5 ms·
This guy doesn't even have a grasp of the basic facts of the web app business. The core of his argument is that an ad-supported business is ipso facto a fad.
by pg 19y ago
This guy doesn't even have a grasp of the basic facts of the web app business. The core of his argument is that an ad-supported business is ipso facto a fad. So is Google a fad? Are all the ad-supported businesses of the past 100 years?
Look no further than Friendster for evidence of users' fickleness? Friendster wasn't killed by the market; it committed suicide.
- run4yourlives 19y agoI don't think I'm saying that ad-based businesses are a fad at all. What I am saying is that ad-based businesses aren't stable enough to warrant the valuations that we're seeing right now. The core audience - the user - is not loyal enough to justify valuations that would take years of sustained behavior to see any ROI. The cause of Friendster's demise is irrelevant - it's the speed at which it happened that proves the point. 19 million users lost in under 2 years is fast even for web apps. Ads are a perfectly legitimate form of revenue.
- pg 19y ago> I don't think I'm saying that ad-based businesses are a fad at all. "Consumer loyalty is directly linked to the amount the consumer invests out of pocket." "With social networking sites the amount spent is zero - and the loyalty corresponds." "Facebook and mySpace are only as valuable as the next big thing. In other words: they are fads."
- run4yourlives 19y agoPaul, you're completely ignoring my main point by focusing on this idea that I'm suggesting ad-based models don't work. I'm not saying that. What I'm saying is that because consumers that don't invest out of pocket are fickle and that ad-revenue follows consumers, valuations of companies that survive solely on ad revenue should reflect this. Right now they do not, hence they are overvalued. When a company is overvalued, it's not a good time to invest. The fact that there continues to be a market is based on the fact that Facebook, or a site of equal stature hasn't actually had to justify its value. Once it does, the house of cards will adjust a little.
- davidw 19y agoI think fickleness is more closely related to switching costs than sunk costs. In other words, I don't pay a dime for Gmail, but it would be quite difficult to move away from. Facebook probably doesn't have quite that much of a lock on your data, but I guess that depends on who you are and how you use it.
- run4yourlives 19y agoThat's a good point actually, but I think though that you can't discount the user's emotional attachment to sunk costs.
- mojuba 19y agoEveryone would easily switch to a better mail system that offers some kind of a one-click migration/import from GMail, provided it is really better in some ways. In fact, however harsh it may sound, GMail can be ruined in a matter of months just because the majority of its user base is not loyal. Compare it with Apple in terms of loyalty, if in doubt.
- abstractbill 19y ago"consumers that don't invest out of pocket are fickle" If consumers who didn't pay for stuff were not making investments in other ways, I suspect it would be easier to get users to register. Time is an investment, as is trust.
- staunch 19y agoMySpace has justified it's $600M valuation, which you might have claimed was unjustifiably inflated, no? What makes you think Facebook can't justify a few multiples of MySpace given its trajectory?
- run4yourlives 19y agoLet's assume that mySpace is making the $25M/month speculated. At a $600M, it would take 2 years of sustained $25M months to see a return. At 100 million visitors, $25M translates to $4 a month per user in ad funds. $4, per user, per month, sustained for 24 months. Just to break even. Those are insane prices at insane growth trajectories. You can call that justification of a valuation, but I call it unsustainable speculation.
- sabat 19y ago"What I am saying is that ad-based businesses aren't stable enough to warrant the valuations that we're seeing right now." What valuations? You mean profits? I honestly don't know what companies you're talking about. Google? You're predicting the downfall of Google? Get in line -- there's been one for years, right next to the one that predicts Apple will Die Any Day Now[tm].
- AF 19y agoHaven't we already discussed this? Google is not your regular old ad-supported company. They have a unique position being an ad provider. He can correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe Google was who he had in mind when he made that statement.
- AF 19y agoGoogle isn't an ad-supported business, though. They are an ad business, period. Not many companies have the privilege of being an ad provider, which functions much more like a traditional company. And there haven't been Internet companies for the last 100 years. 50 years ago switching newspapers would've been a much different thing than switching websites today.
- sabat 19y ago"Google isn't an ad-supported business, though. They are an ad business, period." Sorry, but you're just playing semantic games there. "Ad-supported business" and "ad business" means the same thing in this context.
- run4yourlives 19y agoThere's a huge difference! Google is a ad monopoly, they own the method of delivery, the ads, the monetary distribution and the placement. That's an advantage that no other company can claim, and basically means that you can't compare them in this context at all.
- sabat 19y agoNope, no fundamental difference. Money is made from advertising. As long as businesses continue to advertise, revenue is generated.
- staunch 19y agoThe confusion is that Google has two businesses that are integrated. They have products that are advertising supported and they have an advertising platform available to others. Google could kill their open AdSense product completely and still make billions dollars selling ads on their products.
- richcollins 19y ago"With social networking sites the amount spent is zero" That statement further supports your claim. The time people spend working on their profile, building friends and relationships ... etc is probably worth much more to them than a $300 iPod.