2 ms·

So you're acknowledging video AND posting a video (which are not the same thing) are both forms of speech, and instead you are just quibbling over the fact that

So you're acknowledging video AND posting a video (which are not the same thing) are both forms of speech, and instead you are just quibbling over the fact that they are not the same as spoken or written speech, even though that wasn't something that was ever claimed?

defrost 2y ago
> So you're acknowledging video AND posting a video (which are not the same thing) are both forms of speech, No. Speech is talky talky audible words. Video is moving pictures but not film. > the fact that they are not the same as spoken or written speech, Yes, that's the fact, both in real life and legally, as evidenced in transcripts of numerous cases before courts. > even though that wasn't something that was ever claimed? This person did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40154349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40154349 They typed in written form "Posting the video is a form of speech." apparently not grasping what you have just agreed to as fact; moving pictures are not spoken words.
- DEADMINCE 2y ago
  > Speech is talky talky audible words. Legally, it's much broader in scope. At this point arguing further and not agreeing or acknowledging that basic truth is arguing semantics and nothing more, and not something I'm interested in continuing for the sake of it to to have a final say. Cheers.