4 ms·
>I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me. I heard those quote for the first time about 4 years a
by al_borland 3y ago
>I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me.
I heard those quote for the first time about 4 years ago. I had often been a bit disappointed with myself for not taking more notes while reading, or reviewing what I read in a way where I could be one of those people to bring up quotes and concepts, citing back to the original source, with freakish accuracy. This quote made me feel better about simply reading, getting whatever I get out of it, and trusting that I’ve gained some perspective, even if I can’t cite all the sources that built my perspective on a topic.
- rramadass 3y ago> simply reading, getting whatever I get out of it, and trusting that I’ve gained some perspective, This is the way to approach it, particularly in these times when knowledge is so vast and there is so much to read. The principle to keep in mind is "Knowledge for Knowledge sake." But what has happened ever since Industrialization is the focus on output (for a Economy). Hence everything is supposed to be done for a job/money/fame/etc. which i believe is detrimental in the general case.
- verisimi 3y agoWho has knowledge though? Is the acceptance of this or that thought of another person's 'knowledge'? Are you filling up on knowledge or nonsense?
- rramadass 3y agoThis is where your Intellect's "Power of Discrimination" comes into play i.e. you are the decider on what is "Knowledge" or "Nonsense" for you. A good example is "Organized Religion".
- _aavaa_ 3y ago> particularly in these times when knowledge is so vast and there is so much to read. I come down on the other side of this. The implicit assumption here is that more is better, but it's like drinking from the firehose. > The principle to keep in mind is "Knowledge for Knowledge sake." The other position is that knowledge is only useful if it lets you do something that you couldn't do without it. If you're gaining knowledge for the pleasure of gaining it, and I see no need to justify why one would do this, then whether you read deeply or read widely doesn't make much of a difference. But if you want to do something with that knowledge, the approach you take should be informed by what you want to do.
- rramadass 3y ago> The implicit assumption here is that more is better, No, that is the assumption that you are making and not what i meant. It is an undeniable fact that today we have a far far greater amount of Scientific and Technological Knowledge (sheer Data without making any value judgements) than in any time in the past Human history. Our Society's dependence on Science/Technology has also increased exponentially since the beginning of Industrialization thus forcing us to know/learn more and more. Also see my comment here - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40154158 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40154158 > The other position is that knowledge is only useful if it lets you do something that you couldn't do without it. This is a very limiting viewpoint which is what the posted article and my comments are arguing against. The utility of some knowledge may not be apparent at its inception but may turn out to be of utmost importance when other fields have also developed so everything can come together into a greater whole. A good example is how Materials Science revolutionized Civil Engineering in the building of man-made structures. > If you're gaining knowledge for the pleasure of gaining it, and I see no need to justify why one would do this, then whether you read deeply or read widely doesn't make much of a difference. The justification has to do with getting exposed to a greater amount of concepts/ideas and not necessarily understanding/assimilating everything. Here reading widely does make a difference. > But if you want to do something with that knowledge, the approach you take should be informed by what you want to do. Only in the specific case when the end-goal/knowledge is clear eg. Engineering. Many a time in scientific research one does not even know the utility of something until sometime in the future when things align correctly. A great example is "Number Theory" which G.H.Hardy thought useless as a practical discipline but which has turned out to be indispensable in today's information technology (in cryptography etc.) centric world.
- _aavaa_ 3y ago> It is an undeniable fact that today we have a far far greater amount of Scientific and Technological Knowledge I don't dispute it. What I dispute is the implication I believe your proposing, which is "there is more knowledge, and therefore we need to read broadly and not focus as much on deep understanding". If that is not what you mean, please correct me since I don't see what other implication you mean. > The utility of some knowledge may not be apparent at its inception but may turn out to be of utmost importance when other fields have also developed so everything can come together into a greater whole. I don't disagree. But to apply this knowledge later you need to have remembered about it, and writing notes (which is where this discussion started) absolutely helps with this. I'm arguing for writing down the concepts that you found important or interesting at the time, not a synopsis of each subchapter. > The justification has to do with getting exposed to a greater amount of concepts/ideas and not necessarily understanding/assimilating everything. Here reading widely does make a difference. But reading widely only makes a difference to the degree that you do assimilate the content and that it changes you. > Many a time in scientific research one does not even know the utility of something until sometime in the future when things align correctly. Except we are not talking about doing scientific research (where I agree getting more knowledge is the whole point). We're talking about reading other people's work to get something out of it. And, especially, in this context there is a trade-off between "just in case" knowledge and "just in time" knowledge.
- Zambyte 3y agoI still encourage you to write though. Writing has seriously transformed the way that I think. I refer to my notes very often too.
- beebmam 3y agoHow do you know that writing has improved the way that you think? By what metrics did you come to that conclusion? If someone else showed you that by writing their transformed thinking reduced their quality of life, would you be less prescriptive to others?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scubbo 3y ago"prescriptive" is a strong word to apply to an _encouragement_.
- kaonwarb 3y agoIt would be quite sad if metrics were the only acceptable means of conveying personal experience.
- pvg 3y agoBy what metrics Before they started writing regularly they were just a Zambit and look at them now. And who knows, you could make beebman following their method.
- Zambyte 3y agoI have never experienced people telling me I have a good memory before I started my current writing habit. Within the last few months I have noticed 3 or 4 times people have made remarks about me having a good memory. I don't think that I actually have a much better memory than I used to, I think I have just offloaded so much that was occupying my brain into my computer without fear of forgetting it, that I am able to allocate a lot more memory towards things people actually notice. I also believe I spend much more of my mental capacity on reason rather than recall. I think I have gotten slightly better at reasoning due to that, just going off how I feel when I try to reason about things; I feel more lucid than I used to. Trying to "remember" things is really more of a mechanical process for me than it is a mental one. I think of some keyword that is vaguely related to the concept I'm interested in, and then hop around the hyperlinks and backlinks in my notes until I find what I'm looking for. Sometimes I will start this process to find a spot that I want to start writing a new note, only to discover that I have actually written the note already! That is always a trip when it happens.
- gr8r 3y ago> where I could be one of those people to bring up quotes and concepts, citing back to the original source, with freakish accuracy If you cannot retrieve a few timeless (to you or in general) quotes/concepts/dialogues and a few trending ones (trending in big or small circles) - there is some amount of info/tasks overload going on. Also I think we find people who can "bring up quotes and concepts with freakish accuracy" cool for some reasons.
- gladuz 3y agoCal Newport talked about this in his podcast. Just taking a book and going in is really important to reduce the friction.
- swozey 3y agoI'm pretty sure it's my ADHD causing me to have horrendous memory issues but I have read so, so many books since I was a kid. Have tons of favorites. Stuff like the entire Wheel of Time series, things like that. I can barely remember anything but vague events and characters. Like, my favorite book is Canticle for Leibowitz which I've read multiple times but I couldn't even tell you the main characters name other than he's a priest-type of character and what the general book is about. I guess one benefit of that is that I can read the same book over and over and over again but like you said, it feels so strange/wrong that I can't remember so much more. Reading more complicated things like G.E.B., Michel de Montaigne, etc is practically pointless for me, I won't remember any of the theories/quotes and it feels practically useless to even go through. By the time I'm on chapter 5 I've probably forgotten 1-4.