4 ms·
On what legal basis could Australia possibly expect to control what Twitter does in other countries?
by adastra22 3y ago
On what legal basis could Australia possibly expect to control what Twitter does in other countries?
- hkwerf 3y agoI'm not sure whether there is a legal twitter entity in Australia, but it may not need a legal basis to control. In this case, it's sufficient to have a legal basis to censor, no matter the path Twitter users in Australia choose to use in order to access it. If Twitter does not want its whole service to be censored in a country, they may have to comply with legal requirements in that country. Nothing new here. It's the same as with EU DSA, GDPR and so on.
- mytailorisrich 3y ago> eSafety “will continue to use its suite of powers under the Online Safety Act to protect Australians from serious online harms, including extreme violent content” So in this case that's the Australian's Online Safety Act. The legal basis is easy. The issue is obviously enforcement, so realistically this only works for countries powerful enough to put enough pressure on the target company.
- adastra22 3y agoAustralian law and courts has no jurisdiction over what happens in American or European data centers, so long as those bits never deliver to Australia.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoAustralian law and courts have jurisdiction over whatever Australian law says they have. Again, the issue is enforcement.
- adastra22 3y agoThats not how sovereignty works.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoThat's how the law and jurisdiction work. Jurisdiction is defined by law. Sovereignty is what complicates enforcement.
- fragmede 3y agoThe law, as implemented by people, who are not stupid, will note that a VPN is all that's needed to access stuff as if outside the country, rendering county-specific blocks laughably useless, and require that stricter measures be put in place, under whatever threat they can manage.
- defrost 3y agoThe people that want this ban are, for all their performative public facing statments, not altogether stupid. Despite the claim for a ban the desired end goal is what is effectively a bloody great speed bump that slows the transmission of bullshit when fire starts in a theatre. What very rapidly happened in Australia very soom after the stabbing in the church was a flood of BS claims and counter claims that had no truth to them but served to inflame a crowd which surrounded the church demanding retribution and the immediate lynching of either A) the Muslim responsible, or B) the Jewish man responsible ... It's fairly widely understood in Australia and, surprisingly, supported on both sides of the political divide (with one or two specific exceptions) than total bans aren't achievable but legal boundaries can and often will slow the speed of yelling "Fire!!" in a theatre. While there are few real absolute in life it is generally the case that most of the people that can operate a VPN aren't getting sucked into bloody stupid real life pitch fork waving. Although it's certainly the case that some of those that can operate a VPN will be turds that enjoy pouring gasoline on a spark.
- richrichie 3y ago[flagged]