5 ms·
> The restoration is part of a "bold bid to steal container traffic" away from the waterway, said the Financial Times. I doubt that. Isn't the Canal already op
by WalterBright 3y ago
> The restoration is part of a "bold bid to steal container traffic" away from the waterway, said the Financial Times.
I doubt that. Isn't the Canal already operating at maximum capacity? The railroad would simply enable more traffic. It's not zero sum.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoLong term maybe, but it'll take years for the rest of the logistics network to fully accommodate the new capacity and do things like building more ships or reallocating routes. In the meantime the new ports would probably undercut Panama fees to attract traffic that would otherwise go via the canal.
- bluGill 3y agoNot really as the canal is overfull so anyone in shipping has incentive to see if they can make this work for some shipments now.
- Arrath 3y agoYeah we recently had a load pay something like $1.5m to jump up the queue to transit the canal. Not even a "guaranteed transit by X" but just jumping up the line! Which at the time was something like a month and a half long, IIRC. Being a specialized load (read, unusual cargo, not containerized, on a barge) I doubt transloading to rail and back onto a ship on the other side would have been practical in our case but for other cargoes? It might be an attractive alternative.
- kortilla 3y agoWhy not go around if the queue is a month and a half long?
- crowcroft 3y agoI'm not an expert, but my understanding in large freight is that Cost >>> Time. Going around probably costs a lot more in fuel etc would be my guess.
- lokar 3y agoAnd some freight (LNG) is consumed by waiting or going around (the ship burns it to generate power to cool the LNG)!
- LargoLasskhyfv 3y agoIt would have to burn that anyways.
- bobthepanda 3y agoCape Horn is quite hazardous, so it's not a journey to prefer anyways.
- Gibbon1 3y agoFriend went through the canal and had to sit for a few days with a bunch of other ships. That's something operators hate. Because any time spent waiting is lost opportunity. I'm assuming being able to punt and offload and swap cargo would be a welcome alternative for operators. Maybe you spend a day to offload and load new cargo but that would beat waiting two days for a slot to open up at the panama canal.
- billfruit 3y agoAlso there is already a railway along the canal, the Panama Canal Railway which connects coast to coast.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThat's a much shorter train trip than this Mexico one. So why isn't this rail line already taking the traffic Mexico hopes for?
- kibwen 3y agoThe Panama canal rail line does carry cargo, but its capacity is much less than the canal; every dollar that Panama spends improving the rail line is a dollar not spent improving the canal.
- SilasX 3y agoYeah I remember having this realization after I ran the numbers. A canal with a massive ship beats rail easily on throughput. So much for my idea to have ships plug into a maglev railway and fire their containers to the other side. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38992104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38992104
- geonineties 3y agoI don't think your math works out. Let's assume you want to move 3000 containers along a 3000 mile path. Let's also assume 1: you can stack containers one high onto the railway at the rate one container per minute, 2: the containers will move at 300 miles per hour and 3: the ship moves at 20. On thenship all 3000 containers arrive at once and the total time to move them is 3000miles / 20 = 150 hours. On the rail the containers take 50hr to offload. Hence the first container will arrive at the other side in 3000/300 = 10 hours. The _last_ container will arrive at 60 hrs 0 minutes. At one minute per container in the 150hrs it took the ship to arrive you could have delivered 140*60 = 8400 containers to the other side. Not that the ship is only 15 times slower than the railway. The governing factors on your railway are the ratios for distance to travel vs the offload time. Or put another way the delay bandwidth product.
- berkut 3y agoI think the throughput is currently quite limited because of low levels of water in the natural lakes close to Panama which are used for both Panama's drinking water and for the locks in the canal, so they're restricting the number of ships per day...