5 ms·
Companies this size die several years before the body hits the floor. They're dead when everyone starts to hate them and someone says "no, look how much money
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Companies this size die several years before the body hits the floor.
They're dead when everyone starts to hate them and someone says "no, look how much money they're making, they're fine." That's the fatal blow, because they think they're fine, and keep doing the things that make everyone hate them.
At that point you're just waiting for someone else to offer an alternative. Then people prefer the alternative because the incumbent has been screwing them for so long, and even if they change at that point, it's too late because nobody likes or trusts them anymore, and ships that big can't turn on a dime anyway.
You have to address the rot when customers start complaining about it, not after they've already switched to a competitor.
- carlossouza 3y agoThat also sounds a lot like Blockbuster. Google continues generating profits out of inertia and a lack of a better alternative. It went for “don’t be evil” to “a necessary evil” (just until something a little better appears).
- nothercastle 3y agoI think they are just at attain median levels of evil now.
- eproxus 3y agoThe bigger the behemoth, the slower the fall.
- samch 3y agoI know they aren’t the same scale as Google, but what you wrote really describes Atlassian for me.
- rurp 3y agoWhile I totally agree that Atlassian products are terrible and steadily getting even worse, I'm not sure they are going anywhere anytime soon given their disconnect between users and customers. Most people who have to suffer their products have no say in the purchasing decision, and the company does a somewhat better job of appealing to the relative small group that does. Atlassian could very well have Oracle-like staying power.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThat sounds a lot like Kodak. I remember running into Kodak engineers, at an event in the 1990s, and they were all complaining about the same thing. They were digital engineers, and they were complaining that film people kept sabotaging their projects. Kodak invented the digital camera. They should have ruled the roost (at least, until the iPhone came out). Instead, they imploded, almost overnight. The film part was highly profitable. Until it wasn't. By then, it was too late. They had cooked the goose.
- Terr_ 3y agoI'm not a Steve Jobs fan, but one business-quote I do like: "If you don't cannibalize yourself, someone else will." In other words, it could have been better for Kodak as a whole if they allowed their digital-arm to compete more with their film-arm, so that as the market shifted they'd at least be riding the wave rather than under it.
- MattyRad 3y agoI'm also not a Steve Jobs fan, and this reminds me of how Flash died[1]. The Flash Renaissance was the counter-era to the search despair era we currently find ourselves in. In the same vein as Kodak, I wonder what the alternate timeline would look like where Adobe cannibalized native apps. [1] https://youtu.be/65crLKNQR0E?si=mXPgXxlMRxU-xjcu&t=2472 https://youtu.be/65crLKNQR0E?si=mXPgXxlMRxU-xjcu&t=2472
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe mistake Adobe made was in canceling Flash instead of open sourcing it. Publish a spec and the let browsers implement the client side, then you can keep selling tools to make animations without everyone having to deal with the bug-riddled proprietary player Adobe clearly had no interest in properly maintaining to begin with. It's kind of astonishing that all these years later we still don't have something equivalent in browsers. In theory they're Turing-complete and you can do whatever you want, but where's the thing that makes it that easy?
- Certhas 3y agoAny examples of this actually playing out with a company as established as Google? You can read comments like this on many companies... Microsoft (70B$ income), Meta (40B$), Oracle (8.5B$), IBM(7.5B$), SAP (6B$), yet none of them seem to ever actually enter the predicted death spiral. And the internet isn't new anymore. There is no vast landscape of unexplored new technological possibilities, and no garage start up with an engineering mindset that will just offer a better solution.
- makeitdouble 3y agoMicrosoft and Meta reinvented themselves a few times over. At this point Windows is just an legacy business unit for instance, and Meta literally changed name to mark the turn. Oracle, IBM and SAP have the advantage(?) of being heavily business focused from the start, and I don't see them ever die a natural death in our lifetimes. As long as they have the money to outbribe the competition they'll be there, and it will require a small miracle to break that loop.
- AnonymousPlanet 3y agoThe one thing that has kept Microsoft afloat is their business oriented part. They are deeply entrenched in any company that needs to use Office and only ever hires Windows admins who won't even look beyond Windows. That is pretty much every non tech small to medium company. When things were shifting to the cloud they were smart enough to make sure it would be their cloud, locking customers even deeper into their own technology. Anything else they do is a bonus.
- makeitdouble 3y agoTo add to this, Microsoft is really really good at understanding businesses, in a way Google will probably never be I think. Having on premise hosting options for Exchange and all their core services is an example of that, even as they're also pushing for 365 in the cloud. I remember them being earlier than GCP to deal with GDPR and the in EU requirements as well but my memory might be failing.