4 ms·
EVs are only practical if you have a garage and can charge it overnight. (Outdoor chargers don't work because thieves steal the copper wires.)
by WalterBright 3y ago
EVs are only practical if you have a garage and can charge it overnight.
(Outdoor chargers don't work because thieves steal the copper wires.)
- bdcravens 3y agoI agree. I didn't buy my first EV until I bought my house. (And now we are all in, a two-EV household)
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoI have a garage and I made a conscious decision to buy an ICE car over a BEV, even though I could afford it. Last time I ran the numbers is was 8 to 10 years before I hit break for an ICE vs an equivalent EV (in feature set that I cared about) given my driving habits and operating costs for either. And there's some electrical work that needs to be done to properly support charging a BEV without juggling what's drawing power when all the time. Upgrades to happen either way but they'd have to be rushed if I had bought a BEV, vs taking the time over the next few years. So at least to for my situation it makes more sense to stick to ICE for now. If the BEV evangelists are right and battery prices drop down to the point where the purchase price of a BEV is the same as an ICE, then it makes more sense to wait. Buy ICE now, get everything in place, evaluate everything again in a few years.
- D13Fd 3y agoThis math works as long as you don’t care about your personal contribution to climate change.
- WalterBright 3y agoI remember from the Obama "cash for clunkers" that the CO2 emissions from constructing a car was about the same as the CO2 emissions for driving 20,000 miles on it. This foundered the entire rationale for "cash for clunkers" to switch to more fuel efficient cars, but facts didn't matter. Politics did.
- chgs 3y agoThis was a choice between a new ICE and a new EV so your point is meaningless
- effluvium 3y agoA lot of millennials and gen Z's are choosing to not have kids. No real reason for those without kids to give a fuck, and those with kids have a larger carbon footprint than those without children.
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoThe math works because I don't drive much.
- jfim 3y ago> Last time I ran the numbers is was 8 to 10 years before I hit break for an ICE vs an equivalent EV That assumes your time is worth zero. The best feature about having an EV or plug in hybrid is that if you can charge at home, you never have to waste time going to the gas station, except for road trips.
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoThat's an odd way of looking at it, and I don't it's terribly valid but sure let's run with it for a bit. The gas station is right on the route home. Any which way I used to go home, it's on the route on the right side of the road. When I was commuting every day it I was refuelling roughly every 3 weeks taking 3 to 6 minutes depending on if I had to wait for a gas stall to open. I work from home now so it's not entirely valid but use this for the sake of easy comparison. Let's say it takes 10 seconds to unplug/close door/stow cable when you leave, and another 10 seconds when you get back. 5 days a week plus weekend trip for errands or whatever, so 6 minutes every 3 weeks. In other words, about the same as buying gas. But then that leaves out the issue of DC fast charging, which inherently does longer, even when everything is working. Right now, the fast chargers not named Tesla are a bit of a gamble and now you have to consider time spent looking for an alternative charger if the one you want is occupied or out of order. Then throw in that my problems with locating a fast charge are made more so because I don't have a data plan on my smartphone, which limits which chargers I can use and cuts me off from knowing chargers are working and well... So I'm not overly keen on that argument.
- Rinzler89 3y agoForget about stealing copper, a lot of outdoor public chargers are just defective. Either the connector, the charger, the payment system or the app is wonky. Compared to the speed, ease and reliability of filling up a gas tank, public charging an EV is hell. Until we fix this, people without a house and garage to have their own charger are going get screwed badly by the forced EV transition.
- chgs 3y ago> Outdoor chargers don't work because thieves steal the copper wires Yet in reality thousands of people charge their cars in their driveways every day without this problem.
- pornel 3y agoThey're fine even without it if there's infrastructure. Supermarkets around me have fast chargers, so I just recharge during my weekly shopping (BEVs don't need to be plugged every day).
- WalterBright 3y agoHow many hours do you spend at the supermarket? I'm usually in and out in 10 minutes, that isn't much of a charge. Also, how many charging stations are there compared to the number of parking spaces? The markets I've seen have 2 charging stations with about a hundred parking spaces. The stations are always in use, so they're fairly useless unless you want to hang around for most of the day.
- simfree 3y ago350kw chargers can take you from low to fairly full in 10 minutes. Level 2 chargers that generally push 6kw of power and take hours to fully charge a car aren't very useful for brief charging stops like this.
- pornel 3y agoPublic DC chargers are orders of magnitude faster than domestic or "destination" chargers. Modern BEVs typically need 30 minutes to charge from 10 to 80% (it slows down asymptotically above 80). I have 150kW chargers around here (southwest UK), which add 80 miles of range in 10 minutes. My weekly shopping usually takes longer than the car needs to fully change.
- chgs 3y agoDo supermarkets have 150kW chargers? I thought they were 7kW ones, or about 20 miles/hour. 80 miles from 15kWh would be over 5 miles per kWh which seems quite high. What’s the cost per mile compared to petrol? How many 150kW chargers are at your local supermarket? How many car parking spaces in total?
- pornel 3y ago
- sn 3y agoWe are a 2 EV household. We charge exclusively at work (for free) or at public chargers.