6 ms·
DJI might get banned next in the US
- coldtea 3y agoIf you can't compete, ban them!
- hanniabu 3y agoMore like if you can't control them. Drones put a lot of power back into citizens and that's not great for those in charge.
- hedora 3y ago[deleted]
- sithadmin 3y agoThe US federal government's hostility towards DJI is tangential to its hostility towards drone operators in general. There are real national security concerns about the ability for DJI's devices and software platforms to exfiltrate sensitive data that could be used for military strategy, corporate espionage, or even things like gaining unfair advantages in real estate and infrastructure development deals.
- firebat45 3y agoIt's interesting how advocating for backdoors into consumer products (like the US wanted DJI to do) suddenly makes you uneasy that there are other backdoors into those products. I don't like Apple, but this was exactly their argument against putting in backdoors to unlock people's devices, and I support them in that.
- talldayo 3y ago[deleted]
- cwyers 3y agoYou're right, it would be better if there was fair competition and we could let the market decide things. But that's not the status quo. The status quo is one party (China) has extremely protectionist policies and encourages IP theft from other countries. Because of this, companies in other countries are at a disadvantage competing in the Chinese market and against Chinese companies. So then you have to decide: is letting Chinese companies win the competition via unfair practices better or worse than engaging in tit-for-tat and levelling the playing field a bit?
- mandibles 3y agoProtectionism hurts the ultimate consumer of the product. If domestic companies require patronage from the state in order to remain in business, they should not exist, no matter the conditions in some other jurisdiction.
- rayiner 3y agoCitation needed.
- kube-system 3y ago> Protectionism hurts the ultimate consumer of the product. In times of good economies, open borders, and peace, it might. But it also incurs significant risk if there are disruptions. > If domestic companies require patronage from the state in order to remain in business, they should not exist, no matter the conditions in some other jurisdiction. DJI and similar Chinese tech companies are benefiting from very significant protectionism, themselves. Should they not exist?
- glimshe 3y ago"Patronage from state" is a sensationalist way of putting us trying to avoid being overly dependent on a hostile dictatorship. Yes, the consumer will pay more but in this case it's worth it. It's like paying more for something because of insurance costs.
- cwyers 3y ago`Protectionism hurts the ultimate consumer of the product.` So do lots of other things, and you need to balance competing sources of harm against each other. Allowing foreign companies benefitting from protectionist policies drive domestic industries out of business leaves consumers vulnerable to several other harms. You can't just do everything in a vacuum without considering the context because it's the "right thing to do" and expect the best outcomes.
- kevin42 3y agoMy concern isn't about competition but that since the drones dial home and get over the air updates, there's little that would prevent China from using it to gather images and location data that that we wouldn't want them to (private/commercial/military).
- ribosometronome 3y agoWhy not ban that, then? Similar to concerns re: TikTok propaganda, it seems like the solution is not to solve the problem but to try and limit the bad things to being done by American companies.
- sithadmin 3y agoThat's not really a fair assessment of the situation. The real (and valid) concern is that DJI's commercial products dominate the market for land/resource development, agriculture, infrastructure, chemical refining and pipelines, and other segments, and the software platform is capable of exfiltrating data (flight telemetry, imaging, etc.) back to a firm with strong ties to Chinese government and state enterprises.
- hedora 3y agoDJI, in particular has a bunch of phone-home kill switch stuff built in. The FAA mandated a lot of it, and now I think they realize that, in practice, that means they're mandating that the Chinese military has indirect control over drones operated by Americans on US soil. I think it'd be better to ban remote kill switches and instead mandate GIS databases that warn you if you're violating airspace restrictions (for drones over a certain size, where this isn't adding a bunch of complexity). Shielding domestic drone manufacturers from international competition essentially guarantees that we'll fall behind China. That will cause a national security issue worse than the current situation. Sometimes I wonder if the regulators are intentionally screwing the US over, or if it's just that the federal government has become unable to coordinate the actions of its own agencies. edit: The sibling comments are great examples of why we need strong privacy laws. If it was illegal for DJI to exfiltrate the data the drones gather back to their manufacturers, then those classes of national security issues would take care of themselves, and the rules would solve the problem for all industries, not just this one company.
- Ancapistani 3y ago> The FAA mandated a lot of it Source? I'm a Part 107 pilot, and none of the commercial stuff I fly has those restrictions.
- init2null 3y agoThere's an unlock mechanism in the DJI app for those with the appropriate license. There are plenty of restrictions without it.
- Ancapistani 3y agoI’m aware - but that’s a DJI thing, not an FAA requirement. I dumped DJI when I couldn’t get it to unlock for a job at an airport.
- init2null 3y agoDefinitely a DJI thing since the Autel is way, way less restricted. I got annoyed that a few little barely-used airstrips seemed to enforce limitations on the entire county.
- odiroot 3y agoIronically this actually helped Honda in the end, when it was Harley Davidson lobbying US gov for help.
- johnea 3y agoThis applies even more to teh chinese EV import bans. It seems if the USactually wanted people to drive EVs and put photovoltaic on their houses that they would embrace Chinese government subsidized products. Why wouldn't we want the Chinese subsidy to advance the US's electrification? WRT the the security vulnerabiliters, this is just another case of protecting US surveilance companies. A law to ban all user data collection and exfiltration would be the most benificial to the population, but I think goggle would have a few complaints.
- throwaway4good 3y agoWhat is the US alternative? Who is lobbying for this?
- sorenjan 3y agoI think Skydio was the main US alternative until they stopped making consumer drones. They can probably start making them again fairly soon if they're incentivized. I guess they're still an alternative to DJI's commercial segment, but I don't know of any competitors to DJI for most of their consumer drones.
- rasz 3y agoThey are an "alternative", they abandoned consumer market because they were unable to compete on technology and unwilling on price. Even Ukrainians dont want them and prefer DJI.
- mullingitover 3y agoI shudder to think of what's going to happen to my 401k when this turns into a tit for tat game and China bans Apple products.
- MaxHoppersGhost 3y agoThinking of our 401ks only is what got us into this mess with China in the first place.
- anononaut 3y agoIs it? I would put citizen privacy and leveling the playing field above outright min/maxing share prices or GDP. Convince me.
- echelon 3y agoWe thought China would join the WTO and "Westernize" themselves. They didn't, and it's clear they're trying to come out on top. That's why the West is switching to full-on contagion mode. The pandemic was the trigger event that gave us the activation energy to accept supply chain disruptions and ease into the pain of decoupling. It'll go much faster now. The de-China-fication is going to accelerate rapidly. The game is now near-shore, friend-shore. Mexico is now the biggest trade partner of the US, and it's still only ramping up. The rail and truck corridors are growing significantly and we're about to pour in huge infrastructure investments.
- Hock88sdx 3y agoIt is pretty much game over for America now. Huawei has 2nm chip and will mass produce next year Q1. China EVs already so far ahead that Tesla had to mass layoff and price drop. Chinese drones are so numerous, even American Naval Admiral scared to engage Chinese. There are simply no simulation path of American stayimg ahead in next 100 years. Unlike Japanese, Chinese wont do Japanese kowtow. The best way forward is American get their budget in order. Once Chinese achieve full domestic consumption game over for America. Now Chinese has wodld biggest auto market 30m, bigger than USA and EU combined. Imagine that happen to planes, everyday consumptions. China also massive purchasing and delivering physical gold to Shanghai. Therr is no way USD and American economy able to sustain itself when Chinese outcompete, outspy, out militarise America. If you look at Chinese space station vs American ISS, you will know who will become star trek first. Even Chinese desert turning green will likely trigger dust bowl in America in the next 30 years. Game over America.
- sorenjan 3y agoWhat other options are there on the drone market? It's my impression that DJI are the biggest because they are the best.
- antonkochubey 3y agonot much for consumers (Autel Robotics is also Chinese IIRC), plenty of options for industrial/military
- beeboobaa3 3y agoThere already are no options if you don't want to beg china for permission any time you want to use your property.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThe US has a mature and highly diversified drone industry with excellent tech. It just isn't targeted at consumers, which is the market segment where DJI plays.
- sithadmin 3y agoDJI does own the consumer segment, but they're also still usually the go-to brand for US commercial purposes as well. Their software and hardware reliability is leaps and bounds better than anything else on the market until you start getting into defense contractor territory.
- johnea 3y agoApparently even when used to maim, mutilate and murder other people, DJI is superior. https://archive.ph/VkYSu https://archive.ph/VkYSu https://www.wsj.com/world/how-american-drones-failed-to-turn-the-tide-in-ukraine-b0ebbac3 https://www.wsj.com/world/how-american-drones-failed-to-turn...
- numpad0 3y agoIsn't it partly an artificial problem created by export regulations? US had soft-restricted civilian ownership of missile-related technologies by controlling exports and inflating prices. But none of it applies to DJI drones somehow, so it wins.
- SeanAnderson 3y agoNote that DJI was added to the US' "Entity List" in 2020 which limited the ability for US companies to export products to DJI, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/12/22/2020-28031/addition-of-entities-to-the-entity-list-revision-of-entry-on-the-entity-list-and-removal-of-entities#:~:text=and%20Materials%20(CNSIM)%3B-,DJI,-%3B%20and%20Kuang%2DChi https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/12/22/2020-28... Interesting to see the US taking things a step further.
- konschubert 3y agoI’m less worried about DJIs ability to spread propaganda than TikTok’s.
- ceejayoz 3y agoI'd imagine the concern about DJI is more in the realm of distributed sensors all over the world.
- jijijijij 3y agoI mean, Chinese electronics are everywhere. What's the specific threat here? I doubt DJI can easily exfiltrate HD video streams directly off of these drones. I'd be more concerned about their apps, cloud stuff and similar. Instead of banning the communist hardware they could require open standards/access for interfaces, firmware and so on. Then again, sharing code does smell a bit like communism too. So let's better err on the side of freedom and ban everything.
- rasz 3y ago>specific threat here? cloud based, calling home, telemetry, video/radio surveillance, logistics exfiltration. Pretty much same arguments as in case of Chinese port cranes sending video feeds of sensitive shipments/port operations back to China, except on a global scale with high margin of deployments in security scenarios (police/fire/rescue/inspection/military). One example is current Ukrainian situation. China gets a feed of who/where/how/what and how successful from supposedly civilian hardware.
- jijijijij 3y agoUkraine has their own firmware and apps for these drones. Which is exactly how to find a compromise with the situation.
- sithadmin 3y agoHow exactly is a DJI device going to spread propaganda? Fly around with a banner?
- segasaturn 3y agoIronically, modified DJI drones have been invaluable in the defense of Ukraine, especially in the early days.
- sircastor 3y agoThis makes me worry that BambuLab might be up on the list too. Any Chinese-owned company becomes a risk. Not necessarily from an actual surveillance/security/propaganda point of view, but it's hard to not view the TikTok ban as a little xenophobic. It's weird to me that so many congress-people are convinced this is a existential threat, but nobody shares any meaningful evidence. It feels like the kind of situation where "We can't tell them to move the nukes out of ____ because then they'll know our capabilities to detect their nukes."
- kube-system 3y agoWell, there's this: https://www.npr.org/2024/03/21/1239691465/tiktok-ban-bill-senate https://www.npr.org/2024/03/21/1239691465/tiktok-ban-bill-se...
- sithadmin 3y agoThe difference between DJI and Bambu is that Bambu products aren't being used in contexts that convey potentially sensitive information about infrastructure, heavy industry, agriculture, or land development. Bambu has a place in the low end of the market, but anybody doing serious prototyping work in spaces that cross into 'national security' territory is relying on far more specialized and US/Euro-centric vendor ecosystems for additive manufacturing.
- Takennickname 3y agoGood. So more people can stop pretending America is about freedom. Tired of this bullshit rhetoric. Military industrial complex gets richer by robbing other countries, and politicians get richer by robbing Americans.
- uxp100 3y agoElise Stefanik seems to be making a name for herself, but I’m skeptical this will go anywhere. is the article simplifying something? The law mentions networks, but would a better word be bands or something? I’m not familiar with drones but I would think most of them do not use what you’d call a network.
- smashah 3y agoInstead of actually producing/making anything in the last 20 years, America has focussed on worldwide destabilization and funding high-tech projects like uber, theranos, hyperloop, a tunnel in las vegas, the holocaust of Gaza, Elon Musk's ego and 10 thousand delivery apps. Mainly because contrarian VCs were busy trying to get some Saudi chumps to hold the bag pre-IPO and because the leadership is just a foreign sleeper cell - activated not on behalf of the working people, but on behalf of rent-seekers, financializers, and a certain foreign government. Instead of competing, US thinks it can ban it's way to success.
- deputy 3y ago[deleted]
- oautholaf 3y agoHave to say, I bought a DJI drone that I enjoyed, but then the app stopped working after my Android phone upgraded to a new OS version. Even months later, it appeared that DJI had made no effort to fix this issue (which clearly did not affect only me). There are open source apps, but the existing open source apps at the time did not control a specific unique and important feature on the drone I bought. Never buying DJI again.
- jijijijij 3y ago> In communist China. Oh boy, the American red scare talk. It's 2024 guys. Capitalism won. You can stop salivating when you hear the word 'communism'. Traitor Trump said this, sleepy Joe looked there, bad communist China will take freedom guns away... in 10 years American English will be fully memefied dum-dum talk.
- mrandish 3y agoThis proposed action just sounds like more election year grandstanding that will reduce American consumer's freedom to choose while having little practical effect on actually improving any national security that matters or can't otherwise be worked around. If it becomes law, the most likely outcome is that DJI becomes a US-based and owned company to whatever extent the law requires. The enterprise itself is too valuable to just shut down, so it's basically a government forced transfer of an asset. Being a forced sale, DJI's valuation will be substantially depressed. This will harm the Chinese entrepreneurs who started DJI as well as their investors but only indirectly cause relatively inconsequential damage to the overall Chinese stock market. To whatever extent Chinese intelligence is harvesting DJI drone data, there are other ways they can get that data ranging from LEO satellites to hiding imaging/sensor packages on any of the thousands of China-based passenger, cargo and private jets that overfly the U.S. weekly. Thus, any actual net improvement in national security posture is relatively minor at best. It's frustrating because even if we grant there's significant national security harm happening from DJI drone data, there are far more direct and effective ways to mitigate any such harm. For example, mandate that consumer drone data acquired in the U.S. cannot be stored in or transit China without a license. At the same time reverse the new FAA requirement for drone manufacturers to install software remote kill switches on consumer drones. While the idea may have sounded vaguely appealing in concept, in practice it's been a huge hassle for American consumers while being ineffective as a security measure because it's so easy for bad actors to work around. Thus, the only remaining effect is the unintended consequence that it forces U.S. consumers by law to accept the anti-feature of drone makers being able to kill American's drones at will - including foreign owned companies.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoAnd yet people tell me to "reform the system" instead of advocating to alternatives to the pathologically centralizing and ever daily more despotic USG.
- johnea 3y agoI'm sure my comment will be at the bottom and no one will ever see it, but: This law, `Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Act of 2019': https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/4998 https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/4998 Should certainly apply to android, iOS, windows, and most modern american made automobiles, televisions, refrigerators?, and almost all consumer electronics that are net connected. The collection and efiltration of personal data from the entire population is a national security risk.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoThis makes sense to me. Although DJI is not a propaganda tool like TikTok, it is still a national security threat. Who knows what they could be doing - like capturing surveillance footage and biometrics (facial recognition) or high resolution maps from across the country and handing it to the CCP. There is no need for the US to trade at all with China given they are an authoritarian government undermining US interests. We should be seeking a fast path to divestment and disrupt their foreign policy goals in places like Africa.
- nickburns 3y agowhat's the purported privacy risk/s to American citizens specifically with DJI's drones? or is this purely a matter of geopolitics? (TFA links to a paywalled NYT article on what seems to be this point.)
- shanewilhelm 3y agoGeopolitics. A congressperson is quoted as saying they pose a national security risk.