Yes that's the definition of winning. Impact is pretty broad. Lots of people are positively impacted by AI: their lives get easier. Others see their livelihoods

Yes that's the definition of winning. Impact is pretty broad. Lots of people are positively impacted by AI: their lives get easier. Others see their livelihoods imperilled. Believe me, I know. But that isn't the X-Risk that people like Scott are talking about. They think AI is physically dangerous, that the Matrix scenario could happen for real. It's not about jobs in this case.