6 ms·
Somehow This $10k Flame-Thrower Robot Dog Is Completely Legal in 48 States
- jszymborski 3y agoI wonder how suitable this is for wildfires if it relies on LIDAR. This is far from my area of expertise, though.
- snapcaster 3y agoYou mean creating them?
- kevingadd 3y agoControlled burns are used to fight fires
- Ragnarork 3y agoWhat concrete needs can there be for a flamethrower? That isn't going to backfire (hah) badly.
- josefresco 3y agoFTA: "The company lists possible applications of the new robot as "wildfire control and prevention," "agricultural management," "ecological conservation," "snow and ice removal," and "entertainment and SFX." But most of all, it sets things on fire in a variety of real-world scenarios."
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoClearing weeds and other grasses
- IncreasePosts 3y agoFarmers use flame throwers near me to burn their fields
- sandworm101 3y agoFire is tool. Sometimes you need to burn invasive species. Sometimes you need to start a small forest fire to prevent a bigger one (controlled burning). Sometimes you need to melt ice off a metal structure that you don't want to touch (HV electrical lines). This is just a safer way to deploy an already-used tool.
- codedokode 3y agoAre ordinary citizens allowed to "start a small forest fire"?
- sandworm101 3y agoNot sure what "ordinary citizen" means, but all sorts of people are involved in forest management. There must be volunteer firefighters out there with the authority to conduct such burns when needed. And I have personally seen crews conduct burns in the pacific northwest, although only of brush rather than a full forest fire. Certainly some civilians can make legitimate use of this robot.
- jimt1234 3y agoWildfire control. The biggest killer with wildfires, or any fire, is the smoke inhalation, and I guess this robot would be immune to that, which is pretty cool. (I got caught in a small house fire as a child. All I remember is not being able to breathe or see anything. I had to basically feel my way out of the house.)
- teeray 3y agoLiterally fighting fire with fire
- tekla 3y agoTo werf flammen
- 15155 3y ago> What concrete needs can there be for a flamethrower? I think that this would be obvious: "Gee, I'd sure like to set something on fire over there, but I'm way too far way to get the job done. If only I had something that would throw flame..."
- kwhitefoot 3y agoWhat are flame throwers for? Apart from the obvious people killing purpose.
- sandworm101 3y agoIn combat, flamethrowers were rarely used to kill. They are meant to terrify. Point a flamethrower at a bunker and those protected inside will surrender.
- shitpostbot 3y agoDid you literally just make that up and try to pass it off as an authoritative fact?
- tdb7893 3y agoWelcome to the internet and especially HN specifically, haha. Also I enjoy that someone called "shitpostbot" is the one calling this out
- sandworm101 3y agoRead about their use. Not the propaganda clips. Read about how they were deployed, the issues with them. They had a very narrow use case in combat.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lupusreal 3y agoWho the hell wants to deal with a surrendering bunker? You let rip with the flame thrower and fill that bunker with carbon monoxide. In the wars and battles flamethrowers are famous for, Marines were doing shit like collecting skulls. Neither side was in a hostage taking mood.
- OJFord 3y agoBurning crop stubble (where that's legal) or heath control?
- sandworm101 3y agoIf you have ever used an actual flamethrower, you will appreciate this robot. Flamethrowers are hella dangerous for the people using/handling/loading them.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoYou can also buy actual flame throwers I dont recall the price but it aint cheap.
- fragmede 3y agoThe one the boring company made was only $500, iirc. cheaper than many guns out there
- sandworm101 3y agoThat wasn't a flamethrower. It was a propane torch. It might have shot flames, but that does not make it a flamethrower.
- fragmede 3y agointeresting. I'm not a flamethrower-ologist. Does it have to use gasolihe to properly be considered a flame thrower?
- sandworm101 3y agoIt has to throw burning liquid. Point musk's "flamethrower" at someone for a second and you will burn their clothes and hair. Throw burning gasoline or napalm at them for a second and they will need head-to-toe skin grafts.
- fragmede 3y agointeresting, thanks
- throwup238 3y ago> Specific restrictions exist in Maryland, where flamethrowers require a Federal Firearms License to own, and California, where the range of flamethrowers cannot exceed 10 feet. As a Californian I knew I was going to be disappointed before I even opened the link. I like the weather and the governance but we’re really not allowed to own anything fun. Can’t even own a ferret or a hedgehog.
- lgeorget 3y agoPresumably 10 feet is already room for plenty of fun.
- black_puppydog 3y agomeh, about 3 meters.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoMaybe for children. I think the CA Regulators are out of touch with the typical flamethrower consumer and lack cognitive empathy.
- hypeatei 3y agoIt's funny because most of the firearm laws aren't even that enforceable. For example: magazine size limits. It isn't federally prohibited to ship large magazines into California, so unless a cop catches you with one then you can easily own a magazine larger than 10 rounds.
- 15155 3y agoOr just 3D print a completely functional standard-capacity magazine in a matter of hours and purchase a spring from McMaster-Carr.
- tylerflick 3y agoAlmost any company selling magazines in the US is enforcing state laws as well. Reference: I used to work in this industry and encoded local legislation enforcements in our order processing software.
- neilv 3y agoMarketing materials for the standalone flamethrower product from the same company, https://throwflame.com/arc/ https://throwflame.com/arc/ , includes a photo carousel of mounting it on various military rifles in civilian contexts. Gun manufacturers somehow don't get sued into oblivion for how their products are used. I suspect that product teams found to be reckless in other categories don't have the same protections. (Is a lawyer going to try to argue that the US Founding Fathers envisioned a well-regulated militia of robot dogs with flamethrowers on their backs?)
- arcticbull 3y ago> Gun manufacturers somehow don't get sued into oblivion for how their products are used. Well you can thank the gun manufacturer liability shield laws for that. Like the The Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA) of 2005.
- 15155 3y agoThe alternative is special interest groups suing arms manufacturers out of existence as a backdoor means to deprive people of their Second Amendment rights. One can still sue an arms manufacturer if a faulty product explodes in their face.. they just can't cry foul about what other people do with these lawful products.
- bumby 3y ago>they just can't cry foul about what other people do with these lawful products. I think it's a bit more nuanced. This statement is mainly related to manufacturing defects, but there are other avenues to liability more related to "reasonableness". It's also important to note this has changed over time, from former negligence liabilities to the current form of strict liability. (Point being: how society defines liability changes)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 15155 3y ago
- beeboobaa3 3y agoHow hard would it be to swap that flame thrower for a machine gun?
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoDepends on what you mean by "machine gun"[1]. By the most common military definition, no. The recoil force would probably throw it to the ground, and even if it did not, the accuracy would be so laughable that it'd be more efficient to just load cyberdog with the same weight in high explosive fragmentation. A SMG or autopistol . . maybe. Something like the Skorpion, firing .32 ACP, might be low recoil enough for aimed fire. [1] There's a few categories here, and popular/legal categories differ from military ones. Legal "machine guns" include firearm capable of automatic fire, but this includes: 1) Autopistols and submachine guns (SMGs) fire pistol calibers, from .22LR (American 180) to .45 ACP (Thompson); 2) Assault Rifles, firing intermediate power cartridges like .223 and 7.62x39mm; 3) Battle Rifles are firing full power rifle cartridges - .308 Winchester and 7.62x54mm- from a box or drum magazine and can fire in full auto[a]; 4) General Purpose Machine Guns (GPMGs) capable of sustained belt-fed rapid fire with full-power rifle cartridges; 5) Here we're entering the realm of support weapons[b], firing Heavy Machine Gun rounds like .50 BMG, 12.7mm, 14mm, and other weapons like the Mark 19 automatic grenade launcher or the M134 Minigun (which fires .308 but a whole lot of them). [1.a] Lots and LOTS of Internet Tough Guys will insist that the M14 or FAL on full auto is totally controllable by Real Men - i.e., it's only the sissification of our cucked armed forces that have brought on the curse of the Intermediate Cartridge. I'll leave judgement to the reader. Incidentally, the Venn Diagram of "Battle Rifle" and the older 1900s-1930s term "Light Machine Gun" is, functionally, a single large circle - it's just the advancement in materials and machining that make them any different. So why didn't LMGs take off back when men were Manly Men and could handle the POWER? Heh heh heh heh yeah. Physics wins again. [1.b] Needless to say, a whole other category of internet moron insists that .50 BMG on autofire is controllable by a "man enough" infantryman operating singly. I'm sorry that this opinion exists, like, as a human being, but make your own judgement, as always.
- 15155 3y agoAiming accurately on the move would be the hard part here (but this has been long-solved for fixed/emplaced weapons, at least.) But any SMG or carbine could be installed quite easily.
- ccozan 3y agoActually forget about the flamethrower, I want the robo-dog, is just 1600 USD! How come?!
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoIt’s from China. The base model is 1,600 and is not terribly impressive in terms of payload carrying capacity (few kilos). The higher end one from the same maker can carry 12kg of stuff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barbariangrunge 3y agoI thought it was the right to bear-armnaments, not the right to dog-armnaments
- teeray 3y ago> They are not considered firearms by federal agencies Despite being literally armaments of fire
- 15155 3y ago"Firearm" has a very specific legal definition pertaining to explosive-powered projectile weapons.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoUnlike the Tesla "flamethrower" referenced in the article which is just a propane torch rather than a liquid flamethrower, this appears to be much more like the actual weapon of war?
- 15155 3y agoYes, this actually uses liquid-state fuel which is substantially more sticky, spreads more, can actually "wet" things, and doesn't instantly burn up upon atomization like LP.
- diakt 3y agoPeople are reasonably confused as to why this is being viewed as a potential value add for firefighting. This is generally within my area of expertise as a former wildland guy and dev. I personally think this could be a game changer within reason in 8-12 years. There are two situations where this could be useful, either on an active fire or as part of a prophylactic approach. On an active fire, traditional approaches on the ground involve figuring out where the fire is going, and squeezing it on the sides until it becomes manageable at the point. Backburns are sometimes used (under very specific conditions) to create areas of black (black meaning burned). Black is safe - removes flashy fuels at the front, and can corral the fire's ability to run. However, you do not want to be downwind of a fire, so backburns are used sparingly, and rarely in front of really dangerous fires. If you lay a backburn right with drip torches, you can actually encourage your fire to run backwards (back in backburn) into the active fire by burning the area closest to you, then burning closer and closer to the active fire, even against the wind. This robot could potentially allow us to set deeper backburns, so more effective counterfires. I am skeptical of my own argument because of price point (not sure how you can thermal shield to avoid sacrificing a bot, though to be fair, backburns don't generally get that hot immediately). That's the active side. On the passive side, we have incredibly unhealthy forests on the west coast. We have changed our approaches but are toughing through the tail end of the consequences not allowing the natural cycle to cleanse ladder fuels from forests. We also live closer to the urban wildland interface nowadays. On the climate change side, we are getting more lightning strikes, which are the primary cause of western wildfires, and you can make an argument that wind patterns are changing. Bark beetles, surprisingly enough, are probably not causative (I will avoid this rabbithole but it's intuitively quite offputting), though they are spreading northward to novel biomes by the day. To get to the point, we have a ton of biomass that is dangerous to have in forests, and it's several orders of magnitude larger than our current work capacity within the USFS/BLM, even just waving off Alaska as a lost cause. Planned burns are increasingly socially accepted, and robots like these may offer an increased level of fire control, multiply work capacity, and minimize person risk. This is a much stickier argument (a lot of coordination, training, predicting demand increase for planned burns) but I'll wait to see. I'd say bear case for using these things on fire is survivability, but also fuel load capacity, air possibly being a better resource vector (e.g. napalm bomblets), and departmental adoption, not to even address the standard swathe of hard problems (movement planning, battery capacity, dist syst for hell machines) that we all recognize here. I'm not optimistic, but I'm extremely curious to see how things go.
- sheepscreek 3y agoIt was a little jarring to watch the promotional video. I am struggling to explain exactly how I feel, but I will try: I think the more real impact of this will be an increase in the number wildfires, and the domino effect that causes - like gobbling up entire forests or burning up homes. I guess you can argue it's not any different compared to a flamethrower gun. BUT..when you are remote controlling the thing that shoots fire, it could lead to a sense of dissociation or desensitization. It may feel like a game, than reality. I hope that makes sense.
- generalizations 3y agoNote that good forestry involves setting controlled burns, which this could help with.
- generalizations 3y agoOddly, I don't see any mention of what fuel this thing uses. Gasoline? Edit, nevermind, it was a little buried: https://throwflame.com/products/napalm-mix-fuel-gelling-agents/ https://throwflame.com/products/napalm-mix-fuel-gelling-agen...
- infotapeworm 3y agoGod, I love America