5 ms·
Credit to this organization from pivoting (AFAIK) from their original plan to scrape the plastic out of the water on the open ocean ("System 001"). Intercepting
by xnx 3y ago
Credit to this organization from pivoting (AFAIK) from their original plan to scrape the plastic out of the water on the open ocean ("System 001"). Intercepting plastic at river mouths seems much more practical and cost effective.
- buovjaga 3y agoThey're still working on open oceans: https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/ https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoThis river cleanup is brilliant and effective. Messing with the top meter of ocean water does its own kind of damage. So much of the life in the ocean surface layer is going to be involved with the floating trash, like it or not. Ocean surface sterilization seems incautious and worrisome. Never mind we don't like to see trash. Stripping the ocean surface water will have unforeseen consequences.
- laborcontract 3y agoAre you talking about sea life? According to the video on the site, the boats travel at less than 3km/h and they have live video feeds monitoring the nets. Am I missing anything here?
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoAs most people do, you are considering only fish and such. Things we can see. Not the bulk of all ocean life, the tiny microscopic creatures that dominate the ecosystem. It's only the top surface, right? The ocean can be miles deep! But the density of life in the ocean decreases geometrically with depth. By mass, the top inches contain more life than the entire balance of it. Because, sunlight.
- NamTaf 3y agoExcept the net completely transparent to microscopic organisms like plankton? The section "The System at Sea" on this site [1] goes into detail about the multitude of systems they have to prevent the impact on ocean life. There's some 9 image slides give information about it. With all those considered, am I missing something? [1]: https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/ https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/
- nickburns 3y agono parties of this exchange are missing anything here except for not one having been privy to the original and actual design of the system—which specific factors identified (i.e. surface microbiome, etc.), as everyone's comments demonstrate, are clearly worth having been taken, and continue to be worth taking into consideration with previous and future improvements and/or redesigns of such. no need for any of this standoffishness.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoThe life has, like it or not, integrated with the trash. Adhered to it; put spores on it; coated it. Remove the trash - remove some fraction of the life. Not trying to be standoffish. Just being aware that the law of unintended consequences will bite you in the ass every time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dingnuts 3y agoI'm sure you, random Redditor, er, Orange Site Commenter, are an expert on both the topic and the design of the mechanism in question If only Boyan Slat had thought to ask you first
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoOh, this project is widely criticized over its entire existence. Don't rely on some commenter on HN for sure. Do your own research. It won't take long.
- cdrini 3y agoThey have a lot of precautions in place to avoid damaging any wild life. They move slowly, and their nets have special channels to allow animals to pass through and avoid getting caught. See the "managing environmental impact" section here: https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/ https://theoceancleanup.com/oceans/ I imagine there must be _some_ non zero risk, but I imagine the benefits of removing the plastic outweigh the risk. Ie removing the plastic is better for the wildlife overall, despite the small potential risk.
- foota 3y agoIt seems to me like removing a non negligible amount of biomass from the ocean would be infeasible, so it's difficult for me to see the impact this could possibly have.
- codingdave 3y agoHow did you jump from cleanup to sterilization? You do have a point that the impact on the ecosystem is a concern worth exploring, but your statement goes off the rails from there and assumes that they are sterilizing the ocean surface? You've got to expect pushback on such a leap unless you justify it.
- renewiltord 3y agoI'm calling for a moratorium on the river barricades until we can determine that it's not damaging to the environment. They were so occupied with whether they could they didn't stop to ask if they should. This is why they need to teach ethics in school next to engineering. Messing with fragile systems like this is dangerous. Many studies show that blocking river flow causes the extinction of species. Until we can be sure that this is safe, we shouldn't do it. We should first study it over a reasonable period of time (say 20 years) before doing anything like this. Humans think they can just modify the environment without consequences. That is the root of the issue. We need real change.
- rmah 3y agoHow do you know they didn't stop to ask if they should? And concluded after, detailed and deep study, that yes, they should. Perhaps they (or someone else) already did studies of the impact of blocking rivers partially or totally? Are you, perhaps, making assumptions about what they did without first stopping to think if you should make such assumptions?
- cdrini 3y ago1) this organisation was founded in 2013; they've been thinking and researching into this for a while, this wasn't a rash intervention. 2) they didn't block the river flow! 100% that would be very dangerous. The have a capture device on the surface of the water. Wildlife and water travel freely under the surface. 3) the mission statement of this organisation is about helping wildlife, so I reckon they think a lot about the impacts that anything they do can have on wildlife.
- ljlolel 3y agoMy understanding from last year is that they’re doing both prevention and cleanup. They have a good explanation on their website on microplastic sizes
- dylan604 3y agoRight. Slowing/stopping the flow into the ocean doesn't magically clean the oceans. It would always need to be a multi-step approach.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- gnyman 3y agoYes! This is one of the reasons I like them so much and support them. They have been focused on the end goal, even if it meant having to kill the original idea that drove the initial fame and success. The automated, solar powered platform [1] I try to remember them when I'm getting too emotionally attached to an idea. They remain pragmatic, focused on reducing the plastic in the optimal way. Even when that means doing it manually, by driving around in "dirty" ships, instead of the nice clean automated solar powered platforms they initially pitched. Same with expanding to the rivers. Where their initial (and still working) platform is a automated and solar powered one, but recently they are just putting up fences/barriers and then manually scoping up the trash with (again, "dirty") excavators. I wish them all the luck. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROW9F-c0kIQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROW9F-c0kIQ
- usrusr 3y agoThanks for pointing that out, it never occurred to me that it might be the same organisation! The open ocean approach had always been far out in terms of good intentions but unrealistic expectations in my eyes, but with this pivot it's actually awesome: the fancy idea as an accidental Trojan horse to get the reasonable but not quite as exciting idea off the ground. In hindsight this could have been the one best possible path, I doubt that they would be where they are if they had started out with the effective but boring (compared to their exiting off-shore fantasies!). And neither would they be where they are if they deliberately started with the Trojan horse, knowing of its nature. The best salespersons are always those who honestly fail to understand why the buyer might prefer something different than what they are selling.