5 ms·
John Carmack on Meta Horizon OS
- anthk 3y agoNon JS address: https://nitter.privacydev.net/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1782826465207165288 https://nitter.privacydev.net/ID_AA_Carmack/status/178282646...
- jejeyyy77 3y agobad take from carmack
- Diederich 3y agoCan you expand on that? Thank you.
- Alupis 3y agoI'm not the parent - but Carmack has curated a history of being very wrong about VR and it's potential. Practically none of his predictions since joining Oculus/Meta have become reality - and probably never will. He's at the stage of his life/career where he doesn't have to actually worry about a successful product. He's probably content to just hack on cool tech - regardless of outcome. So, take his predictions for all things VR-related as wishful thinking. Maybe they'll become true, but probably not. He'll have a ton of fun either way.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nomel 3y agoDo you have some examples of this "very wrong"? I am finding his predictions on standalone being what gets mass adoption, inside out tracking taking over, and MR environment interactions being mostly a gimmick, correct.
- supernovae 3y agoAs fan of the amazing quest 3, i'm interested in seeing what a "OEM" ecosystem can do. I do think that stand alone VR is where it's at because it frees you while still being completely capable for PCVR so i'm hopeful some PCVR "first" headsets can join a program like this and deliver on stand alone while still keeping their bread and butter.
- chatmasta 3y agoI've only skimmed the Horizon OS news, but my first reaction was that it looks like an obvious attempt to emulate the success of Android. Own the operating system, ship it with a flagship product, and push it to other OEMs. There are more iPhones than Google Pixels but there are more Androids than any other phone.
- flakiness 3y agoIf it opens up the Horizon OS in Android level, it'll cost them massively as pointed out in the tweet. Android could've been much-much-much simpler if it were only for Pixel. I think people at Meta are aware of that and the Horizon-compatible devices will be less diverse than the ones from the Android ecosystem.
- chatmasta 3y agoBut if Android were only for Pixel it might not have succeeded. I guess one notable difference is that Android started as software-only, and Pixel came later. Maybe Google would have played it differently if they had a flagship phone from the beginning. Still, I’m surprised to see Carmack taking a position against opening a platform. Although it sounds from his tweet that he thinks it’s more of a proprietary partnership than true open sourcing. If that’s the case, I see the argument for it being a distraction. But if the roadmap includes open sourcing the OS, then surely the “distraction” is worth it to capture the majority of the market.
- bagels 3y agoAndroid was around for a long time before the Pixel phones came out. Maybe you just mean Google branded phones in general? 2008: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system) 2010: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Nexus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Nexus 2016: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pixel_(1st_generation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pixel_(1st_generation)
- flakiness 3y ago
- zoeysmithe 3y ago>Meta already sells the Quest systems basically at production cost This is of course scary and why the VR market is now pretty much a monopoly. Perhaps the next versions of the vision pro will be lowered cost and have more games, but Zuck is just throwing money at each headset so how can groups like HTC compete? HTC and Valve never really had a chance when a headset that costs $300 to make is sold for $300. Zuck and Carmack running victory laps now trying to Android-ize VR is probably not super surprising, but all of this show what happens when there's no real regulations to stop this kind of monopolization. imho, Apple certainly saw this coming and fears a new Android-like competitor in a space they arguably could do well in. So the Vision Pro was pushed out before this got traction. Now its a matter of titan vs titan because smaller players are probably not going to enter this space anymore outside of hardware partners for Meta.
- supernovae 3y agoValve never really tried to compete. Index is old, outdated and never saw a price discount and their supposed Index V2 has been delayed so long it's a huge meme. HTC never really iterated like Quest did beyond big bulky headsets that required a full room set up did they? I can't say Meta spending 10s of millions to push the technology forward is monopolistic unless you want to say Nintendo, Sony and Microsoft consoles or any device with a walled garden (ipad/iphone) ecosystem is monopolistic.
- robandrews 3y agoThough total losses for Reality Labs is not 10s of millions but $45B since the end of 2020 [1]. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/meta-stock-plunges-15-company-plans-invest-heavliy-artificial-intellig-rcna149258# https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/meta-stock-plunges-15...
- asdff 3y agoWhy would the vision pro have games? I'm still waiting for the damn iPhone to be the gaming platform they promised over a decade ago. I watched over the last few years as Mac computers somehow got more powerful than they ever were but also have lost just about all support for modern games. The truth is, despite what apple says out of their mouth at their pressers, they don't really care about gaming or have any interest in establishing a viable development environment for this platform. Valve isn't even porting their games to mac anymore despite how much fanfare the relationship with this company and apple had for years.
- mgiampapa 3y agoBack in march Google approached Meta to try and push XR in a very one-sided arrangement. https://www.roadtovr.com/meta-google-android-xr-quest-rejected/ https://www.roadtovr.com/meta-google-android-xr-quest-reject... The timing of this is probably just a manifestation of the f-you back to google from Zuck and Boz.
- ffhhj 3y agoHow much is the cost of making all those Quests, and how much does Meta make in a year? It's weird they aren't giving them away for free, or at least with a cheap subscription plan. Seems very short sighted, maybe Apple is paying them to avoid Vision's demise.
- adamomada 3y agoNothing is free, even “free” cellphones w subscription are paying back the cost. Ignoring that, like covid test kits, if you make something (useful) available for actual free, there is unlimited demand and all stock disappears immediately.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> if you make something (useful) available for actual free, there is unlimited demand and all stock disappears immediately This is locally bounded. My community can provide free dog-poo bags. I doubt one could do that in e.g. rural Alabama.
- ffhhj 3y agoOne man's trash is another man's treasure. And when applied to ad ridden platforms the metaphor sticks very well.
- supernovae 3y agoThey have been heavily subsidized. Throwing them out for free wouldn't do anything for anyone. People attach monetary value to product value intrinsically.
- ffhhj 3y agoI say Meta is a heavy lifter that can fully subside them. They want us to strap an ad ridden device to our heads? Won't really work with the price higher than $0.
- rationalfaith 3y ago[dead]
- rgbrenner 3y ago"so don’t expect this to result in cheaper VR headsets from other companies with Quest equivalent capabilities." Other VR companies won't need to make their own OS, directly reducing the cost of producing the software for their headset. That's going to lead to cheaper headsets from those companies. Maybe not as cheap as Meta's, but still cheaper than current prices. "VR is held back more by software than hardware. This initiative will be a drag on software development at Meta. Unquestionably. [It] will steal the focus of key developers that would be better spent improving the system." You just said it's held back by software. Software is part of the system. Having a reusable VR OS frees up resources to focus on other parts of the software that build on top of it. Meta isn't doing it out of the goodness of their heart... they want 3rd parties to use this OS, so that when apps are created for their headset, it'll work with Meta's. And since Meta gives away the hardware at cost, they'll win the race. Carmack is so focused on the view of winning through depriving competitors of resources, he thinks there's tension when Meta executes a strategy that grows VR and puts them at the center, ensuring their long term success.
- oersted 3y ago> Meta already sells the Quest systems basically at production cost, and just ignores the development costs It is a bit ambiguous, but it sounds like they sell the Quest at hardware cost and take the loss in all software costs and R&D. So it's irrelevant that other VR companies won't have the costs of building the OS, the headsets cannot be cheaper unless they optimize the production, which they are unlikely to do better than Meta (except perhaps for Chinese companies).
- cosmotic 3y agoWhat I gathered from Carmack is the cost Mets sells their hardware at is BOM plus assembly. He specifically excluded development cost, which I presume includes OS and software.
- sxp 3y agoWhen I was at Google working on VR there, I was always jealous of Oculus's vertical integration that let them move so much faster than Google's VR team. Working with partner hardware was the biggest time sink in terms of utility gained per hour spent for Google's VR plans and it's going to be a giant drag for Meta. Because of business contracts, there were firewalls in the source code which meant fixing bugs that spanned the stack took forever and there was a bunch of back-and-forth between companies about whose responsibility it is. This is very different from the standard culture of Google & Meta where a dev can (relatively) easily access the source code for any part of the stack and fix the bug without going through tons of red tape. On top of this, hardware partners have very different goals from the core OS developer (i.e, Google or Meta) who want to grow the ecosystem. So the hardware vendors add various features to their hardware and the OS devs need to add hacks to work around it. In theory, the OS developer writes a "compatibility" doc and requires hardware makers to follow it. In practice, the hardware maker fails to do so and the OS maker has to put in software hacks to work around hardware bugs. And then engineers on the OS team have to waste time chasing these bugs which affect a tiny portion of users but are high priority due to business contracts. Some of those business contracts made no sense from a VR ecosystem perspective, but Google went through with them for other reasons such as preventing a key phone maker from jumping ship to another OS or company. That's probably what's happening here. Meta doesn't want third-party vendors to build VR solutions on top of AVP or Google's XR OS, so they're offering crumbs to distract other companies.
- supernovae 3y agoI always felt Google did what Google does best by shooting off its own foot by controlling who has access to the google store with an iron fist. Since Meta can't win over google, i guess the next best thing to do is make sure meta store can be on other hardware since G isn't allowing that.
- loulouxiv 3y agoSince you say that you were working on VR at Google, did you work on Cardboard Camera or know someone that did ? Do you think there is any chance that the app woukd be open sourced some day ?
- dvt 3y agoCarmack is 100% correct in his assessment that software is holding VR back way more than hardware. The software is cumbersome, difficult to use, non-intuitive, confusing for newcomers, and glitchy. This is all even though you have a device as powerful as a laptop strapped to your face. Other than a few games (Alyx, Beatsaber, maybe a few others), VR gaming is awful. "Productivity" software is even worse. I regret spending $1500 on my Quest Pro given that I've only used it for like a dozen hours. VR Operating Systems and UI/UX concepts need to be re-thought from the ground up.
- crooked-v 3y agoThe worst part of VR games is the ongoing obsession of developers with trying to replicate FPS games in the worst possible vomit-inducing way, while completely ignoring all the interesting potential in things that barely anyone has even touched yet, like simulation games with virtual dioramas, small-scale games with shared social lobbies, games that play with size/perspective differences, and so on.
- bloopernova 3y agoSomething like Goragoa in VR might be amazing. https://gorogoa.com/ https://gorogoa.com/
- kbenson 3y agoEven with the FPS adjacent games there's a lot of untapped potential there since your input is so much more rich. For a along time I had the idea to create some FPS rogue type game (because I was more interested in the mechanics to follow than the game itself) for VR, where your skill level in a specific aspect affected your perception of the world. High sword skill? While you're swinging a sword the world slows down. High block skill? Same when blocking with a shield. High evasion? When you move while there's a projectile/weapon swinging within a certain distance, same thing. You can apply the concept to many things. I know I'm never going to have the time and attention to do it, but it would be cool to see the idea explored at least, and it's something it's hard to do unless you're actually doing a good approximation of the fidelity of actual movements of a person so the time time difference actually gives them a chance to take advantage of it. I think people focus too much on the 3D aspects of VR and not enough on the interactions, and ways in which those interactions open up completely new gameplay mechanics, not just aping what people can do in real life now that you can see arms and hands.
- Zigurd 3y agoin Zuck's 3-minute video on insta, I initially thought he announced there would be Google Play Store, which would very likely imply Google Mobile Services, too. But I was wrong: Zuck also said "if they (Google) are up for it." If Zuck has to resort to spitballing that idea out loud, I'd say it is far from happening any time soon. That means HorizonOS is def not an Android equivalent to VisionOS. It's just AOSP plus the Horizon SDK. Google should do a deal with Meta. But they guard Android with a very risk-averse approach.
- tempodox 3y agoThere can only be one ad monopolist in the world, and Google sure as hell won’t let the competition in.
- TiredOfLife 3y agoAs I understand, Google (who previously abandoned their Dreams VR thing) is currently working on their own VR version of Android.
- Zigurd 3y agoLast I heard it is called Android XR and Samsung is building a device that will run it. That makes it even less likely they will let the app store and GMS apps ship with Horizon OS
- dark__paladin 3y agoCan I get a reality check on the state of headsets? It seems that the only people interested in these things are Apple/Meta hype boys (if the latter even exists), and people that are interested in VR gaming. I have only ever considered a headset because of games, only to conclude that it would be a severe waste of money, and that approximates the opinion of most people I know (echo chamber acknowledged). I'll repeat the usual sentiments of Glass being a failure, the Vive is nearly ten years old, the Quest is a VR Chat/Beat Saber machine, and the Apple Vision is a Black Mirror style immersive nightmare machine. I want my ideas to be challenged on this, but I really believe that Horizon OS will be a "Did you know that Meta released a VR operating system?" fun fact in 10 years, probably when Apple releases a $5000 Vision Pro 4 Ultimate. Who on Earth is using these things? I realize where I am posting, but who outside the tech world is getting excited about and actually buying/using VR Headsets? Obviously I've been wrong before about tech trends but this one seems to be so blatantly companies sniffing their own farts in regards to "we are the future" sentiments.
- barbariangrunge 3y agoVr is compelling in a way you can’t recognize without trying it, and even peoples memories of it seem less compelling than the actual experience. However, it’s inconvenient enough to use that many people don’t use their headsets as much as they expected. And there’s locomotion challenges that are hard to overcome imho. Finally, theres some privacy and lock in issues with the current iterations of the tech. Valve seems to be the closest thing to the good guys here - is that still true?
- nomel 3y ago> And there’s locomotion challenges that are hard to overcome imho. I think this is the biggest hurdle: getting your VR legs nice and strong. It took me about two weeks of reasonable use before smooth locomotion was possible. I know other people that tried it once, felt sick, and were done with it. I think this is one of the reasons why there's such a big youngster population on Quest games; they don't seem to be affected as much.
- dagmx 3y ago
- jmyeet 3y ago> VR is held back more by software than hardware. VR isn't being "held back" at all. There's simply absolutely no demand for it. It solves no problem for which there is a mass market. It is the ultimate solution looking for a problem. > ... Meta as a company, as well as the individual engineers, want the shine of making industry leading high-end gear. Do they? I suspect this claim is colored by his own experiences at Oculus/Meta but it's not necessarily true. I suspect Meta would be giddy if they could sell 100x as many units of a cheaper unit because it means they would've found a product-market fit of some kind.
- Havoc 3y agoThe first paragraph of that felt like razor sharp insight, and the rest of post...not wrong perhaps but certainly more diffuse. Maybe twitter was right about 140 chars.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- roland35 3y agoHe's absolutely correct about the software needing to improve. It is difficult to set up meetings or group games all the time. It's too bad, because playing with friends is the best way to keep people engaged in VR. There just isn't enough single-person experiences that are long term fun, except maybe watching movies.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoI'm amazed that all of these VR players are dropping the world's easiest to hold ball. Just give people a damn VR headset with the same compute flexibility as a Windows, macOS, or Linux desktop and do away with these stupid walled gardens. The units would fly off the shelf because, whoa! You could actually do something with the damn devices.
- nomel 3y agoFor standalone, Quest 3 was the first generation that really had enough CPU to open the settings menu, at the same time as another app, and not result in a stuttery mess. Until very recently, it has definitely been limited by compute.
- GuB-42 3y agoVR needs low latency and a lot of computing power. It is hard to make it flexible. That's why, a few generations ago at least, game consoles are so much more efficient. Consoles have fixed and specialized hardware, and developers can tune their games to take advantage of every single bit. No need to accommodate for different specs, no costly abstraction layers, no random tasks running in the background,...
- gradschoolfail 3y agoPlease go easy on nitter: http://web.archive.org/web/20240425211438/https://nitter.privacydev.net/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1782826465207165288 http://web.archive.org/web/20240425211438/https://nitter.pri...
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoIf there was a world war 3 coming, what would you need? Invest incthat, not VR headsets
- alisonatwork 3y agoSo, FPV drone goggles?
- tonymet 3y agoHe’s right that “open” isn’t necessarily good. “Sharing” sounds nice but also leads to fragmentation and distraction. Android chose an “open” model and ended up failing on its primary goal as a mobile OS experience, even if some components of android went on to be popular for other applications. It led to chaotic device fragmentation, nearly every major Android vendor going bankrupt , and Google running effectively a charity unit (Pixel) to keep it alive. It only carries on with search engine subsidies. Apple chose “closed” to the chagrin of hacker news “experts”. But the truth that “closed” iOS is a very lucrative, high-margin business. “Open source” sounds nice, but as we’ve seen, many dedicated open source developers end up burned out and under-compensated. “Open” can be a good thing, but is not a guarantee of producing positive outcomes.