3 ms·
They weren't asked to settle in Palestine by its local inhabitants, but they were chased by mobs with clubs and metal pipes from the places they did live. I'm n
by tptacek 3y ago
They weren't asked to settle in Palestine by its local inhabitants, but they were chased by mobs with clubs and metal pipes from the places they did live. I'm not sure what litigating this gets you, rhetorically.
It's worth noting that (excepting maybe Egypt?) all the surrounding Arab states were also the creation of European imperial colonialism, a fact that only seems to matter when the people implicated happen to be Jewish. But for a couple quirks of history, Palestinians would have a universally recognized, sovereign homeland; today, we call it "Jordan", and it is ruled by a dynasty of monarchs who conspired to prevent what was, around '67, a Palestinian majority from obtaining political power.
I think what's happening in Gaza is an atrocity, and that Israel has done as much as anybody in the region to dispossess and abuse the residents of the West Bank and Gaza. But I also understand why people read antisemitism into blank "colonialism" complaints about Israel. Clearly, colonialism is only situationally worth getting riled up about.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- racional 3y ago[flagged]
- racional 3y agoBut I also understand why people read antisemitism into blank "colonialism" complaints about Israel. Whose "complaints", specifically? If it's in reference to what I've been saying, then you're going to have to either explain what you mean - or dial back the rather offensive insinuation that you're making above.
- tptacek 3y agoI'm happy to dial back any offensive insinuation I've made, but I'll have to ask you to tell me what it was first. I don't know you, you're just a message board abstraction to me, and if I've wrongly attributed some sentiment to you, I'll be glad to correct the record.
- racional 3y agoHow about you answer my question first: Whose colonialism remarks ("complaints") were you referring to, specifically? Was it mine, or was it not?
- tptacek 3y agoIt was not your remark. So far as I know, I'm one of a very few people who have read your comment (just by dint of the age and depth of the thread). There is no mass mobilization over any supposed racism or antisemitism embedded in your specific statements, the way there is over the claimed "whiteness" or "Polishness" or "European-ness" of Israeli citizens. That is to say: I thought that in referring to common complaints in the discourse, I was clear that I was talking about a wider phenomenon, not this particular thread, but message boards are tricky and I could have done better. I'd have no trouble using direct language, describing a particular argument as "racist" or "antisemitic", if I felt that was what the argument was. But there's no reason you'd have known that, and I understand if I read as sort of cagily making that accusation without making it directly. Nope, not my intent, sorry to drive up your cortisol that way. I'll be more cautious going forward.
- racional 3y agoPlease do. I appreciate the thoughtful clarification.