10 ms·
Google's Self-Driving Car Gets Mixed Reviews
- drbawb 14y agoFirst thing I'm going to do w/ my Google Car is put a label that says: "PRESS IN CASE OF SKYNET!" under the kill switch.
- revelation 14y agoThe first will be allowing the car to stray from routes that it has been specifically trained to drive. I think the author is hugely overstating the importance of this.
- antonioevans 14y agoI live in NYC and the best use-case for this is taxis. Taxi do not take the same route twice. Traffic is a nightmare during different seasonal, temporal, or accident events. So like a Garmin device it should be able to "remap" the trip. In our lifetimes this will be possible but maybe not in next 1-3 years. (I hope I am wrong)
- MaxGabriel 14y agoThe car already doesn't need to be on planned routes, it remaps the trip as needed. That was done back during the DARPA Challenges. They're just limiting the car here for the media.
- revelation 14y agoGoogle has covered large parts of the (populated) world with Street View. Pictures [1] indicate that the cars were equipped with laser sensors. So Google probably has enough data to have the cars drive new routes. But thats not the point. Most of peoples daily driving routine is the same routes over and over, commuting to and from work. Going even further: I'd imagine that you could train the car on a specific route by driving it manually. Such information could be crowdsourced, much as Google already does with its traffic data on Maps. [1]: http://cdn.physorg.com/newman/gfx/news/hires/streetviewca.jpg http://cdn.physorg.com/newman/gfx/news/hires/streetviewca.jp...
- Qworg 14y agoI believed that as well, but now I'm not so sure. The density of data gathered by the Velodyne on the self driving cars is far higher than the SICK lasers in that picture. Also, the scene may have changed in the interim.
- revelation 14y agoYes, but we're still talking cars that measure metres by metres, and streets with lots of extra room. As you mention, the scene may have changed - so trying to preplan the whole route to the inch will only hurt you. What is needed is basic data above GPS, and I think the Street View lasers can be that.
- Qworg 14y agoI'm sorry I was unclear - I meant that the scene could have changed since the Street View team was last through. The Google Maps data is surprisingly bad - we saw several presentations about the Car, and they highlighted how awful it really is. I don't think that they're preplanning. I think that they're analyzing the scene for differences to simplify and speed calculation. Having good a priori data is really powerful.
- falcolas 14y agoI agree 100%. My commute is over the same route, every day, some 260 days a year. The value of freeing me up to do something else for that hour each day can't be understated.
- benmccann 14y agoYou might be surprised. It's a bit more than having to just program in new GPS coordinates. Imagine the car drives the route once collecting tons of data with the laser range finder and other sensors on the car. Now they let the car sit for a few days while they process all the data. Finally the car can drive the route. There's still some pretty hard challenges to solve in making those offline algorithms realtime. Maybe some of it is just waiting a couple years for faster processors, but I'm guessing they might have some pretty intense engineering challenges ahead.
- nolok 14y agoI don't think he meant doing it was an easy task, but rather that a large majority of the time when you take your car you go on a route you've already taken in the past, and if the car can self train its routes when in manual mode then you only need to drive it once / the first few times to go to work/groceries/school/...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 14y ago> Disappointing because it's clearly not going to be ready for public use for years and years. > That step still seems -- to me -- many years off Than you, KTVZ reporter. I will take your expert opinion into account.
- rallison 14y agoFTA: For now, at least, the car only drives routes it's been trained to drive. My ride in Washington DC was along a route that Google engineers had driven with the car earlier. Google refused to allow the car to be driven anywhere beyond this well-studied environment, at least not with the media tagging along. Reporter, did you even ask the Google engineers about that? For a media demo, it is not at all surprising that they would use an already driven route. The reporting here was a bit disappointing.
- alain94040 14y agoReporter, did you even ask the Google engineers about that? For a media demo, it is not at all surprising that they would use an already driven route. The reporting here was a bit disappointing. Actually, no, this limitation has been well documented (but cleverly brushed aside). The car doesn't see and understand the road ahead, it follows an invisible line on the ground, and can stop if it detects danger. It doesn't read signs. So yes, demos are impressive, but slightly misleading.
- jedc 14y agoI'm pretty sure there's no "invisible line on the ground". From what I've read, the route simply needs to be mapped at a higher resolution than most roads have been mapped before.
- eco 14y agoCNN Auto writer, actually. The article is just reprinted on KTVZ's website.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoThe lack of a turn signal made me chuckle. That is such a software development moment :) Probably too easy to implement, that's why they forgot it. But the fact that the car often needs the human to intervene is a bit more interesting. Why would a human better know if there is enough space for two cars to pass each other in a narrow street?
- christiangenco 14y agoIf I was google I'd be erring on the side of extreme caution. The first public accident that happens with one of these cars is going to get plastered over every media outlet in the world. That they had the car in "super safe driving" mode for a media event seems entirely reasonable, even if the car probably could've navigated the narrow street with 95% confidence. The obvious path of attack is targeting the safety of an automated driver. Lose voter confidence and the whole thing comes crumbling down to be delayed another decade of legislation. That's my guess, anyway.
- jrockway 14y agoThe first public accident that happens with one of these cars is going to get plastered over every media outlet in the world. There's already been an accident, the car hit another car from behind. But supposedly this was in manual mode.
- uncoder0 14y agoSource? I thought the car was hit by someone else. edit: Found it, http://www.slashgear.com/googles-robot-car-accident-blamed-on-human-05169836/ http://www.slashgear.com/googles-robot-car-accident-blamed-o.... You were correct. I had thought they were rear ended by a human.
- Qworg 14y agoThe system likely has a bubble of safety around it to allow for sudden changes close to the car. This makes the "car" far larger than it would actually be.
- 14y ago
- ajays 14y agoFTA: "But the biggest step will be to create a car that will let me just sit in the back seat with no-one at all in the driver's seat. . . . If Google can get there before a major automaker beats them to it, I'll be really impressed." A major automaker has as much chance of beating Google as a 350lb man has of beating Usain Bolt at the 100m dash. The automakers aren't really known for doing cutting-edge software, you know.
- sanderjd 14y agoThat part made me grin. Most non-technical people I've talked to have expressed surprise that Google is the company furthest along with this technology. They see the problem as one of vehicular design rather than large-scale data analysis. Automakers are pretty good at the former, but nobody has proved themselves to be better at the latter than Google.
- elsurudo 14y agoAbsolutely. Google must realize that its supremacy in search/ads will eventually come to an end, so they're making a really smart, long-term investment here. Self-driving cars would be awesomely useful, and Google has exactly the right resources (top AI engineers) to make this happen. One day, we'll all likely have cars with AI powered by Google.
- haakon666 14y agoOr you could view it that they are trying to extract an extra hour or two of eyeball time per person per day. Since you no longer have to drive the car, you could be using your android tablet on the commute to work....
- elsurudo 14y agoThat's a good point. It's a way to make more money from the users they already have. It's certainly in line with their current ad-based business model, but man, talk about thinking outside the box... I guess if they get Google AI in your car, it will probably come with lots of other Google products, too.
- nthitz 14y agoNo turn signals? How could they have not put those in yet?! Next you will tell me it won't tune the radio to my top songs on google music!
- samineru 14y ago> The data from each situation would be ingested and analyzed so the car could learn what to do in the future. Those lessons could, hopefully, be applied to a broad range of driving conundrums. This is huge. Maybe a handful of cars are learning there way around slowly, but if they have legitimate automatic learning systems, imagine two or three thousand cars all learning together.
- CognitiveLens 14y agoThis is a major piece in the overall puzzle that the article doesn't really explore. Google's greatest strategic advantage is networked systems - each additional driverless car is a mobile, sensor-packed learning system for all other driverless cars. I strongly doubt that the plan is for each car to 'learn' how to handle each new driving situation independently - as soon as one car learns a behavior, they all learn that behavior. That level of networked learning system is probably not fully mature, but it's certainly not far from reality.
- doubleconfess 14y agoWow, this reporter was horrible. He reminds me of those clients who when you show them the early stages of their site after a few weeks of work, point out everything that doesn't work as a huge the-sky-is-falling catastrophic event that is proof of the project's eventual demise. This reporter got to sit in a car that is doing things that a few years ago still seemed like science fiction and yet he had these niggling complaints: For now, at least, the car only drives routes it's been trained to drive. Google is pretty good at mapping things. Since the Google car only just got its learner's permit, it drives accordingly I think this is meant as a literal statement. The car is able to drive of its own accord, but needs an adult present who can take over if needed. But did you just say that the GOOGLE CAR HAS A LEARNER'S PERMIT?? That's amazing! Then there was the jerking halt on a side street caused by a car that stopped a little abruptly almost two car lengths ahead. If you don't think the software is going to err on the side of caution for YEARS after widespread usage, you are mistaken. Eventually we will be so used to trusting these cars that we will probably be napping on the way to work, so who cares that the car hits the brakes a few more times than it should? And eventually I'm sure these cars will be a model of efficiency, with fast moving currents of cars zipping here and there. One step at a time. Surprisingly, one thing the car can't do all on its own is use the turn signals. Hey, how come when I click this button on my site does nothing happen??? THIS PROJECT IS A COMPLETE FAILURE!!! If Google can get there before a major automaker beats them to it, I'll be really impressed. The most preposterous statement of all. Please get the reporter on the line and let me place a bet of Google vs all the automakers combined on who will release this technology is first. Assuming that Google hasn't locked up all of the pertinent technologies, this wouldn't be a fair fight.
- ColinWright 14y agoI'm really disappointed to see this as the top voted reply. Of course the reporter is wrong, of course his article can be ripped apart, of course this is a momentous achievement and the reporter is just too ignorant to know that, and we're all clever enough to see how amazing this is. You're missing the point and the lesson: This is how normals think. I've written more here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4018684 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4018684 Don't just laugh at the ignorance, learn from it.
- ColinWright 14y agoSo many of the comments here are pointing out the flaws in the reporter's account and, quite rightly, scoffing at their ignorance. But there's a lesson to learn: he's an ordinary person, and this is what he thinks about the demo! So don't just dismiss it as completely missing the point. Learn and understand that this is how the normals think. This is an important lesson for we who write code. This really is how the normals think. Dismiss and ignore it at your peril and loss.
- rangibaby 14y agoThis won't be the last critical review that Google gets. History has shown that people are incredibly quick to dismiss and attack things they don't understand. A good (recent!) tech example would be the iPhone: back in 2008; it's kind of funny now, but my first impression of it was "huh, where's the stylus?" and I wasn't alone. The amount of "No stylus, so it's hard to use" FUD being spread around was incredible. Now my two year-old son tries to swipe on my computer dumbscreen to go to the next photo. The "People of the land.... morons" opinion curve is probably going to follow the same trajectory; they will dismiss and criticize until they can't remember how crappy driving a car really was.
- lumberjack 14y agoCan the lack of automatic turn signal be due to some legal implications? Like for example, the car falling in the same position as other car with assisted driving technologies. Or perhaps it's just a quick way to change the car's route?