4 ms·
I don't know what a "run of the mill HN-er" is, but I'm ethnically Russian and a Russian citizen who was born in USSR and lived in Russia for >20 years of my li
by int_19h 3y ago
I don't know what a "run of the mill HN-er" is, but I'm ethnically Russian and a Russian citizen who was born in USSR and lived in Russia for >20 years of my life. Those wars (and the associated terrorist activity) were my background as a teenager growing up.
Indeed, "Wahhabi radical Islamic terrorism" was how Russian agitprop described it at the time. It is also rather obviously false when you look at the background of people involved. The original Chechen independence movement (1991-1996) was led by Dzhokhar Dudayev, who, before resigning from the armed forces, was a Major General in the Soviet Air Force, and had personally flown combat sorties in Afghanistan against the mujahideen. The notion that he was a "Wahhabi radical" is laughable; by all accounts, he wasn't even religious.
Now, there were many factions among Chechen rebels, and some of them - associated with people like Shamil Basayev and Ibn al-Khattab - were indeed Salafi (not Wahhabi) extremists. Those were also the guys carrying out terrorist attacks in Russia proper, and invading Dagestan in 1999. However, at no point during the existence of Chechnya as a de facto independent entity those forces had overall control of it. The dominant faction was always the nationalists, who were indeed mostly Muslim, but representing Zikrist Sufi Islam (an offshoot of the Qadiriyya tarikat) that has been the traditional Chechen religion since Kunta-Hajji Kishiev introduced it there in early 19th century. Notably, Aslan Maskhadov, who was the president of Chechnya after Dudayev, was of that faction. Again, the notion that those guys were radical Salafis is laughable because, if anything, Salafis hate Sufi almost as much as they hate Shi'a. As a matter of realpolitik, the Salafi faction did have some positions in the government, including those created specifically for them, such as the Ministry of Sharia Security.
During the second war when Russia re-occupied Chechnya, parts of the nationalist faction have defected to Russia; most notably, the Kadyrov family. In independent Chechnya, Akhmad Kadyrov was the Grand Mufti (the similarity of his last name to "Qadiriyya" is not a coincidence). After defection, he became the first president of Chechnya as constituent republic of the Russian Federation, and, of course, his son is still the president today. Nationalists who did not defect were either wiped out or left to establish a government-in-exile, leaving Salafi extremists as the predominant force to wage guerilla war under the flag of their self-proclaimed "Caucasus Emirate".
TL;DR is that the people who are running Chechnya today for the Russians are largely the same people whom Russia was describing as "radical Islamic terrorists" in 1994-1996 while bombing the hell out of civilian population.
- mopsi 3y agoThere's an interesting sidestory to Dudayev. In the late 1980s, he was a divisional commander with HQ in Tartu, occupied Estonia. He had good relations with the local population and Estonian independence movement greatly influenced his views on Chechen independence. Five years later, the extremely brutal methods used by Russia to extinguish Chechen independence influenced Estonia (along with Latvia and Lithuania) to seek NATO membership.