3 ms·
> Krakauer points out that humans and chimpanzees share nearly 99 percent of our genetic code. “Imagine I gave you Hamlet,” Krakauer says, “and I changed less t
by bee_rider 3y ago
> Krakauer points out that humans and chimpanzees share nearly 99 percent of our genetic code. “Imagine I gave you Hamlet,” Krakauer says, “and I changed less than 1 percent of the text and I said, ‘What’s the play?’ and you said, ‘It’s Hamlet.’ And I said, ‘What have I changed?’ ‘I’m not quite sure…I did see a few typos.’”
I can’t stand this comparison, I mean, sure if you got Hamlet with 1% errors you’d recognize it as mostly Hamlet. But if you got a computer program with 1% of the instructions switched out, I bet you’d get a non-working program.
Also Hamlet is ~30,000 words long. If you randomly distribute errors, sure, it will look like Hamlet. If you give somebody 300 words to change Hamlet, I bet they could come up with something. Put “actually Hamlet was a ghost the whole time” at the end, I don’t know, I’m not M. Night Shyamalan.
- greenhearth 3y agoYou could do much more damage than that. In poetry and Shakespeare especially, each word is used very carefully as a unit of very dense information. You could make Hamlet not related to his own father and fundamentally change any structural meaning behind the play. The resulting work would be named "Hamlet" but not be THE "Hamlet" at all.
- lajy 3y ago> But if you got a computer program with 1% of the instructions switched out, I bet you’d get a non-working program. I believe it was a comment I saw on here once that took it a step further and included the OS and all hardware logic in there as well. I can have two identical desktop computers with only one program installed on each, the only difference being that the program is totally different. Those two devices could ultimate be two seemingly completely unrelated machines to the end user, even though they share far more than 99% of the exact same instructions. The only "code" they wouldn't share is the specific program they run. Everything else from the hardware to the OS is many millions of "lines" that are the same. Something that plays movies nonstop vs a production database. Photoshop vs Halo: The Master Chief Collection. An IDE vs a point of sale system. Control software vs a web browser. A program that locks you into the software vs one that still gives you access to the OS. The differences can start getting seemingly huge very quickly.
- passion__desire 3y agoHashing functions do that. Q: How many bits in the resultant hash will change, if the x bits are changed in its the original input A: 50% on average, regardless of how many bits are changed. All you are doing in your mind is devising scenarios to map different resultant strings to plausible reallife scenarios and spooking yourself. https://crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/71988/how-many-bits-in-the-resultant-hash-will-change-if-the-x-bits-are-changed-in-it https://crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/71988/how-many-bi...
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoThe problem, I think, is that a layperson is unaccustomed to systems like computer programs and DNA where 99% precision is laughably insufficient to specify the behavior. If you baked some cookies and you adjusted the amount of any one ingredient by 1%... I'm not sure the average American cook has the measurement equipment to notice. With a good scale you might be able to tell. Built a shed and adjusted the measurements by 1%? It's still going to stand up just fine. Wrote an email and swapped 1 in 100 words? They might not seven notice a difference. If you took out only the 1% that was the baking soda, or the 1% that is the nails in the rafters, or finished your email with "Screw that!" yeah, that might be hugely different...but that's exactly the kind of precision edits to critical details that computer programs and DNA require to change user-visible behavior in a huge way.
- LeroyRaz 3y agoLay people are totally used to this type of precision. It's like you did a typo in your cookie recipe and instead of 100 grams of sugar instead put 1000 kilos. It's only a few extra zeros after all. A tiny change in the text.
- TheVespasian 3y agoLeifCarrotson was arguing that, but mistakenly typed out about 10 words that would indicate the opposite
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]