3 ms·

Can you please elaborate which part of the comment you are refuting?

• nyolfen 2y ago
  if it was not more effective than existing options, both sides would not be scaling production and deployment at an unparalleled rate
  • dgroshev 2y ago
    Both sides suffer from shell and ATGM shortage and inability to suppress/destroy air defences, which drives suboptimal adaptations. An FPV drone assembled in a garage from aliexpress components and a tesla battery [1] with a submunition extracted from a cluster shell [2] is more effective than a single old howitzer with 10 shells per 2km of frontline [3], but it's a pretty low bar. The 10% estimate is not mine, it's from a legitimate expert who regularly goes to the frontline in Ukraine. [1]: An amusing anecdote from that podcast: Tesla battery packs are a big source of batteries for FPV drones. The packs can be sourced for next to nothing from totaled Teslas, and individual cells are very reliable. [2]: https://www.twz.com/ukrainians-are-cutting-open-u-s-cluster-shells-to-make-drone-munitions https://www.twz.com/ukrainians-are-cutting-open-u-s-cluster-... [3]: https://foreignpolicy.com/2024/04/17/ukraine-frontline-ammo-russia-war/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2024/04/17/ukraine-frontline-ammo-...