3 ms·
Do other countries that spend much less on education not have to deal with inefficient and outdated school buildings? And how much does ESL even cost? If it co
by rayiner 3y ago
Do other countries that spend much less on education not have to deal with inefficient and outdated school buildings?
And how much does ESL even cost? If it comes remotely near explaining why NYC needs three times as much money as Japan to do a worse job, that seems like a huge downside to immigration that nobody is talking about.
- ethbr1 3y agoI'd be curious on the apples:apples comparison between NYC and Tokyo education costs. On the one hand, Tokyo is much older than NYC. On the other hand, the Japanese have a penchant for tearing down and rebuilding things (partially policy-driven).
- bobthepanda 3y agoMost of Tokyo was firebombed in WWII.
- ethbr1 3y agoAbout 30%, including the urban core. [0] But thankfully the war ended before it was completely destroyed, as it would have continued being hit otherwise. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo#Postwar_recovery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo#Postwar_rec...
- bobthepanda 3y agoESL is essentially a second staff on top of the normal staff. It’s not the only kind of support staff though; US schools mainline special needs children in regular schools because it leads to better educational outcomes and societal integration in the long run, whereas Japan usually separates most of these children into separate schools. A lot of countries have significantly newer schools, because a lot of the physical building were destroyed like everything else during the wars, or most people moved into newly developed suburbs and new towns. NYC notably doesn’t includes its suburbs so its share of old buildings is a problem that suburban districts do not have.
- rayiner 3y ago> US schools mainline special needs children in regular schools because it leads to better educational outcomes and societal integration in the long run, whereas Japan usually separates most of these children into separate schools If it delivers much worse results at much higher costs for everyone else, that seems like a terrible trade off.
- bobthepanda 3y agothis depends on if you think that the school system is more expensive than basically running an institutionalized welfare state for special needs people. The US dismantled these systems and then proceeded to enshrine these rights in the ADA. Given that the US can barely handle the meager social security of those with work disability, it's hard to imagine that we could afford widespread, more expensive specialized institutions. And Japan is not exactly doing hot with spending given that they run a 263% debt to GDP ratio.
- rayiner 3y agoDoes japan run an institutionalized welfare system for special needs people? I don’t believe that’s the case. Japan has a different set of problems, but delivering efficient and cost effective, high quality education is something they get right. And insofar as special needs people are evenly distributed among various countries populations, we should be able to learn from what they do.