7 ms·
Android 15 may make it harder for sideloaded apps to get sensitive permissions
- wkat4242 3y agoHmm I hope there's still a way to bypass this. I sideload all my apps using aurora store (so I don't have to sign in with a Google account) and I don't want them limited in functionality.
- bitwize 3y agoIncreased restrictions on which programs may run and what they can do are the future of computing. We really can't afford the risks of letting everybody just run arbitrary code. Windows and macOS are next. It didn't mention apps installed with 'adb install'. I think you might be able to run those with no restrictions. And LineageOS, GrapheneOS, and so forth may give you the option of disabling this feature or making it more configurable.
- varispeed 3y ago> We really can't afford the risks of letting everybody just run arbitrary code. The pleb running applications they want on the device they own? Madness!
- Sakos 3y agoWhile poorly phrased, I think the concern is legit. As somebody who wants full control over my system, I don't want most of the applications I use on a day to day basis to have that same full control over my system. I'm a separate entity from the programs I use and the people who make the programs I use. The world is so much more complex than it used to be. I'd rather applications be limited in what they can access on my system by default, and a way to change it based on my needs. I don't want the programs to decide on their own what they're entitled to anymore. There's been a fundamental breach of trust by too many actors too many times.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- varispeed 3y agoYes, you should be able to run apps you want in a way you want. Not the way the manufacturer or OS vendor wants. Of course sandboxing options should be available, but if you wanted to run an app fully unrestricted, you should be able to. I am still quite upset that I cannot run call recording apps on Android as they can't obtain permission to record audio during a call. edit: Just to add, call recording is legal in my country. Years ago it saved me from losing money when insurance company attempted to scam me. I agreed to a policy over the phone based on the promised features. When I got the documents mailed, it turned out most of what was promised was missing in the agreement. Then company said they never promised these things and wanted to charge me substantial cancellation fee. Once I told them I have recordings, they backtracked on everything and cancelled it. The other ways I found it very useful was recording calls with my doctor so I could listen again in case I forgot or misheard something and also I used to record calls with my very ill relative to have some memories of him. Now I cannot do that anymore.
- curt15 3y agoThe key point for someone "who wants full control over my system" is that *you*, the end user, have the final say over what programs are entitled to.
- bitwize 3y agoEnd users can't be trusted. Most of them are a "Taylor Swift nudes here! Download this file, open it, and enable all requested permissions" away from being pwned. The most effective defense against this kind of attack has been allowlisting what can be run.
- thejohnconway 3y agoIf Macs too far down that road I’ll move to Linux for my desktop computing. It’s already getting annoying.
- wkat4242 3y agoYes exactly. I already did just that.
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoIf it happens to you with any degree of regularity does that not imply that you are regularly granting new code access to sensitive aspects of your machine? macOS is a far far cry from, let’s say, Vista UAC.
- thejohnconway 3y agoUpdates break thing tha used to work. My mouse situation drives me crazy, and my Wacom Cintiq stopped working a couple of months back. File management is starting to be a problem.
- keyringlight 3y agoAs far as desktop OSes go, I think the much larger problem is how to let users control the degree of sandboxing an application has. On mobile we're broadly used to each application asking for permissions (and whether we've trained users to just hammer 'allow' until it proceeds) and each is largely independent. Windows also has its legacy software that wouldn't know about new restrictions, so would need dummy access until allowed, and UI for the user to gain understanding about why their newly downloaded utility can't access their webcam and all their files yet, and how to rectify that. Windows already has something like this through controlled folder access, but I've yet to hear of someone who turns it on. Part of the biggest strength of desktops is how all the software/hardware parts combine, so I think this is high stakes in terms of not pissing people off so the feature actually gets used.
- gravescale 3y agoYes, the open software war has been lost fairly comprehensively and many programs that are routinely installed on computers are dreadful spyware, but instead of being random ill-advised junk from some forum, they're 389MB of analytics masquerading as productivity software from the very biggest corporate names in software. Who know what all that evil junk is doing with its execute bit and filesystem and network access. (https://xkcd.com/1200/ https://xkcd.com/1200/) And if you think the situation is bad with Teams and Dropbox and other "Western-style" software, it's way worse elsewhere in the world.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>We really can't afford the risks of letting everybody just run arbitrary code. You are, of course, talking about JavaShit right?
- cess11 3y ago'So today we have marketing departments who say things like "we don't need computers, we need... appliances. Make me a computer that doesn't run every program, just a program that does this specialized task, like streaming audio, or routing packets, or playing Xbox games, and make sure it doesn't run programs that I haven't authorized that might undermine our profits". And on the surface, this seems like a reasonable idea -- just a program that does one specialized task -- after all, we can put an electric motor in a blender, and we can install a motor in a dishwasher, and we don't worry if it's still possible to run a dishwashing program in a blender. But that's not what we do when we turn a computer into an appliance. We're not making a computer that runs only the "appliance" app; we're making a computer that can run every program, but which uses some combination of rootkits, spyware, and code-signing to prevent the user from knowing which processes are running, from installing her own software, and from terminating processes that she doesn't want. In other words, an appliance is not a stripped-down computer -- it is a fully functional computer with spyware on it out of the box.' https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Coming_War_on_General_Computation https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Coming_War_on_General_Com...
- izacus 3y agoApps installed from alternative stores (using APIs made for those) aren't subject to those restrictions - it's written in the article. It's explicilty restricted only to apps that don't use the new "app store" APIs in Android.
- tetris11 3y agoAs with all non-feature creep, I feel the need to compulsively blurt out: "Yet."
- wkat4242 3y agoAurora isn't an official third party store. There isn't much chance that Google will whitelist it because it's a privacy alternative for the play store itself. Google has been all over it trying to block it so I doubt it will select it as an exception.
- izacus 3y agoWhat do you mean "official third party store"? There's no such thing. It's an OS level API where store needs to register itself as a store unrelated to Google (it's an AOSP concept).
- Sakos 3y agoRead the article. There's an explicit white-list for being exempt from this new restriction and only "trusted installers" will be on it. Clearly the Play Store will be exempt, but we have no idea what will be put on the white list according to what criteria. As pointed out in the article's conclusion.
- RobotToaster 3y ago> Apps installed from alternative stores (using APIs made for those) aren't subject to those restrictions These restrictions already exist for in call audio accessibility APIs. At least one call recorder app has gone as far as making their own app store to bypass these restrictions.
- realharo 3y agoYes, if you're willing to jump through scare dialogs and search for where in the UI to find "hidden" settings, you can manually override it per app as before.
- account42 3y agoIt's like they are asking to get slapped by the EU. Hopefully they will be, and hard.
- izacus 3y agoWhich EU law would that violate? Especially since EU is lately very sensitive about digital abuse.
- jeroenhd 3y agoThe Digital Markets Act (DMA), presumably: the law that forced Apple to allow installing apps from third party sources (though I doubt their current solution is compliant). Large vendors (gatekeepers) are not allowed to give themselves benefits that their competitors don't have. A third party alternative must have the ability to compete with the gatekeepers, which means Google isn't allows to treat Google Maps specially, Apple isn't allowed to treat Safari specially, and so on. They can still comply with these laws if they have a quick and accessible method of getting your app store listed in the exemption list (which would quickly run into edge cases from apps like Aurora and the abusive shitstains that install stalkerware), especially if they show their willingness by pre-populating the list with common Play Store alternatives. They could also just disable the feature in EU phones (the way Apple chose to comply with the law) so they don't break the law. Or they could leave the list unpopulated inside the EU, making the OS harder to use for EU users but not exempting themselves as a middle finger to the EU lawmakers (the way Apple tends to comply with these laws).
- miki123211 3y agoThis doesn't apply to third-party stores I think. If this works anything like other prompts of this kind, this will only appear for apps installed directly from an apk file, but not via apps installed from a store, even if the store itself was installed through an app file. In principle, it would be possible to create a store that installs apps from the file system, perhaps with some affordances to enable automatic updates from a URL. I don't think it could support app files directly, there are some extra requirements on store "bundles", but an "installer" should be possible.
- iAkashPaul 3y agoI actually want Play Store apps to be equally configurable. Apps like Truecaller refuse to work without so many permissions. Being Android you'd expect some way to provide a dummy contact book, location & other accesses that apps need. Heck I'd want an option to freeze apps once I'm logged in & only unfreeze them when I need to use them. Would absolutely improve battery life.
- Xeamek 3y agoIt's up to app maker to ensure it will work without permissions granted. ...but ofc most app makers are lazy and just throw up error whenever they don't get what their wont, forcing users to give up. I guess google could introduce a dummy system for every single service and feed that to the apps when the permission is not granted, but I imagine that would be a lot of work. Maybe some day...
- bzzzt 3y agoProviding dummy data would also diminish the value of Android users to Google itself, unless they give themselves an exemption from such a setting which would mean they would be dragged to court by the competition.
- xmprt 3y agoAndroid already does something like this for location services. For example, give precise location vs approximate location. And then for other permissions, there's a popup for whether to give permissions only this time, always, or to not. I guess there could be a 4th option for "mock" permissions. I wonder if an OEM could provide something like this because at the end of the day, the OEM has control over the sensors that are providing the data that's consumed by these apps.
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoJust to drag us out of the techie land of make-believe, this presents such a horrendous user experience for everyone except advanced users that Google or any mainstream OEM is completely sensible to dismiss it on those merits alone. It’s just another layer of crap that moves smartphones one step closer to being as ridiculously complex as Windows PCs.
- jackpeterfletch 3y agoIs there any good data/analysis on how prevalent attacks on these devices are? I’m always on the fence with this stuff. As an engineer I like having access to my device, and the freedom to tinker. But on the flip side. It’s obvious to me that these devices that people’s lives revolve around are absolutely critical targets. Bank accounts, location, 2fa apps/sms, crypto apps, scam calls, literally all the user’s communications are on offer.
- poisonborz 3y agoReasonable, but I can't help thinking that the expectation here is that most users won't do anything about the restriction - the net effect is to discourage developers from sideloading altogether.
- jeroenhd 3y agoMost apps don't need these restrictions. It's a bit annoying if you're installing some kind of third party accessibility service, but I can't remember when I last installed an app that needed notification access. These permissions are rarely needed and often abused by stalkerware to do things like read messages and screen contents. If they keep the override button in the settings, I honestly don't mind the change, as long as Google Play and vendor app stores aren't exempted. If you're going to make things difficult for developers, make them difficult for your own developers as well. I'm sure the DMA will affect this feature for EU models, or Google will be subjected to a chunky fine and forced to change it the moment the first signs of abuse pop up.
- kuschku 3y agoGoogle has restricted more and more functionality to their apps only. System signed, that is. The only way for e.g. KDE connect to continue working properly today is using adb, three hacky permissions, accessibility access and notification access. It's just going to get worse. But if I had a Chromebook, Google would give me the same functionality for free.
- jeroenhd 3y agoYeah, it's rather annoying that I needed to root my phone to fix KDE Connect's clipboard access. That's the only workaround I've needed for years, though. The (relatively recent) changes Google made to the app store API made my life a whole lot easier now that F-Droid can actually update packages without root access. As long as the existing manual overrides (going through the settings and toggling the permission) still exists, I don't see much of a problem.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoThey see apple asking for 99 dollars a year and wonder why they aren't doing that already.
- accurrent 3y agoIve a feeling this comes from some Singapore Govt ruling to "protect" citizens from scam app. https://www.straitstimes.com/tech/android-users-in-s-pore-to-be-blocked-from-sideloading-as-part-of-anti-scam-trial https://www.straitstimes.com/tech/android-users-in-s-pore-to...
- w4rh4wk5 3y agoWhy only side loaded apps though?!
- fareesh 3y agoIt's becoming a common scam in India where people are sent a malicious APK via WhatsApp and the moment they install it, the attacker will reset their passwords via Phone Number + 2FA
- qwertox 3y agoLess and less my phone. I want the small apps which I develop for myself to have all the access without any restrictions. It's getting worse and worse and I wish they'd allow me to whitelist my apps somehow so that they get the same access as system apps do. And if this would mean that I can't use Google Wallet, then at least all the permissions which don't affect apps like Google Wallet. > Malicious Android apps, no matter where they’re sourced from, commonly try to trick users into granting them access to the Accessibility and Notification Listener APIs because of their power. So does Gadgetbridge. I've had devices where Android wouldn't allow me to give it access to the Notification Listener resulting in me not being able to forward the messages to my Mi Band. In the end this was solvable by using ADB, but this is not ok.
- RugnirViking 3y agocut the "sideloading" term. It's downloading. Exactly the same we download any other file. It's not some obscure feature. This kind of terminology is word games to make it sound like somebody doing this is inherent using it wrong or must be up to no good. Its one thing to make it harder to enable stuff. But there absolutely should be ways to say "yes I know what I'm doing".
- realusername 3y agoI'd prefer if we used sideloading for the appstore / playstore. The main location is the website of the developer and the mobile store is a side channel.
- kotaKat 3y agoAnd the walled garden gets hiked up a few more inches, just as Google always planned.
- DeathArrow 3y agoSo it will be less and less possible to use apps downloaded from other places. This is both anti-user and anti-competition.
- Flammy 3y agoFrom the article and comments, I'm assuming this will operate similarly to how Windows makes it slightly harder to run applications that aren't signed by a known trusted source. If so, I don't have a problem with that.
- deely3 3y agoI have, first you have to click "yes" on a modal dialog that blocks screen completely when you start the app, then you have to check checkbox "yes, I agree" and then click ok, then you have to change some hidden settings, then this settings "accidentally" reverts on each update... until they remove it completely. Microsoft, Google, Apple wants more and more control as usual.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]