2 ms·
One thing that’s true is publishing works on a blockbuster model. Most books sell relatively few copies and a handful sell millions. The statistics about the va
by tptacek 3y ago
One thing that’s true is publishing works on a blockbuster model. Most books sell relatively few copies and a handful sell millions. The statistics about the vast majority of traditionally published books selling fewer than five thousand are likely true
I didn't see the "dozen copies" or "less than 99 copies" thing, but I did read an article on the front page about the overwhelming majority of published books not recouping their advances, and this article seems to concur. Of course, that's what you'd expect; it's how a lot of businesses work.
- giantrobot 3y agoBooks not recouping their advances is definitely a thing. With a traditionally published book an author makes their money off royalties which is a few percentage points of the price of the book. The percentages are different for the various formats of the book, a hard cover has different rates than a paperback or eBook. The advance is paid out of the author's royalties for the book. If an author is making a dollar per sale, they'll need 5,000 sales to cover a $5,000 advance before they actually see any additional money from the book. Audiobooks and foreign translations are their own kettle of fish and don't tend to count towards sales to pay down the advance. Sometimes even eBooks don't count towards "sales" to pay down the advance but that is typically older pre-eBook contracts. If an author publishes multiple books with the same publisher each book will have its own advance and sales tracked. A new edition will often come with its own advance but have its sales tracked separately from previous editions. Sales of Book A have no effect on the royalties for Book B. The upside for an author is an advance is a bet on the part of the publisher. So long as the author doesn't break their contract by missing a deadline or not doing the work, they don't have to pay back the publisher's advance (conditions will be in the contract). An author that has an unsuccessful book won't typically end up owing the publisher their advance even if their sales never actually manage to pay it back. For publishers, unless the author totally screws them over, aren't really positioned to lose money on an advance. The blockbusters make them enough money to farm potential blockbusters with other authors. They have lots of ways to get rid of low demand books including just writing them down as a loss so they'll break even on the advance. They're also not going to pay out huge advances to an author with no history or no apparent demand. Source: I know a bunch of people that have published books.
- eslaught 3y ago> books not recouping their advances This is in fact a feature, not a bug. Traditional publishers consider a book to be a "success" when it has recouped about 70% of its advance. Publishers prefer this situation because advances are a fixed cost and by holding down royalties (which they essentially refuse to negotiate on except with the most successful authors), they earn big money on the few books with low advances that do really, really well. This means that authors have an incentive to negotiate as large an advance as possible; so from an author's perspective, if you have earned out your advance, it means you have failed to capture as much value from your book as you could have (and/or, you are a runaway best-seller, so you will presumably negotiate better the next time). Source: CEO testimony from the trial transcripts in the antitrust case against the merger of Peguin Random House and Simon & Schuster. Available here if you're interested (disclosure: I have no interest in Publisher's Lunch, and the transcripts may also be available publically): https://shop.publishersmarketplace.com/ https://shop.publishersmarketplace.com/ Edit: it is funny to see in the trial that some authors and agents clearly do not understand this, even with having it being explained by the CEOs of publishing companies earlier in the very same trial.
- tptacek 3y ago(The subtext here is that advances for midlist authors are not all that high, and for first time authors [or at least "non-celebrity" authors who don't have built-in audiences] substantially lower still). I agree with you that not recouping tends to work to the benefit of both parties in the relationship.