4 ms·
> "Open Source" may help find bugs but it can just as easily help exploit them --- or as in this case, intentionally create and plant them. The bug was found b
by graemep 3y ago
> "Open Source" may help find bugs but it can just as easily help exploit them --- or as in this case, intentionally create and plant them.
The bug was found before it hit production, so to that extent things worked. If there was a similar attack on proprietary software (from a malicious or suborned employee, a contractor, a sub contractor, or from the vast amounts of open source code used in most of it, or by some other route) we might never have known. It certainly could not have been investigated by someone who did not have access to the source.
- ranger_danger 3y ago> The bug was found before it hit production But it was found by pure accident in someone's spare time and not as part of any standard testing/procedures.
- chasil 3y agoHow can we be sure that it was found by accident?
- ranger_danger 3y agoWe can't, you're right I just took them for their word on it. Just like we can't know that this was actually intentional or done by a professional or state actor.
- graemep 3y agoI thought he was working, not doing it in his spare time? He is paid to work on Postgres and that is what he was doing when he spotted it, right?
- jqpabc123 3y agoThe bug was found before it hit production, so to that extent things worked. Not according to the article: "Ubuntu 24.04 LTS (Noble Numbat) also contained the infected files, which have since been removed. Advisories were also issued by Arch and openSUSE." Bottom line: This is proof that there is very little vetting of either code or the people involved in these projects. In many cases, the people are unknown/anonymous. This is a gaping security hole that someone just spent a lot of time and effort to exploit.
- graemep 3y agoApparently not: "The affected version of xz-utils was only in noble-proposed" https://ubuntu.com/security/CVE-2024-3094 https://ubuntu.com/security/CVE-2024-3094
- ranger_danger 3y agoI mean that was always the case with open source. But also the vast majority of programmers, even looking directly at every patch submitted to XZ, wouldn't have found this or had any idea what it could do.