3 ms·
There is proposed EU legislation that (at least when I looked at it a few months ago) explicitly defines expert systems as for regulatory purposes. > The issue
by graemep 3y ago
There is proposed EU legislation that (at least when I looked at it a few months ago) explicitly defines expert systems as for regulatory purposes.
> The issue is that encoding human knowledge in if statements is hard to scale, so it doesn’t seem to be on the path to general artificial intelligence, but fundamentally it is still automation of cognition.
If so, then so are many things that automate what people do or know. Its getting very close to saying if statements are AI at least in some cases. If I ask a client what we should do at a particular step of a process, then code their response as an if statement, is that "automation of cognition"?
Expert systems are somewhat different from simple if statements because they infer from data - the steps are not rigidly defined. However they do have some advantages over things like LLMs for many purposes: they can be analysed/understood and are predictable. I would far prefer to use something something like a medical diagnostic system that used an expert system rather than an LLM.
My first paid job was a prototype expert system, and after a few weeks work it was doing a fairly simple industrial diagnostic task pretty reliably and it did lead to a production version that was used for many years.