it sound like it was ultimately a great decision, because now coal use is at historically low levels while renewables have been increasing. What it neglected to mention is that if nuclear had remained there, the share of coal would have directly and proportionally decreased. To achieve a 5% switch from very dirty to clean energy would be a spectacular feat, and the Germans achieved the opposite when closing their still perfectly usable nuclear plants very recently.
- uecker 3y agoGermany did not achieve "the opposite". Use of fossil fuels and CO2 emissions are constantly decreasing. But it is true that keeping existing nuclear plants running longer would have been good idea. But if one wants to complain about the past, why not complain that we collectively did not invest more in renewables earlier? In contrast to nuclear power, which did not become cheaper despite substantial investments, investments in renewables brought prices down substantially.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DrGeneNelson 3y agoHere's an update and added context to the Cicero Magazin article about Vice-Chancellor Robert Habeck: "Top German Greens officials accused of deception in nuclear phase-out advice" - After months of obstructions, a German high court forces the German government to disclose key internal memoranda regarding a nuclear phase-out following the Russian attack of Ukraine at the end of February, 2022. By Gene Nelson, Ph.D. April 28, 2024 https://tinyurl.com/Greens-fraud https://tinyurl.com/Greens-fraud There will be additional developments in this story.