3 ms·
The problem isn't the manufacturing process, but rather the architecture. At a low level: We take an analog component, then drive it in a way that lets us trea
by ben_w 3y ago
The problem isn't the manufacturing process, but rather the architecture.
At a low level: We take an analog component, then drive it in a way that lets us treat it as digital, then combine loads of them together so we can synthesise a low-resolution approximation of an analog process.
At a higher level: We don't really understand how our brains are architected yet, just that it can make better guesses from fewer examples than our AI.
Also, 400 W of electricity is generally cheaper than 20 W of calories (let alone the 38-100 W rest of body needed to keep the brain alive depending on how much of a couch potato the human is).
- awesomeMilou 3y ago> Also, 400 W of electricity is generally cheaper than 20 W of calories Are you serious? I don't think you have to be an expert to see that the average human can perform more work per energy intake than the average GPU. > The problem isn't the manufacturing process, but rather the architecture. It's very much a problem, good luck trying to even emulate the 3D neural structure of the brain with lithography. And there are few other processes that can create structures at the required scale, with the required precision.
- ben_w 3y ago> Are you serious? I don't think you have to be an expert to see that the average human can perform more work per energy intake than the average GPU. You're objecting to something I didn't say, which is extra weird because I'm just running with the same 400 W/20 W you yourself gave. All I'm doing here is pointing out that 400 W of electricity is cheaper than 20 W of calories especially as 20 W is a misleading number until we get brains in jars. To put numbers to the point, at $0.10/kWh * 400 W * 24h = $0.96, while the UN definition for abject poverty is $2.57 in 2023 dollars. As for my opinion on which can perform more work per unit of energy, that idea is simply too imprecise to answer without more detail — depending on what exactly you mean by "work", a first generation Pi Zero can beat all humans combined while the world's largest supercomputer can't keep up with one human. > It's very much a problem, good luck trying to even emulate the 3D neural structure of the brain with lithography. IIRC by volume a human brain mostly communication between neurones; the ridges are because most of your complexity is a thin layer on the surface, and ridges get you more surface. But that doesn't even matter, because it's a question of the connection graph, and each cell has about 10,000 synapses, and that connectivity be instantiated in many different ways even on a 2D chip. We don't have a complete example connectivity graph for a human brain. Got it for a rat, I think, but not a human, which is why I previously noted that we don't really understand how our brains are architected. > And there are few other processes that can create structures at the required scale, with the required precision. Litho vastly exceeds the required precision. Chemical synapses are 20-30 nm from one cell to the next, and even the more compact electrical synapses are 3.5 nm.
- hum3hum3 3y agoI think the power efficiency is very relaxed as you just need to consider the value of a single performance digital brain that exceeds human level.