2 ms·
> Apps like Truecaller refuse to work without so many permissions. Android apps have had bad habits for a very long time because Android didn’t have the granul
by newscracker 2y ago
> Apps like Truecaller refuse to work without so many permissions.
Android apps have had bad habits for a very long time because Android didn’t have the granular runtime permissions system like iOS did (Android had only install time permissions that was either grant all or no install allowed). Even though Android brought granular runtime permissions from version 6 (?), apps have continued to badger users for every permission that allows them to collect more data. Android users have also been conditioned from the beginning to provide all permissions. So apps expect them to provide what they ask or refuse to work.
On iOS, Apple has stated in its policies for a long time that apps should continue to work even when permissions are denied (with obvious caveats, like for example camera not working if camera permission is not granted).
It’s a stark and disturbing contrast when comparing how Android apps refuse to work whereas the same app by the same developer on iOS would be a lot better behaved even when various permissions are denied.
BTW, Truecaller on iOS will work without getting permissions to access contacts. It will also work if it’s not given access to SMS.
- ryandrake 2y agoDo a CTRL-F (or CMD-F) through these comments and look for the word "refuse". It comes up way too often. This seems to be a huge problem: Apps taking it upon themselves to "refuse to work" until the user gives in to their demands. It's like a hostage negotiation. Developers really shouldn't have the power to say "well I'm in charge, user, not you, so fuck off."