3 ms·
The claims in https://scala-open-letter.github.io/ https://scala-open-letter.github.io/ are that the signers "have become aware" "based on multiple, independent
by ceejayoz 3y ago
The claims in https://scala-open-letter.github.io/ https://scala-open-letter.github.io/ are that the signers "have become aware" "based on multiple, independent, well-substantiated reports showing a systematic pattern of behavior over an extended period" of harrassment, and links those very multiple, independent reports (of which the second is indeed a substantiation of the first).
It's hard to see how any of this is false under the US standards. In the UK, though... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law
> everyone involved in the dissemination of the defamation is liable as having published it
(That wouldn't fly here; retweeting a false claim, barring unusual circumstances, tends not to be actionable.)
The actual allegations weren't litigated in this case, it's a settlement, and I don't doubt it made more sense to say "sorry" and pay £5k/person than to spend years in court litigating a crime that is typically done in a way that leaves little physical evidence that someone else asserted happened.
Even when you win, you lose! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_v_Penguin_Books_Ltd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_v_Penguin_Books_Ltd Millions in legal fees, two years spent proving the case, and he declares bankruptcy when fees are awarded.
- tristor 3y ago> It's hard to see how any of this is false under the US standards. You are taking their claims at face value. It doesn't matter what standards you apply other than truthfulness, and these claims could still be false. There's no substantiation provided, merely the claim that such exists. A court case in the US would still require them to provide that substantiation, otherwise their claims could be considered libel. While the libel laws in the US and UK differ, it is not legal either in the US to defame someone either knowingly or negligently.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> You are taking their claims at face value. They are entitled to that presumption until evidence emerges otherwise. (This is not the case in the UK!) > A court case in the US would still require them to provide that substantiation, otherwise their claims could be considered libel. No. A court case in the US would require Pretty to show evidence they had reason to believe the information was false for them to be liable for defamation.
- nailer 3y agoWhy are people entitled to say bad things about others they cannot prove are true?
- ceejayoz 3y agoBecause sometimes people do bad things in ways that are hard to prove, but they still happen. The Catholic priest makes sure he and the altar boy are the only ones in the church. The coworker who makes unwelcome advances is careful to do it verbally when there aren’t witnesses. The abusive spouse leverages psychological traumas to make their partner feel crazy.
- exe34 3y agoAnd how do you pick whose lives to ruin without evidence? What do you do about the ones who are wrongly accused? How many innocent lives are you willing to destroy?
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat question cuts both ways. How many lives did Weinstein and Cosby and Savile destroy? (And look how tough it was to nail them, and keep it that way.) What about the victims whose attackers are good at avoiding hard evidence? The basic legal standard is crimes/torts in court have to be proven. English law violates it in defamation cases.
- exe34 3y agoInnocent until proven guilty seems like a frivolous device until they come for you. Good luck!
- tristor 3y ago> They are entitled to that presumption until evidence emerges otherwise. Why is only one side “entitled to that presumption”? In most common law countries, including both the US and UK, there is a presumption of innocence when someone faces an accusation, their guilt must be proven with evidence. You are providing heavier weight and benefit to one claim over the other, and that weight is going towards an accusation that presents no substantive evidence. That’s your prerogative, but it is philosophically misaligned with a fact-based approach to the law. You are mistaken that this was not libel in the US. Even in the US, the law and precedent is clear, you cannot go around claiming someone is guilty of a crime they’re not convicted of, actively seek to prevent them from being employed, and explicitly cause their dismissal from their means of livelihood. That establishes clear damages, and if you have no evidence to support your claim, not even the lower burden of proof that would prevail in a civil matter, you would lose if sued for libel and defamation. Once damages and either willful disregard, negligence, or malice are established, all elements are present.