3 ms·
This is one of the few cases where I, a person who once dated a self-proclaimed "eat the rich" communist, think that Musk's politics is really useful. Why? Lef
by ben_w 3y ago
This is one of the few cases where I, a person who once dated a self-proclaimed "eat the rich" communist, think that Musk's politics is really useful.
Why? Lefty eco-conscious plant-based-diet types like me switching away from ICE cars is not sufficient to fix greenhouse emissions, and the only way to get everyone on board is for someone to make vehicles for the political tribe that wants to own and drive the exact sort of vehicle that people like me want kept off public roads, vehicles like Cybertruck.
So, if we're having a big fight left/right battle over "is Cybertruck bad" and that battles leads to all the Republicans in the USA buying one as a status symbol just to "own the libs", that's great, because now everyone is going electric.
- leereeves 3y agoIt's not going to though. Republicans don't care about Elon, Tesla, or the Cybertruck. Instead Democrats are apparently choosing to buy hybrids instead of electric cars. (I guess they aren't that worried about climate change.)
- ben_w 3y agoI think hybrids are a good thing. 90% of the (environmental) benefit for 10% of the battery requirement. This also applies to putting PV on the cars themselves: 80% of the mean daily milage is still really useful, even though it really isn't going to be enough for everyone.
- ryandvm 3y agoThe only problem is that there's absolutely nothing green about an 8,000 pound truck that will only last 10 years. It can't tow worth a shit, so it's absolutely not a truck for people that actually need trucks. It's environmentally disastrous to manufacture, tears up roads, chews through tires, and gets abysmal mileage when compared to other electric vehicles. It's just an emotional support truck for cyrpto bros.
- ben_w 3y ago> It's just an emotional support truck for cyrpto bros. I was considering describing it as a "penis extension" in the original comment, but sure. > It's environmentally disastrous to manufacture, tears up roads, chews through tires, and gets abysmal mileage when compared to other electric vehicles. And compared to ICE trucks? Because that's what matters. Not being a truck person, I'll have to just assume you're correct about it only lasting 10 years or not being able to tow, despite these being surprising claims.
- lamontcg 3y agoThe problem is that the Cybertruck appeals mostly to people with an Elon Musk fetish. It doesn't actually appeal to "Republicans", just to silicon valley Libertarian Party techno-optimist types with more disposable income than sense. There aren't enough of them to make a difference. It doesn't appeal to your average Republican F150 driver in Ohio.
- r00fus 3y agoMusk's approach is a complete fail, tho. He pissed off his existing customer base (eco-lefties and centrists) and the right-fringe he courted didn't buy. But honestly it's not about politics. Musk sounds and acts unstable. He is a splitting his time among 4 companies and pushing a vanity project (Cybertruck) that really no one wants (those 2M signups were for a 40k or 50k vehicle). He's a horrible CEO and politics aside, his departure will be a sign that Tesla is ready to move forward.
- rsync 3y ago"... the only way to get everyone on board is for someone to make vehicles for the political tribe that wants to own and drive the exact sort of vehicle that people like me want kept off public roads ..." I cautiously, tentatively agree with you. However, the cybertruck is not the correct aesthetic for achieving this and is, therefore, a huge missed opportunity. An electric vehicle that looked like this: https://www.mercedes-benz-trucks.com/en_GB/models/unimog-implement-carrier.html https://www.mercedes-benz-trucks.com/en_GB/models/unimog-imp... ... would be much closer to the mark and could, theoretically, achieve the outcome you're describing.