4 ms·
> and correctly refusing to censor speech outside of Australian jurisdiction. Speech? Regardless of any stance here on the matter the Australian Government is
by defrost 3y ago
> and correctly refusing to censor speech outside of Australian jurisdiction.
Speech?
Regardless of any stance here on the matter the Australian Government isn't asking to censor any speech .. they want to dampen down the glorification of violent acts by asking social media to not carry the video of the stabbing.
You can write paragraphs about the event, transcribe what was said, the speech part isn't being asked to be censored here.
On the second point, coordinated five eyes actions requiring oversight from citizens of all countries involved and being kept in check is one thing; using the statements of Senator Jacqui Lambie (a fringe member of a finge political party (Clive Palmer, the Vogon offspring of Jabba the Hutt)) as representitive of Australian policy makes as much sense as taking Senator Ted Cruz a spokesperson for the USofA.
Pragmatically spies and cops might want encryption with backdoors, practically they're unlikely to get this .. "even in Australia".
- DEADMINCE 3y ago>the Australian Government isn't asking to censor any speech .. they want to dampen down the glorification of violent acts by asking social media to not carry the video of the stabbing. Posting the video is a form of speech.
- defrost 3y agoUse your words. Explain how, if "video is a form of speech" it is the case that Miller_v._California : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v._California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v._California and Paris Adult Theatre I v. Slaton : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Adult_Theatre_I_v._Slaton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Adult_Theatre_I_v._Slato... even exist as U.S. Supreme Court rulings?
- DEADMINCE 3y ago> Use your words. Please keep in mind the HN guidelines. Be kind. Don't be snarky. [0] The cases you linked are about limits on speech. They don't do anything to demonstrate video isn't a speech. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- defrost 3y agoThey specifically limit video | film. They specifically treat film | video in a manner distinct from the spoken or written word.
- pseudalopex 3y agoMiller's offense was mailing brochures. The Miller test has been applied to books. Paris Adult Theatre I v. Slaton distinguished businesses and homes according to the article.
- defrost 3y agoBut I'm guessing we're agreed that video and books have been treated seperately and that limitations on availability have been applied to film|video content by a Federal US Government despite a "free speech" ammendment? Which really is all that is sufficient to establish the point that free speech has categories and that video has been treated in as a seperate category to the spoken word and both to the written word. The claim that free speech is equally and equivilantly { film , speech , writing } in the USofA is false in law. They overlap to a large degree, but not perfectly. There is precedent for limiting video content within a free speech society.
- pseudalopex 3y agoYou admit now video is speech? > But I'm guessing we're agreed that video and books have been treated seperately In a narrow and irrelevant manner only. Visual child pornography is extra illegal. > There is precedent for limiting video content within a free speech society. There is precedent for limiting all forms of speech.
- defrost 3y agoThere is: * Speech, * Writing, * Video, * Dance, * Morse Code, and many many other forms of communication. > Visual child pornography is extra illegal. But written isn't? Clearly there are priors for Australia limiting video content.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoWhen people say “free speech”, they are talking about information in general. Video is speech under that definition. I understand that the Australian government wants to avoid glorifying violent acts, but I would argue that it is better to depict the world as it is, rather than try to hide the bad parts and pretend it’ll fix itself. If the Australian government isn’t authoritarian, at best they can politely ask media to not carry it, but they should not be able to force it. That’s only possible under authoritarian regimes where the government thinks they have a right to control information.
- defrost 3y agoWhat about under the definition of "speech" .. freedom to discuss. With respect to video, let us note that even in the USofA the absolutist interpretation of the First Amendment (US) as applied to video pornography has never been sustained by the (US) Supreme Court. It's a shit show there with 80+ years of bun fights and variation by state. I understand the position that you're taking here, but it's not that clear cut in the US so why should it be in Australia?