3 ms·
I oppose municipal internet because then the municipality has to hire a staff of network administrators and a staff of people to actually install the service to
by SoftTalker 3y ago
I oppose municipal internet because then the municipality has to hire a staff of network administrators and a staff of people to actually install the service to households and customer service people to manage subscriptions and front-line tech support questions (or pay contractors to do all that). Lots of graft and favoritism will go in on that. Friends will get hired although they are not competent to do those jobs. County government salaries typically aren't market leading so even when those jobs aren't given to friends, they aren't going to get the best people. I have to pay for all of that, so my taxes go up, even if I don't use their service or if I don't have internet service at all.
- rdudek 3y agoIn my town we have standard Xfinity for cable and now quantum fiber and Ting Internet laying down fiber. It increased our choice from single ISP to multiple ones.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoAs opposed to the private industry, famously meritocratic and never hiring friends, family, and insiders?
- linsomniac 3y agoAre you sure your taxes are used to fund the municipal Internet? In my locality they issued a bond to fund the initial trenching, and use the subscription fees to pay back that bond and fund the long term operation. No taxes are paying for it, people who are not using the municipal Internet don't pay anything for it. Do you still oppose municipal Internet in that case? Maybe your locality is different, but before we got municipal Internet we had basically 3 choices: Xfinity at $180/mo for ~gig down/120M (something in that ballpark) up, CenturyLink with 40Mbps or less DSL (antiquated infrastructure, they actively blocked CLECs from doing anything that could improve it), or terrestrial wireless (fairly sketchy in our environment). Once we got municipal broadband, we finally got fiber to the house, gigabit symmetric, great customer support, and latency that was 10x lower, AND Xfinity dropped their prices.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoI have to pay for all of that, You realize it isn't free and people still subscribe right? Also do you realize this has already been done and worked incredibly well in lots of places with much faster speeds and cheaper prices? This isn't some wild experiment.
- bandrami 3y agoFrom an econ theory standpoint it's in a weird place: broadband is both rivalrous and excludable, so it's not a "public good" in the traditional sense, but it also relies on geographically-fixed infrastructure, so a private market for it cannot be efficient. In the US, goods like this are usually provisioned through a metered semipublic utility. The problem is that to work, those need a monopoly.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoThe problem is that to work, those need a monopoly. This isn't true and we can see it by the fact that lots of places have multiple wires run to them from ATT and multiple cable companies. Most of the time with cable a neighborhood is wired up but a cable isn't ran to a house until it is needed. ISPs make so much profit they don't need everyone to sign up. A lot of times there is nothing to dig and it is run off a pole. They aren't giving a metered commodity like electricity, gas or water with their lines. Once a line is run to someone's house it's wildly profitable since the bandwidth per person is so cheap.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoYou should actually look at the books of these ISP's. Loaded with debt and other liabilities and grocery store profits/net margins. Gross margins may be 60% or more but they aren't ending up with the shareholders or C-Levels
- CyberDildonics 3y agoYou should actually look at the books of these ISP's. Then link something and show me specifically what you are talking about. Loaded with debt and other liabilities and grocery store profits/net margins. I'm not sure exactly what this is supposed to mean, but debt is how things are financed and comcast made a 3 billion dollar profit from 31 billion in revenue. https://www.google.com/search?q=comcast+profit https://www.google.com/search?q=comcast+profit
- patmorgan23 3y agoCool, then vote against it in your local elections. We have this thing called local control where local governments are empowered to create and tailor the services that their residents need most.
- cyberax 3y ago> Lots of graft and favoritism will go in on that. That's so much better than just not having support that works! My friend had his Comcast line damaged. It required him 2 _months_ to get that fixed, and he was not able to work from home during that time. Of course, you can always switch ISPs, right? Oh, yep. No, most of the US has only one _wired_ ISP.