3 ms·
> "GDPR nightmare for everyone" -> only for companies that intend touse personal data in non-ethical ways You do not understand GDPR. It is a burden even for b
by graemep 3y ago
> "GDPR nightmare for everyone" -> only for companies that intend touse personal data in non-ethical ways
You do not understand GDPR. It is a burden even for businesses or non-profits that keep a minimal amount of data and do not trade it. As with all Eu regulation it is designed around big business. It actually helps the like of FB because they are more able to push people into agreeing to let them use their data.
> "cookie banners for everyone" -> cookie banners only if your website is using cookies in a way that needs a cookie banner.
Yes, but it does little good, and it stops end users from white-listing sites allowed to set cookies because you need to allow the cookies that track your cookie options.
> "USB-C" -> Good for consumer, I believe.
I disagree. It stops new connectors being introduced (because you will still have to provide USB-C). There is little gain: essentially slightly lower sales of charger cables.
Add to that messes like VAT MOSS which was ridiculously heavy and even lead to some small businesses stopping sales to other EU countries to avoid complying with it.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I disagree. It stops new connectors being introduced (because you will still have to provide USB-C). And just like with the predecessor Micro-USB: nothing stops the EU Parliament from adopting new legislation to update to new technologies. Unlike the US Congress, the EU Parliament is still able to regularly pass new laws. > There is little gain: essentially slightly lower sales of charger cables. No charger included means thinner packaging of products like laptops and phones and thus better transport efficiency (you can store more products in one container), less e-waste from chargers and cables that end up in the "never used" bin, and an easier time for consumers: no need to carry half a bag worth of power bricks, a single Anker dual-port power supply is all I need when going on vacation - it powers our laptops, phones, Switch, everything.
- graemep 3y agoIn general USB chargers work with Apple devices. You just need another cable. Cables are small, fragile (so do not last anyway) and have minimal impact on transport or waste production. While legislation can be changed, it takes time and influence to do so. What manufacturer would introduce a new charger unless they are sure the EU would allow it? It essentially means it will only change if a big manufacturer lobbies for it BEFORE launching products, or if a standard gets established in the rest of the world before the products are launched in the EU. Not exactly encouraging innovation.
- sofixa 3y ago> You do not understand GDPR. It is a burden even for businesses or non-profits that keep a minimal amount of data and do not trade it. As with all Eu regulation it is designed around big business. It actually helps the like of FB because they are more able to push people into agreeing to let them use their data. It's not a burden to have to do common sense things. Is it a burden not to leave medical or private or financial data publicly readable stored on a share everyone can access? Yes, it is, but when you have such data you also have a responsibility to protect it. Since private entities were incapable of that, GDPR tells them how they should do that. Reminder that Americans that do not have access to protections such as GDPR, have their private information leaked frequently, and abuse is rampant (any random company you interact with selling whatever they can - be it telecoms, services, up to Grindr selling HIV status). > I disagree. It stops new connectors being introduced (because you will still have to provide USB-C). There is little gain: essentially slightly lower sales of charger cables. There's an explicit mechanism for the connector to be refreshed periodically, so no, it doesn't.
- tzs 3y ago> It's not a burden to have to do common sense things It depends on your scale. Suppose I ran a small website that provided news and articles and forums about some small hobby that I am into. Maybe 100 users worldwide. I include articles about European things related to that hobby, written specifically to better serve the European visitors to my site. The only personal information I store is IP addresses in my Apache logs. Such a site could be run for less than $100/year in hosting costs. If my processing of personal information counts as "occasional" then as far as I can tell GDPR imposes no burden on me, other than having to deal with it when someone requests that I remove their personal information. If my processing does not count as "occasional" then under Article 27 I would need to appoint a representative in the Union that people and regulators could contact when they have GDPR related matters involving me. There are companies that provide "in-Union GDPR representative as a service" but the least expensive I've seen is around €100. If I had to use such a service I'd be at least doubling my costs which would probably push the costs past what I'd be willing to do for a hobby site that is not monetized. Would my processing be "occasional"? The recital for Article 27 doesn't provide any guidance on what "occasional" means. One the one hand one might argue that a low traffic site is almost by definition "occasional" in everything it does. On the other hand one might argue that my site is processing IP addresses on every single request it processes and that something that happens 100% of the time surely can't be "occasional". At some point this issue will arise and the GDPR regulators in some member state will issue a ruling that clarifies it, and if we are lucky no other member state's regulators will issue a ruling that goes the other way. Even if it is eventually decided that processing such as mine is definitely "occasional" the fact that I have to think about it in the first place is somewhat burdensome.