8 ms·
Microsoft is a national security threat: ex-White House cyber policy director
- cranberryturkey 3y agoall tax payer funded software should be open source
- drooopy 3y agoDunno if all government software should be open source but government should definitely avoid vendor lock ins.
- morkalork 3y agoThere's a couple places in the book Skunk Works where the author laments the government's procurement strategy for planes that always ensured different manufacturers got at least some contracts so they wouldn't go out of business and leave the government reliant on just one supplier. He derided it as a form of socialism! Alas, it was a reasonable approach.
- _mlbt 3y agoI see this sentiment all the time, but it could never apply to the defense sector. Do you really want our nations enemies to have access to the source code of fighter jets, cruise missiles, the nuclear weapons program, or missile defense systems?
- convolvatron 3y agook. most. and an aside note do you really want the national defense to be one thumb drive away from total collapse?
- a_simple_man 3y agohow are those systems going to be secure without being audited by the market? the reality is that this military industrial complex is just a way to print money and funnel it into the hands of a few criminals. all of the major news publications openly told you that the USA has been attacked over 100 times in the middle east AND WE LEFT. The public is going to find out very soon that this massive, expensive military can't actually defend against or defeat other militaries. That when you spend $1000 on a hammer everything looks really flashy and impressive AT FIRST with your fancy jets and missile systems, but after enough time, and after enough of the money has been funneled out, you realize it's a paper army. the USA is so weak that Iran is pushing them out of the middle east and there's nothing the theives that run the military can do about it. but don't worry. they already manufactured a Palestine sympathy story ahead of time to explain why they have to pull out and run away like the cowards they are. and your son's and neighbors sons will pay the price with their lives
- SteveNuts 3y agoEvery time I’ve been involved with selling software in any way adjacent to national security they’ve required source code review.
- a_simple_man 3y agoHow are you equating a "code review" to open source, the difference is the difference between asking a couple dudes for advice and asking the entire world for advice. I'm sure the argument sounded really good in your head, but let's be adults here when it comes to the United States military
- Veserv 3y agoBecause auditable does not mean the same thing as audited. It is silly that people keep pushing that dead argument after Heartbleed pounded a stake through its heart. Audits are time consuming, challenging, and boring. Experience shows even critical, high profile projects hardly get any review at all by the "world", let alone actual audits by competent domain experts. Quality verification depends on auditing and auditing depends on competent, trusted review and testing. Global transparency is not a substitute for auditing except when discussing absolute rock-bottom standards. Reviewable is significantly better than unreviewed and unreviewable, but that is the lowest possible bar. Unfortunately, software does, as a general rule, have rock-bottom auditing standards, so FOSS does provide meaningful assurance increases in many use cases. But, that is a artifact of the abysmal quality standards rather than any sort of inherent auditing advantage that FOSS provides. That is not to say that global transparency is not valuable for other reasons, but it provides no meaningful quality verification or auditing advantage in serious applications versus local transparency (to the trusted reviewer). If you want to see how this works in practice, look at literally every other industry.
- a_simple_man 3y agothe market will determine what should and should not be audited, according to supply and demand. thinking that a couple employees that were not paid for with profit but with printed and taxed government dollars is not and never will be a substitute for the free market, which is a synonym for humanity. not respecting that fact will always result in loss and inefficiency. and no amount of paragraphs can undo that.
- mrwyz 3y ago"never apply". https://dodcio.defense.gov/Open-Source-Software-FAQ/ https://dodcio.defense.gov/Open-Source-Software-FAQ/
- _mlbt 3y ago“All”
- b112 3y agoOpen Source != GPL. Nor on Github. I don't know what the parent fully meant, but I do know that some agencies have full access to some Microsoft source code. From where I sit, I find it absurd that everything we use isn't open source. Again, not free, but the code given to purchasers. You don't need closed source to protect IP, and the proof is in all of these API lawsuits, and copyright law. I don't want my missiles to not have code I cannot edit, and stepping back from the top secret sphere, tangential I am appalled at how crappy car firmwares are closed source. In the old days, a country's national transport agencies could look at evey linkage, every rod, every part of a car design. Now 90% of the design is hidden. And with electric cars, it's even more firmware. And the idea that OTA updates are a thing for cars. The madness. The absolute madness. How much do you want to bet that charging firmwares are remotely updatable? Now imagine that 9am on Monday, every electric car explodes? Even today, that would mean an immense number of houses on fire. How could the fire department handle it? And how could it be handled as the fires spread? And what if lots of other infra goes up? And that's today. What about when 90% of transportationn is electric? Even if not a single house or building burned, or person was hurt, how would you replace all those buses, trucks, delivery vehicles, and cars? As COVID showed us, you cannot ramp up and down overnight. And what if it happened to all our allies? Would they still sell part to us? What of all the tractors are electric, and we miss corn and wheat planting season? My point in this tangent is... no one is even looking at the important bits. And to reiterate, how much do you want to bet charging firmwares are remotely updated? Really, they should be air gapped from the entire rest of the car. Letting potential hackers have access in this way, is just plain lazy and reckless.
- bongodongobob 3y agoThat's all fine and good but I don't want missiles with code you can edit. I didn't vote for you, nor do I trust you.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoNobody said random users should be able to edit. FOSS means the code is available, not that they're going to take patches. (See sqlite for an extreme case - code is public domain, but they more or less don't take contributions)
- nurple 3y agoThis is actually not a bad idea for an international peace treaty. If you make weapons, they must be open source. If the real power in these tools is the secrecy behind their design and implementation, seems like a great way to suck the power out of them.
- dh2022 3y agoThis strategy would fall apart when you encounter an adversary willing to sacrifice its own people. Nations that care about their own people need to keep a technological advantage on the battlefield.
- cess11 3y agoStates don't care.
- dh2022 3y agoBelieve it or not, USA government cares at least a little. USA did not institute the draft even when fighting on two fronts (Afghanistan and Iraq). USA made up for the lack in manpower with technology: Reaper drones, cluster munitions, night vision, precise artillery, overwhelming air power.
- nurple 3y agoDon't you find it a bit frightening that this tech is daily giving a smaller and smaller subset of people in the world the unilateral ability to project their will onto the world? At least if they tried to draft in an unjust war, the people could withhold their physical support. This was pretty effective during the Vietnam area, but it's a bargaining chip we've lost. As we saw with 702, we really have very little leverage left in what our gov does anymore, the threat of being voted out even carries little power, exactly because they're systematically removing humans from every loop they can for the purpose of working unilaterally even when--perhaps especially when--it's against the will of the people. The spooks themselves have literally said exactly as much in their fight against privacy. To me, the latest 702 is more terrifying than any adversary. When we, who the government should be beholden to, cannot even know the text of the laws which apply to us, it really puts a fine point on how the those who run our government view themselves in relation to its citizenry. "The liberties of people never were, nor ever will be, secure, when the transactions of their rulers may be concealed from them." -Patrick Henry
- _akhe 3y agoOpen-source doesn't mean "not secure" - the nuclear codes would be in the .env obv >.> Seriously though - the software itself would be separated from secrets architecturally. And because it's open and anyone in the world can contribute it could be superior code than what some private government tech contractor could come up with. For the equipment use case like jets and missiles, a separate directive component (driver) would likely be necessary anyway, not just for security/privacy but because different nations have different equipment. We use F-16s, M-16s, Autel drones, etc. This driver/directive component would be the manufacturer's IP - like an nvidia GPU driver. Think of it like we'd all be running/contributing the same OS but because we have different hardware and security needs there are still some private components. The idea/goal here is that our defense companies would overall benefit from it. Not just because the software is improved, but you can justify funding, build curricula around it - might benefit the defense industry to modernize their tech practices.
- abstractbeliefs 3y agoThe problem is that not all the secrets are so easily extracted - sometimes the design/software is the secret. If you put all the design up for nuclear weapons but just kept the nuclear codes secret it's great that no one can fire ours, but people could implement the design on their own with different codes. To use a more realistic example, consider air defence missile systems use to shoot down incoming missiles and drones. The secrets here aren't keys, it's software-driven behaviours including the approach to identify radar tracks as hostile or noise, identify when to commit a missile and how to target it, the code implicitly contains the vulnerabilities where the radar tracking is less effective and more evadable and how the system tries to mitigate this, etc. When you take away all the secret behaviours, you quickly end up with not much more than just the drivers connecting the hardware to the logic, which isn't a lot of code that's driving the funding. How you set a missile tubes tilt and direction is trivial stuff and is mostly reused from old platforms that were funded decades ago. Additionally, there is some talk about how this is kind of like security through obscurity. When it comes to things like weapons and other high-tech capabilities, security isn't only security against being owned, it's security against your opponent closing the technological gap. Unfair wars, where you have a significant tech lead on your opponent, means your population bleeds less.
- prepend 3y agoCertainly. It’s not like giving them the source code would increase risk significantly, if the software is designed well. I think it would actually strengthen as more researchers would study and submit contribs. I think Linux is as or more secure than windows and it’s open source. There’s tons of sensitive systems that are open source. It’s a design fallacy that security through obscurity is good.
- gray_-_wolf 3y ago> It’s not like giving them the source code would increase risk significantly I like free software a lot, and do not know much about weapon development, but would not the software reveal a lot about capabilities of the weapon platform? The argument to keep the software private might not be motivated just by attempt to hide security holes, but also by desire to hide what the weapon can do, what are the operational limits, etc.
- tester756 3y ago>It’s a design fallacy that security through obscurity is good. Yet, still obscurity increases security. Reverse engineering is not trivial and raises the bar.
- prepend 3y ago> Yet, still obscurity increases security. I disagree and think obscurity decreases security. It just gives the false belief of security.
- tester756 3y agoReverse engineering is not trivial and raises the bar.
- fsflover 3y agoAny relevant links? I can share this: https://blog.invisiblethings.org/2008/09/02/three-approaches-to-computer-security.html https://blog.invisiblethings.org/2008/09/02/three-approaches...
- cess11 3y agoWhy not?
- xyst 3y agoClosed source is a recipe for disaster. Many attacks on important infrastructure have been because of closed source/proprietary software. - Stuxnet (developed to attack PLCs which control nuclear centrifuges) - Petya (targeted Microsoft developed systems and software and brought governments and states to their knees. Notably Ukraine)
- SoftTalker 3y ago> Do you really want our nations enemies to have access to the source code of fighter jets, cruise missiles, the nuclear weapons program, or missile defense systems They likely already do. Between exploiting remote vulnerabilites (a nation-state intrusion will never even be noticed -- they aren't going to encrypt all the files and ask for ransom) and old-fashioned spycraft, it would be really amazing if all the contractors involved on those projects had perfect security.
- derf_ 3y agoFrom my time working in defense contracting, quite a lot of the software was open source, built on open source components (just like everything else) or even hosted on official military GitHub repos. Code written by the (federal) government itself cannot even be copyrighted (in the US). Obviously you are not going to find the classified stuff on GitHub, but even there it was very common for the government to take all of the source code from one contractor and hand it to another one to work on. You also design your systems so that as much as possible can be unclassified, because unclassified development is much, much easier.
- advael 3y agoUnironically yes. Auditable software is inherently more secure, especially over the kind of timescale relevant to governments
- newsclues 3y agoOpen source doesn’t mean freely available online for everyone
- fsflover 3y agohttps://publiccode.eu https://publiccode.eu
- kypro 3y agoI don't know how it works in the US, but this is very much the default when building public software in the UK, https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/service-standard/point-12-make-new-source-code-open https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/service-standard/point-12-... > Public services are built with public money. So unless there’s a good reason not to do so, the code they’re based should be made available for people to reuse and build on. > Open source code can be reused by developers working in government, avoiding duplication of work and reducing costs for government as a whole. And publishing source code under an open licence means that you’re less likely to get locked in to working with a single supplier. Obviously there are exceptions made, but you have to explain why the exception is necessary. An auth library would be an example of where you might not want the code pubic.
- listless 3y agoSo are liquids over 3.4 ounces
- croes 3y agoLiquids are less dangerous
- hulitu 3y ago> Microsoft is a national security threat: ex-White House cyber policy director They needed some decades to find out. /s
- RGamma 3y agoA couple more decades 'til they notice that software runs on hardware.
- outside1234 3y agoI mean there are lots of logging options that are not Microsoft. This sounds like more of a agency fail if anything
- wumeow 3y agoMicrosoft’s security failures are a threat to national security. Microsoft itself is not.
- littlestymaar 3y agoDepends on your nation maybe, but if you are anything but American, it is definitely a threat to your national security.
- Avamander 3y agoAnything used will become a target. How the hell is MS a bigger threat than the rest? If anything a lot of the industry is a way bigger threat and spends less on security.
- wumeow 3y agoI don’t understand your comment. Microsofts failures are a threat precisely because it is so used, especially by the US govt. And they may spend a lot on security, but their recent failures have been pretty amateurish. A recent breach they had was due to an old, non-2fa service account with a weak password and privileged access. See also the CISA report about last years breach.
- Avamander 3y agoAnd if it were ten open-source projects then they'd have to defend themselves against nation-state attackers. They're not ready for it. The researchers that demonstrated an attack on Linux got vilified instead of the maintainers that had misplaced their trust. *Researchers* not a truly sophisticated and a well-funded threat actor. Do you see the issue? Do you really think the alternatives are more diligent with their defense, 2FA, have spent as much time and effort on security? I truly don't like Microsoft but this seems like shitting on them but I really don't see the point. Anything they use is going to be a "national security threat." I'd gladly see other vendors stepping up, but it's enormously difficult and we're not really there yet.
- outside1234 3y agoWait til someone tells them that Google can basically unplug the internet
- janice1999 3y agoEven more reason to tackle monopolies and break up 'too big to fail' companies.
- Avamander 3y agoLarger ships carry more people and can thus sink with more, let's cut the ships in half? Point being, there's a lot of infrastructure that kinda doesn't make sense split up. If you want resiliency, build a second system in parallel not make management of an existing one times more expensive.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoThere's really no reason for all sensitive data and email to be stored on the servers of one company which has tens of thousands of employees who might be insider threats not to just one customer, but all of them.
- wepple 3y agoDouble-edged sword, because few organizations also have the resources to do security at the scale and depth as a MS/goog/Amz
- salawat 3y agoYes? There is a little bit of wisdom out there: Don't put all your eggs in one basket. Heterogenous architecture (where you intentionallly mix and match differing parts for increased fault tolerance) has been a thing for decades.
- Avamander 3y agoYou do realise you'll have half a ship, not two ships then? Defence in depth is expensive, infrastructure at scale is expensive, it would be difficult and more expensive to have a bunch of small operators reach the same level considering the initial cost and overhead. I'm sure though that such equally viable alternatives could be built, but not by splitting existing ones.
- oldpersonintx 3y agoA reasonable fix is easy: stop using Windows
- DonHopkins 3y agoYou're suffering from Gates Derangement Syndrome.
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- tantalor 3y ago[flagged]
- vlovich123 3y agoI'm not a fan of Microsoft, but this is some amazing blame shifting. The root cause of the problem is the government single-sourcing a vendor and being incapable of negotiating with said vendor. The US government is 10% of Microsoft's annual revenue just on security services (if I read the article correctly) but is failing to negotiate. The right answer here is if the situation is that bad, make a very public long-term commitment to shift to something else & up-level your IT department to be able to execute multi-year projects competently. Instead of meeting Microsoft on the business playing field, it's trying to use scary "national security threat" verbiage to try to bully them in the court of public opinion. Regarding security, at the end of the day, the US government is a huge target for adversaries. You can't outsource your security practices & if MS software is really that much worse they should be fixing their purchasing requirements. The reality though is that whatever software the US government would switch to would become the focus of adversarial research.
- theturtletalks 3y agoThe Pentagon can’t even pass an audit for the past 6 years, but yeah Microsoft is the national security threat.
- skhunted 3y agoWhat does one have to do with the other? It’s possible to have more than one threat.
- washadjeffmad 3y agoThe era of global botnets, worms, and ransomware can be credited to Microsoft, as well. Lax concern and slow turnaround for CVEs, poor update performance that led to much of the world turning off automatic updates, and updates being blocked on non-activated installs, if they weren't just easily broken gave root (literally) to fleets of vulnerable internet connected Windows systems being leveraged against the world at large for roughly a decade until Windows 10 brought (and forced) endpoint security practices into the 21th century. It's reassuring that their official stance hasn't changed; "This is how big we are, and it'd be a real tragedy if we couldn't afford to stop something like what we caused before from happening again...", instead of being sued into responsibility by the world at large. (Uh oh, not 5 minutes in and it looks like Microsoft PR is already here to downvote the trouble away.)
- xyst 3y agoNot sure why this is downvoted. “NotPetya” and StuxNet were sophisticated worms/viruses which leveraged flaws in Microsoft products to ultimately bring down infra (ie, Iran nuclear program) or bring down countries (ie, Ukraine suffered attacks to energy sector)
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoPart of the reason it is downvoted is the snide insult at the end about downvotes. It took conscious decision and effort to edit a snide insult into the post where there was none before. As one of the people being derogatorily called "Microsoft PR", this is unnecessarily antagonistic of GP towards me on HN, especially when I did nothing to GP. Commenting on your downvotes is off-topic, against the rules, and when done as a snide insult like above: rude. GP might experience better results if they edited their post to remove the snide, insulting comments about downvoters.
- washadjeffmad 3y agoReddit refugees. The downvote has become the new "disagree/disapprove" button, post-exodus.
- xil3 3y agoMaybe it's time to move to open source solutions (*nix), with custom security/audit measures. Might be very expensive initially, but then they'd have complete control.
- nickff 3y agoYou’re implicitly assuming they’d be better off with more control; I’m not sure that’s true.
- imglorp 3y agoMore control yes but also: more transparency, more vendor choices across the lifecyle. Also more control over telemetry: the current MS stack uploads far more than necessary to only keep things running; government users should not be surveilled, their data should not be sold, etc.
- breatheoften 3y agoIt would definitely be possible for government to be good at things ... in the olden days of tech development, very good people were employed and empowered at government positions with technology roles. I'm thinking back to later 90s when I filled out my financial student aid application. That was an _extremly_ complicated web product for the time, built entirely by the government, and it completely worked and was easy to use. Commercial products like turbotax on the web didn't get parity of complexity and robustness for a good decade more than that. The 'outsource everything' 'not allowed to compete with private industry' mentalities are what has the made the government unable to function in a quality manner ... Its virtually impossible for the government to just hire some people to a team to build some shit -- instead they are _required_ to create bids for contractors to bid on and then incredibly formal contract management processes that are just incredibly disfunctional by design ... It doesn't have to be this way -- its a political result going back to the 'small government' movement which was ultimately about proving that government has to be bad at everything by imposing rules to ensure that result in as many places as possible ...
- 3y ago
- mikewarot 3y agoI call bullshit. Someone, somewhere long ago deep inside of the bowels of the NSA decided to deprioritize actual security, and the use of the capability security model. They knowingly did this, because actually secure computing (which they already had at the time[1,2,3]) represented a threat to the NSA, or so they thought at the time. The trade-offs seemed acceptable, because there were systemic approaches at the time that could keep things secure via other means, such as air-gapping, TEMPEST screening, etc. Much like the consumer decision on the other side of that secrecy barrier, when it was decided the MULTICS was too complex, and you really didn't need all of that complexity (to allow mutli-level security), the easing of hardware requirements, and systems design time all seemed worth it. Here we are 50 years later, and both decisions have proven to be disastrous. We've swiss-cheesed our infrastructure in a manner that can only be hinted at metaphorically. The closest analogies I know are: Imagine the power grid and modern society, with absolutely zero circuit breakers or fuses. Imagine running an economy without being able to divide wealth into uniform small amounts, dollars, cents, etc. In both cases, everything becomes all or nothing. This is what we have with computers, all or nothing. You have to trust software you run, or you simply can't run it. It's the same with the "License Agreement", nobody actually reads them, and nobody tries to enforce them, yet there they are. It's possible to have secure computing, we had it in the 1980s, but we didn't realize it. It was crude, but effective, because we had systems with no persistent internal storage, and we could write protect the storage we had. Thus it was possible to manage data, and the side effects allowed, in a simple, powerful way by simply not putting data at risk, making copies, and using those instead. Until we reverse the bad decisions of the 1970s, we're going to keep up the deranged behavior, blaming everything and everyone, and ignoring the one way out of this. You shouldn't ever have to trust a program you execute to behave in the manner you expect. Your computer should enforce the limits you expect, and the program should have zero ways around those limits. [1] https://csrc.nist.rip/publications/history/ande72.pdf https://csrc.nist.rip/publications/history/ande72.pdf [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security [3] https://web.archive.org/web/20120919111301/http://www.albany.edu/acc/courses/ia/classics/belllapadula1.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20120919111301/http://www.albany...
- Veserv 3y ago
- jjtheblunt 3y agoThe White House is a national security threat, according to polls of disgruntled americans, if Reuters and AP are accurate.
- helpfulclippy 3y agoCSRB's report on the Exchange Online breach that dropped a couple weeks ago was pretty damning. Microsoft had a situation where a threat actor had access to the entirety of Exchange Online, and possibly their entire cloud. CSRB describes the entire incident as completely avoidable, and resulting from Microsoft's inadequate security culture, and it calls Microsoft out for making public statements about the breach and its response that it knew to be inaccurate. The ONLY way that breach got detected was because the State department bought the premium package with extra logging that let them see when mailboxes get opened. It turned out, Microsoft had a signing key that could create access tokens for anything in their cloud, and it was stolen by Storm-0558. (More precisely, the key was only supposed to be useful for a portion of their services, but a bug allowed Storm-0558 to bypass that scope limitation.) And they used that to go read the e-mails of the State department and a bunch of other organizations, and private individuals. There was nothing customers could do to prevent the attack, and apparently no other indication in their logs that it was taking place, besides this category of entry that was gatekept behind a premium subscription package. Microsoft generated the key in 2016 and discontinued it years prior to the incident, but it was never revoked. Microsoft didn't even bother with key rotations anymore after 2021 because one time they fucked it up and it caused an outage, so they decided to just not do that anymore. Also, Microsoft apparently didn't have any means of detecting the obvious use of a zombie key. Also, Microsoft still doesn't really know how they got the key. They made a blog post about their theory, representing it as something they were highly confident in based on the evidence. After 6 months of pressure from the government, Microsoft finally updated the post to admit that they had no evidence of critical parts of what they claimed, and several key points in their narrative were factually incorrect. Then earlier this year, Microsoft got hacked AGAIN because they had an unused-but-active test account with a guessable password and no MFA, and it was authorized for access to e-mail boxes of (at a minimum) numerous members of Microsoft senior leadership. Microsoft has got serious problems. edit: I keep futzing with my phrasing. Those wanting a much better account should just read the report, since it has a great deal more nuance and information. https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/2024-04/CSRB_Review_of_the_Summer_2023_MEO_Intrusion_Final_508c.pdf https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/2024-04/CSRB_Review...
- quantified 3y ago
- eimrine 3y ago> Microsoft has a shocking level of control over IT within the US federal government Apple has same within US schools oll over the country and nobody even cares. Your government will change but your children will be with you for a while.
- wrycoder 3y agoHigh schools, at least, run on a giant pile of Chromebooks, not Mac hardware.
- michael_vo 3y agoI've been told by current military folks that they are forced to use outdated windows (the ones without security updates) on official military computers on base. So this is where they access emails, surf the web, and all of that. They had to use IE instead of the evergreen edge browser. It's well known among the people who serve that it's a joke.
- wrycoder 3y agoNot just on base. I had a conversation with a three star general. He remarked that while our warships had separate software and hardware for systems and fire control, the rest of of the ship’s IT ran on Windows. Supposedly, there was no connection between the two, but LOL.
- TecoAndJix 3y agoWhy LOL? These are separate systems/networks. Even warships need boring admin things like email, internet, identity management, etc. Plus the systems that go on these ships are heavily customized not just straight out of the box. Source: was IT on a destroyer
- xtracto 3y agoReminds me of Gary McKinnon, who "hacked" US military computers by using default passwords.... what difference does.it make to use newer OSes if ITops sucks?
- consumer451 3y agoTo be more accurate, the leadership of Microsoft's lack of prioritizing security, aka basic quality of product, is a national security threat. A similar claim could obviously be made of Boeing. Just imagine what is happening in their military contracts which we are not allowed to hear about. Looking at the projects which we are allowed to know about, airliners and Boeing's Starliner, clearly Boeing management needs to be put out to pasture. The core issue is cutting corners, for profit. This is not an issue which is easy to handle in our system. It seems that the best we can do is name and shame. Let's do that at least.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FredPret 3y agoIt’s amazing how much leverage MSFT is extracting from Excel. It’s the tiny brick supporting their entire skyscraper.
- hnburnsy 3y agoMaybe the NSA should help protect all Federal government systems. According to Wikipedia... >The NSA is also tasked with the protection of U.S. communications networks and information systems.
- Terr_ 3y agoHow I imagine conversations going in the NSA: "Hey guys, we should fix this vulnerability ASAP." "No can do, it has to wait and be stealth-patched indirectly, otherwise we'll lose the advantage of using it ourselves."
- btbuildem 3y agoWhile this brings to mind that scene [1] from Steve Carrel's "Space Force" show, you can't blame the scorpion for stinging you if you give him a ride on your back. The dependency on (pretty much) a single vendor across the entire military organization is such a monumental single point of failure, I can't imagine what level of obtuse bureaucracy led them there. It seems self-inflicted at best; if it wasn't MS it would've been some other corp. IMO the military (especially given their incredible size and access to resources) should have 100% rolled their own IT solutions from first principles, and built upon that. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zpCOYkdvTQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zpCOYkdvTQ
- faeriechangling 3y agoEven if you pretended Microsoft didn't exist, I don't really see how any similar alternative actually presents a secure alternative. There's a mess of vulnerabilities and complexity at every layer of any modern computing stack you can think of. If you ACTUALLY want security, you're going to be dealing with computers which are 100x slower than what we're used to with a tiny fraction of the features. For the most part I'm not convinced people actually want secure computer systems, they want computer systems which are productive and they'll just cope with the regular security breaches.
- hackernewds 3y agoDon't hear this much about Apple. And most of tech companies run on Apple devices.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI've been hearing about iOS exploits for eons, and exploits against Safari and iMessage specifically happen all the time. See: All the stuff the NSO group has done. Apple has also been getting hit by unpatchable hardware level vulnerabilities because quite simply their hardware is designed to be fast, not designed to be secure. I'm also not saying this based on people reporting vulnerabilities, I'm pointing out the software we're using is fundamentally impossible to secure on merit of its complexity and the tradeoffs people make that neglect security.
- advael 3y agoThe government relying on private contractors is a threat to national security Proprietary software is a threat to national security "Switching vendors" does nothing to solve the core problems here
- ripjaygn 3y agoThe US govt can also do a lot better. The very agency they formed to counter cyber threats and alert against(CISA) itself got hacked because they failed to patch or remediate, and led to a serious leak of sensitive chemical industry information among others. Because they failed to follow their own security advisory. And they won't even put out a report detailing the hack like MS did. > According to an early report on the breach, an anonymous source said that the compromised systems were the Infrastructure Protection (IP) Gateway, which houses critical information about the interdependency of U.S. infrastructure, and the Chemical Security Assessment Tool (CSAT), which houses private sector chemical security plans. > CSAT is an online portal that contains highly sensitive information that determines which facilities are considered high-risk under the Chemical Facility Anti-Terrorism Standards (CFATS). > CISA declined to confirm or deny which of their systems were taken offline. https://securityintelligence.com/news/cisa-hackers-key-systems-offline/ https://securityintelligence.com/news/cisa-hackers-key-syste... > In late February, CISA had already issued a warning that cyber threat actors are exploiting previously identified vulnerabilities in Ivanti Connect Secure and Ivanti Policy Secure gateways. Ivanti Connect Secure is a widely deployed SSL VPN, while Ivanti Policy Secure (IPS) is a network access control (NAC) solution. > Now, CISA itself has fallen victim to a cyberattack involving Ivanti products.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoI'd guess that, before the US ever does anything about its Microsoft Achilles heel, other countries will realize that they face even more threats from depending on Microsoft. (This applies to a number of reckless tech companies upon which countries and other companies create dependencies. But MS is one of the most concerning to me.)
- wolverine876 3y agoThe federal government is merely experiencing what everyone else does: The IT industry has very low standards: Look at the vast amount of fraud, theft, slander, cons, mis/disinformation, etc. on the Internet, not to mention consumers and small businesses getting run over by legal corporate behavior such as not providing customer service, locking accounts, holding money, holding data, surveillance and selling data, etc. It's been said before, but IT needs professional standards that provide actual, real-life security, privacy, etc., just like professional standards for building developers provide actual, safe buildings - imagine a fraud equivalent to cryptocurrency in building architecture and engineering; imagine an SBF. SBF was celebrated and still is by some. Lawyers have professional standards, doctors, accountants, scientists, engineers in most fields, ... the list goes on in every field of human endeavor but IT. And with standards comes liability. Microsoft shouldn't be able to just say, 'sorry about those hackers'.
- amai 3y agoIt is not only a security threat for the US. It is a world wide security threat, because it is used by so many governments. Somehow all antitrust agencies in the world seems to have forgotten that Microsoft has a monopoly in office IT.
- megan_ 3y agoI’ll be an ungrateful fellow to take your services for granted (geniusspyhack atgmail dot com) thank you for recovering my instagram and facebook accounts back great job!!! Y’all can text him for all hack/spy services