4 ms·
> Arguably an extreme in either direction would be relatively effective. We have empirical proof that the restrictive extreme works: https://deathpenaltyinfo.o
by rayiner 3y ago
> Arguably an extreme in either direction would be relatively effective.
We have empirical proof that the restrictive extreme works: https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/news/singapore-announces-plans-to-execute-more-death-sentenced-prisoners-convicted-of-non-violent-drug-offenses https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/news/singapore-announces-plans-....
We have no empirical proof that the permissive extreme works. There's also no moral impetus for the permissive extreme, except maybe in rare cases when people are forced into drug use against their will. We are talking about something that virtually always starts out as a deliberate, anti-social choice.
- doctor_eval 3y agoThe link you provided does not even remotely support your claim, which I can only assume is that the death penalty stops drug distribution. But unless you control for Singapore’s somewhat unique geography and politics, pointing to Singapore’s death penalty - itself the result of a wider political context - signifies very little.
- rayiner 3y agoThe death penalty is very important. What makes ordinary people follow the law is a desire to conform to society’s expectations. Humans are social animals—we want to be “good people,” not “bad people.” Imposing the death penalty for drug dealers cultivates a social norm about how evil drug dealers are. Its society’s ultimate sanction and indicator of the acts society deems evil. It’s like the social opprobrium we have in the US for child molesters, where we look the other way when they get killed in prison. It reinforces the norm—even other criminals realize that child molesters are especially evil.
- saagarjha 3y agoArguing for extrajudicial punishment in prison for criminals as being good, actually is pretty wild
- doctor_eval 3y ago> Imposing the death penalty for drug dealers cultivates a social norm about how evil drug dealers are This is just so unbelievably stupid that I have no words at all.
- throwup238 3y ago> We have no empirical proof that the permissive extreme works. Alcohol. We have plenty of empirical proof that Prohibition doesn't work.
- anon291 3y agoProhibition worked by basically all measures. Cirrhosis rates were down. Violence overall was actually down. Child abuse was down. 100s of thousands of people were saved due to prohibition of alcohol. I'm not even in favor of alcohol prohibition but denying it saved lives goes completely against all data.
- throwup238 3y agoWhat data? I'd love to see your sources for "100s of thousands of people were saved due to prohibition of alcohol." You should update the wikipedia article with those sources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_Prohibition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_Prohibition
- anon291 3y agoYou should read actual data instead of Wikipedia https://www.nber.org/papers/w9681 https://www.nber.org/papers/w9681 <- cirrhosis declined 20 percent https://academic.oup.com/aler/article-abstract/13/1/1/183009 https://academic.oup.com/aler/article-abstract/13/1/1/183009 https://academic.oup.com/aler/article/16/2/433/168495 https://academic.oup.com/aler/article/16/2/433/168495 <- prohibition associated with up to 30 percent reduction in violent crime https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0144818815000587 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01448... <- another researcher with similar findings. The common cultural belief that prohibition failed is a total myth. It achieved everything it set out to achieve. People just wanted to drink. There's actually very little evidence of the supposed ills of prohibition. For example, organized crime is typically said to have been caused by prohibition, but there were other factors at play as well (immigration, economics, etc). Harder liquor being available is another one, and this is true. Cirrhosis severity increased during prohibition but the drop in cirrhosis rates more than made up for that.
- petre 3y agoOh great, the death penalty. It works fine in Korea even without it.
- pixl97 3y agoAh yes, totalitarianism works! FFS, do you even think about the non drug ramifications of said governments policies.
- rayiner 3y agoThe majority providing for an orderly, clean, and safe society for themselves through democratic means is not “totalitarianism.” Democracy does not require kowtowing to antisocial individuals. If you want to be disorderly then go live in the jungle.
- int_19h 3y agoBy this token, if the majority believes that an "orderly, clean, and safe society" means not having, say, people with a certain skin color in it, do you think that is also fine? Or taking an existing modern example of Russia. The majority of its population genuinely believes that e.g. LGBT persecution (which, to remind, these days means that two women kissing in public get arrested) is necessary for an "orderly and clean society". Is that also a good example of such a democracy?
- rayiner 3y agoI don't think there's any comparison between drug users and dealers and racial minorities and LGBT people. Putting that aside, democracy--the collective right to create the kind of society the people want--is more important than individual rights. Societies sometimes make terrible mistakes. Democracy doesn't mean that people always make good decisions. But there is no moral justification for any other approach. Such as having a minority decide that the majority must put up with having to step over drug needles in streets or public parks.
- int_19h 3y agoYou don't think so, but who are you to argue against the democratic social consensus? In Russia they believe that being LGBT is a choice and that it is a choice that is socially harmful. Just like you believe the same wrt drugs. Putting that aside, if you believe that democracy is more important than individual rights, then you are in no position to claim that democracy and totalitarianism are incompatible. One can certainly have a totalitarian society in which the majority consents to it being so. The moral justification for a different approach is that unchecked majority rule is merely "might is right" dressed up in a way that makes it a bit more palatable for the masses.